{"componentChunkName":"component---src-templates-blog-js","path":"/blog/category/line-and-copy-editing/page/2","result":{"data":{"page":{"yoast":{"title":"%%title%% – Insights from a professional fiction editor %%sep%% %%sitename%%","metadesc":"Articles to help authors improve their writing and get published. Insights into the publishing and editing industry (and advice for professional editors).","ogImage":null,"twitterImage":null},"title":"Blog"},"featuredPost":{"edges":[{"node":{"title":"The Earning Potential of Developmental Fiction Editors (in 2027)","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">How much do developmental fiction editors typically earn? What should you charge? Why do rates vary so much, and how you can aim for those higher ones?</p>\n<p>If you’re thinking about becoming a developmental fiction editor, or adding this service to your editorial business, or creating a side gig that turns your passion for storytelling into extra income, this post will help you figure out if it’s financially feasible for you. </p>\n<p>It covers: what editors are charging, why some charge far more than others, how to work out what you need to earn, and what you could realistically make.</p>\n<p>Not sure what developmental editing actually is? Read this post first: <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/what-is-developmental-editing\">What is Developmental Editing?</a></p>\n<h2>What developmental fiction editors are charging in the real world</h2>\n<p>These figures are based on publicly listed rates published by professional bodies, manuscript assessment agencies, a large freelance marketplace and established independent editors in the UK and US. They show what editors <em>charge</em>, not what they <em>earn</em>. </p>\n<p>Dollar figures have been converted to pounds at roughly £0.75 to the dollar, the mid-market rate when I checked at the time of writing (11 November 2026), and everything is rounded. Per-1,000-word figures are my own calculations from the published rates, and the novel-length examples assume 80,000 words.</p>\n<h3>Developmental editing</h3>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Per 1,000 words:</strong> Most editors charge around £20–27 ($27–36), though the full range runs from about £18 to £80 ($23–107).</li>\n<li><strong>Premium end:</strong> Established independent editors charge £60–80 ($80–107) per 1,000 words.</li>\n<li><strong>Per novel:</strong> An 80,000-word manuscript typically costs £1,600–2,200 ($2,100–2,900). At the premium end, it costs £4,800–6,400 ($6,400–8,500).</li>\n<li><strong>Hourly:</strong> Published rates run from about £34 to £53 ($45–70). The suggested UK minimum is £42.66 ($57).</li>\n</ul>\n<h3>Manuscript critique, appraisal and assessment</h3>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Flat fees:</strong> For a novel-length manuscript, the typical fee is £500–870 ($670–1,160), usually with a report of around 2,000–3,500 words.</li>\n<li><strong>Per 1,000 words:</strong> That works out at roughly £6–11 ($8–15). The marketplace average is higher at £19.50 ($26), or about £1,560 ($2,080) for an 80,000-word novel.</li>\n<li><strong>Premium end:</strong> Established independent editors charge around £30 ($40) per 1,000 words, or £2,400 ($3,200) for 80,000 words.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Here&#8217;s a simplified view:</p>\n<p><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table.png\" alt=\"Table comparing typical and premium rates for developmental editing and manuscript assessment, in pounds with US dollars in brackets. Typical rate per 1,000 words: developmental editing £20–27 ($27–36), manuscript assessment £6–11 ($8–15). Typical fee for an 80,000-word novel: £1,600–2,200 ($2,100–2,900) for developmental editing, £500–870 ($670–1,160) for assessment. Premium rate per 1,000 words: £60–80 ($80–107) for developmental editing, £30 ($40) for assessment. Premium fee for an 80,000-word novel: £4,800–6,400 ($6,400–8,500) for developmental editing, £2,400 ($3,200) for assessment. Hourly rate: £34–53 ($45–70) for developmental editing, with no figure given for assessment.\" width=\"2168\" height=\"725\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-2011\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table.png 2168w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-300x100.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-1024x342.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-768x257.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-1536x514.png 1536w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-2048x685.png 2048w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 2168px) 100vw, 2168px\" /></p>\n<p><em>I couldn&#8217;t reliably work out an hourly rate for manuscript assessments, as editors don’t publish one and the deliverables (such as report length and depth) vary. However, they typically take much less time than a full developmental edit.