Traditional Publishing: What Editors Need to Know to Advise Their Clients

Sophie Playle

As a freelance fiction editor, you’ll inevitably find yourself answering questions about publishing. Some clients will be planning to self-publish; others will be hoping to secure a literary agent and a traditional publishing deal. Here’s what you need to know about that.

Updated 18 Nov 2026

You don’t need to be a publishing expert to help your clients navigate their options, but understanding how the different routes work will help you offer informed advice, manage expectations and recognise where your own services best fit with the author’s publishing goals.

This post is part of a mini-series on helping authors choose and prepare for a publishing route: traditional publishing, self-publishing and hybrid.

How does traditional publishing work?

Traditional publishing usually involves an author securing representation from a literary agent.

The benefits of an agent? They champion the author’s rights, fight for the most money for the author, and often know which publishers would be a best fit.

Crucially, many publishing houses do not consider manuscripts from unagented authors – thought some smaller and independent publishers do accept submissions directly from authors.

The traditional publishing process generally looks like this:

  • The author completes their manuscript. They revise it, seek feedback and make it as strong as they can.
  • The author approaches literary agents. They research agents who represent their genre and submit a query letter, synopsis and sample chapters.
  • An agent offers representation. If an agent is interested, they may discuss revisions before submitting the manuscript to publishers.
  • A publisher offers a deal. The agent helps the author negotiate the contract, including the advance, royalties and rights.
  • The manuscript enters the publisher’s editorial process. The author works with an acquiring editor on any revisions, followed by copy-editing and proofreading.
  • The book is produced and published. The publisher oversees cover design, typesetting, printing or ebook production, distribution and marketing.

The exact process varies between publishers, but the above is pretty standard.

Pros and cons of traditional publishing

Traditional publishing offers some significant advantages, but it’s not necessarily the right route for every author.

Pros:

  • No upfront publishing costs for the author.
  • Access to professional editorial, design and production teams.
  • Established distribution networks and potential access to physical bookshops.
  • Publisher support with marketing, publicity and sales. (Though many authors report this is quite limited …)
  • The credibility and validation that can come with a traditional publishing deal.

Cons:

  • Highly competitive, with no guarantee of securing an agent or publisher.
  • The process can be lengthy, with authors often waiting months or years.
  • Less creative control over aspects such as cover design, pricing and publication schedules.
  • Authors receive a much smaller share of each book sale than they do through self-publishing.
  • Publishers still expect authors to contribute significantly to their own marketing and promotion.

Does an author need editing before approaching agents?

Not necessarily. Authors need to submit a manuscript that’s as strong as they can reasonably make it, but that doesn’t mean they automatically need to pay for professional editing.

Developmental editing or a manuscript assessment can be valuable, but editors should assess what an individual manuscript really needs rather than automatically recommending a service.

I’ve explored this in more detail in Editing Before Querying.

What happens after a publisher acquires a manuscript?

Traditional publishers generally expect to acquire manuscripts that are already structurally sound. Although a commissioning editor may suggest revisions, substantial developmental editing isn’t usually part of what they do. They’re unlikely to take on a manuscript with fundamental problems with its plot, characters or structure.

The publisher’s editorial process is more likely to involve line-editing, copy-editing and proofreading, although the exact stages vary.

The publisher commissions and pays for the editorial and production work. The author is paid royalties (usually 5–25% of the profit of each sale, depending on the format of the book). They might also receive an advance on royalties.

Can authors move between traditional and self-publishing?

Yes. Publishing routes aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive, and there are two possibilities worth knowing about.

Trying traditional publishing before self-publishing

An author might spend time querying agents or submitting directly to publishers before deciding to self-publish if they don’t secure a deal.

This is a perfectly valid strategy – and it doesn’t mean failure. Publishers (and agents) are inundated with submissions, and this strategy allows authors to explore traditional publishing without abandoning their book if it doesn’t work out.

However, querying can take a long time, so authors should think about how long they’re prepared to pursue this route. If they subsequently decide to self-publish, they should withdraw any outstanding submissions before making the book publicly available.

Moving from self-publishing to traditional publishing

It might seem counterintuitive, but a book doesn’t necessarily have to begin its life with a traditional publisher to end up there.

Publishers increasingly acquire successful self-published books and authors who have already demonstrated a substantial readership. Some examples include:

  • The Martian by Andy Weir: Originally self-published as an ebook before being acquired by Crown Publishing. It went on to become an international bestseller and a major film.
  • Wool by Hugh Howey: Originally self-published, it was acquired by Simon & Schuster for print publication, while Howey retained control of his ebook editions.
  • Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea by Rebecca Thorne: Originally self-published, it was acquired by Bramble and traditionally reissued in 2024.
  • The Book of Azrael by Amber V. Nicole: Originally self-published, it was acquired by Kensington in 2025.

These deals take different forms. Sometimes publishers acquire the rights to an existing book; sometimes they sign an author for new work.

It’s still relatively unusual, and authors shouldn’t rely on it as a publishing strategy. However, it demonstrates that self-publishing doesn’t necessarily close the door on traditional publishing!

What does this mean for freelance editors?

There are two main opportunities to consider.

Working with authors: Some authors will approach you because they want to prepare their manuscript for submission to agents. Others may be considering their options after receiving rejections. Providing an assessment of their work and where it might fit in the publishing landscape can be a valuable service.

Working with publishers: Traditional publishers hire freelance copy-editors and proofreaders. If you’re interested in this route, working on professional relationships can help you access opportunities.

Further reading

Explore the other articles in this series:

You might also find Editing Before Querying useful.

Sophie Playleworked as a professional editor for 15 years, specialising in developmental editing and copy-editing fiction. Her favourite part of the job was working on imaginative speculative fiction with a literary slant, and reading manuscripts in the bath. She has been teaching editorial skills online for over a decade, and offers online courses and resources to help other editors run their businesses with confidence and skill. Find out more: liminalpages.com

Liminal Letters

The newsletter that shares lessons and reflections on the art and business of editing.

Course updates, special offers and honest opinions on the editing and publishing industry – plus insights into the life of a small business owner: how I juggle a toddler (not literally), limited hours and high ambitions while trying to cultivate meaningful work.