</em></p>\n<h2>Key factors affecting earnings</h2>\n<p>The rates above vary widely, with some editors charging two to four times the typical amount for the same service. I believe several factors explain the gap, and while some depend on an editor’s circumstances, others can be shaped over time.</p>\n<h3>Individual situation</h3>\n<p>Some factors depend on an editor’s own circumstances and the path they choose.</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Experience:</strong> As with all jobs, the more you do, the more you learn. Experienced editors can apply more honed, real-world knowledge to a project, which is value worth paying for, especially if their past clients have been successful.</li>\n<li><strong>Background:</strong> If an editor has a relevant skill or experience (such as time spent as a commissioning editor in a publishing house, or being a published author), this can give them a competitive edge.</li>\n<li><strong>Client source:</strong> Editors must decide for themselves whether they will thrive by working for a larger agency or through a marketplace, or whether they are better positioned to go it alone. With the former, they lose part of their fee to commission, but with the latter they must spend more time marketing. Successful editors know which works best for them.</li>\n</ul>\n<h3>What all editors can control</h3>\n<p>Other factors are within every editor’s control, whatever their background.</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Reputation:</strong> Not quite the same as experience, reputation is affected by client successes and their experience of the service and editor (were they good to work with &#8230;?), and authority and competency signals (such as awards, media appearances, memberships to reputable editorial societies, and more).</li>\n<li><strong>Brand positioning:</strong> This has a massive effect on earning potential. Editors who present themselves in a way that appeals to their ideal clients and demonstrates their individualism and professionalism stand out for all the right reasons.</li>\n<li><strong>Efficiency and boundaries:</strong> The quicker an editor works on a project with a set fee, the more they earn per hour. Similarly, editors who are clear on the project boundaries and do not allow for ‘scope creep’ operate with greater capacity.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Want to learn more about branding and building an editor website that converts? Take a look at this course: <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/the-visible-editor\">The Visible Editor</a>. </p>\n<h3>Where does training fit in?</h3>\n<p>Anyone can call themselves an editor and start trying to find paying clients. There are no regulating bodies or legal requirements like there are for lawyers or doctors.</p>\n<p>Some editors have enough background knowledge and transferable skills and experiences to become successful without formal training, but when you don’t have these things, <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/book-editing-courses\">editorial training</a> provides an essential foundation.</p>\n<p>Training won’t guarantee higher rates, but it can certainly help. It builds your skills, helps you work more efficiently, and gives you credentials that feed into your reputation.</p>\n<h3>Doing the sums</h3>\n<p>Earning potential isn’t only about what editors charge. Earning potential is just that: potential. You can’t just copy what another editor is doing because, as we’ve just seen, there are lots of factors that go into whether that editor can be successful charging that rate. </p>\n<p><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn.png\" alt=\"Venn diagram with three overlapping circles labelled ‘What you need to earn’, ‘Your capacity’ and ‘What your clients will pay’. The point where all three overlap is labelled ‘Your rates’.\" width=\"1024\" height=\"768\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-2012\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn-300x225.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn-768x576.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px\" /></p>\n<p>You also need to think about whether what you can earn from developmental editing matches what you personally need financially. Setting your rate is part of the puzzle, and there are a few things that come into play here.</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>What you need to earn:</strong> This depends on your circumstances and where you live. Remember that the fee isn’t what you keep. Tax and social contributions (which vary by country), business costs, unpaid time (holidays, sickness, marketing and admin) and exchange rates all reduce it.</li>\n<li><strong>Your capacity:</strong> This is how many projects you can realistically complete in a year, which depends on how quickly you work, how much time you spend on running the business and finding clients, and how much time you have available. (Raise your hand if you, too, can only work during school hours!)</li>\n<li><strong>What your clients will pay:</strong> The rates in the table above show what the market currently supports, from typical to premium. As you can see, these vary widely. A potential client is more than ‘someone who is looking for an editor’. There are loads of factors at play, but the bottom line is that you need to position yourself in a way that appeals to clients who are capable of hiring you.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Where these three things overlap, you have workable rates. </p>\n<p>Where they don’t, there are options: increase your capacity, build the reputation that supports higher rates, or add other income. </p>\n<p>In fact, many editors who offer developmental editing don’t rely on it alone. It’s usually one service among several, such as copy-editing or proofreading, and for some it’s a side business alongside other work.</p>\n<h2>What a developmental fiction editor could actually earn</h2>\n<p>Let’s look at some concrete examples. I’ve used the fees from the table for an 80,000-word novel here, and all figures are before tax, business costs and unpaid time. Developmental editing and manuscript assessment are two different services, so I’ve separated these out. </p>\n<p>Remember: rate, speed and the number of projects you can take on make the biggest difference, which is why many editors combine developmental editing with other services, work towards premium rates, or do it as a side income.</p>\n<h3>Developmental editing</h3>\n<p>Six typical edits a year would bring in about £9,600–13,200 ($12,800–17,600), a realistic side income or as part of a wider mix of services. One a month would gross about £19,200–26,400 ($25,600–35,200), and this is closer to a full-time workload. At premium rates, six edits a year would bring in £28,800–38,400 ($38,400–51,200).</p>\n<h3>Manuscript assessment</h3>\n<p>Assessments are priced much lower, so they take more projects to add up – but you can earn more per hour with assessments, and they take much less time overall. Ten a year at typical fees would bring in about £5,000–8,700 ($6,700–11,600), as a side income or as part of a wider suite of services, while ten at premium rates would bring in about £24,000 ($32,000) – much rarer, but not impossible.</p>\n<p><strong>Developmental editing can be a rewarding income, whether it’s a side gig or the heart of a full-time business. The editors who do best build their skills, reputation and business sense over time. If you’d like help laying those foundations, my self-paced <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/book-editing-courses\">developmental editing courses</a> at Liminal Pages are a good place to start.</strong></p>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/developmental-editing-fiction-theory/\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad.png\" alt=\"Banner advertising the online course ‘Developmental Editing: Fiction Theory’ for freelance editors, with a smiling woman holding an open orange book and a ‘Learn more’ button.\" width=\"1320\" height=\"500\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-2013\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad-300x114.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad-1024x388.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad-768x291.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /></a></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>How much do developmental fiction editors typically earn? What should you charge? Why do rates vary so much, and how you can aim for those higher ones? If you’re thinking about becoming a developmental fiction editor, or adding this service to your editorial business, or creating a side gig that turns your passion for storytelling [&hellip;]</p>\n","slug":"earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors-2027","date":"11th November 2026","categories":[{"name":"Freelancing","slug":"freelancing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7727272727272727,"src":"/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/2c512/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg","srcSet":"/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/7ede2/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 195w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/9f700/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 390w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/2c512/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 780w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/05233/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 1170w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/b24a9/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 780px) 100vw, 780px"}}}}}}]},"postCategories":{"edges":[{"node":{"wordpress_id":5,"name":"Developmental Editing","slug":"developmental-editing"}},{"node":{"wordpress_id":8,"name":"Freelancing","slug":"freelancing"}},{"node":{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}},{"node":{"wordpress_id":6,"name":"Publishing Landscape","slug":"publishing-landscape"}}]},"currentCategory":{"edges":[{"node":{"slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}}]},"form":{"wordpress_id":230,"acf":{"title":"Liminal Letters","subtitle":"The newsletter that shares lessons and reflections on the art and business of editing.","introduction":"<p>Course updates, special offers and honest opinions on the editing and publishing industry – plus insights into the life of a small business owner: how I juggle a toddler (not literally), limited hours and high ambitions while trying to cultivate meaningful work.</p>\n","cta_button_text":"Sign up","note":"I will never share or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time. Form not working? Go here: https://liminal-letters.subscribepage.io","mailchimp_url":"liminalpages.us6.list-manage.com","mailchimp_user_id":"5eae0b68be96658ab68947d28","mailchimp_list_id":"5cdff76c1a","mailerlite_user_id":"1255214","mailerlite_form_id":"142431918007256385","success_message":"Thanks for signing up to Liminal Letters. Check your inbox to confirm your subscription. Thanks!","generic_error_message":"Uh-oh. There was a problem signing you up to the mailing list. Please try again later.","already_subscribed_error_message":"You are already subscribed to Liminal Letters. No need to sign up again!","background_image":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":2.6666666666666665,"src":"/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/f422e/newsletter-form-background.jpg","srcSet":"/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/e75b5/newsletter-form-background.jpg 160w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/c01e2/newsletter-form-background.jpg 320w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/f422e/newsletter-form-background.jpg 640w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/a6352/newsletter-form-background.jpg 960w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/ec6c5/newsletter-form-background.jpg 1280w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/7019e/newsletter-form-background.jpg 1870w","sizes":"(max-width: 640px) 100vw, 640px"}}}}}}},"pageContext":{"id":15,"category":4,"filtered":true,"nodes":[{"node":{"title":"5 Comma Rules You Can Sometimes Break","slug":"5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">Commas. They look so insignificant and innocent, but in reality they’re tricky little monsters that can have a big impact on a piece of writing.</p>\n<p>When I was a professional editor, sorting out commas was one of my main tasks. No matter how good the writing, there are <em>always </em>comma issues that need correcting.</p>\n<p>But wait, don’t you just put a comma where you need to pause in a sentence? Hell to the no. That’s not how commas work at all.</p>\n<p>Saying that you put a comma in a sentence whenever you want to create a pause is an oversimplified attempt to summarise several more complicated comma rules.</p>\n<p>It’s true that a comma <em>does </em>create a pause in a sentence, but reverse-engineering this idea doesn’t help you use commas correctly.</p>\n<p><strong>As well as creating pauses in a sentence, commas are used to separate sentence elements.</strong></p>\n<p>Visually separating ideas, items, actions and phrases with commas makes sentences easier to understand.</p>\n<p>In a nutshell, the two main uses of the humble comma are:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>to create rhythm (by indicating a pause)</li>\n<li>to clarify meaning (by separating elements)</li>\n</ul>\n<p>You may have an intuitive understanding of comma usage based on these two ideas. But yes, there are rules when it comes to using commas. Quite a few of them, unfortunately. However, as all good writers and editors know, rules are made to be broken!</p>\n<p>That’s no excuse to throw commas around like confetti or avoid them altogether, though. (<em>Oh, the horror.</em>) Grammar and punctuation rules should only be broken when you know why you’re breaking them – in other words, when you’re aware of the effect you’re creating by doing so.</p>\n<p><strong>Which means you need to know what the rules <em>are</em> before you break them.</strong></p>\n<p>I know. Learning comma placement rules? Fun times.</p>\n<p>It’s because of rule-breakery-creativity (that’s a technical term) that comma usage can be highly subjective. So let’s look at five comma placement rules and how they can be broken – so you don&#8217;t end up over-correcting your client&#8217;s writing.</p>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/coffee-and-clauses-the-art-of-line-and-copy-editing-fiction\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-1907\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"500\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-300x114.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-1024x388.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-768x291.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /></a></p>\n<h2>1. The serial comma</h2>\n<p>Okay, so this one isn’t strictly a rule, but it’s worth mentioning. The serial comma (also known as the Oxford comma or listing comma) is the final comma before ‘and’ in a list of three or more items, e.g. Sophie ate a pie, two cookies, and a square of chocolate.</p>\n<p>Whether you want to use a serial comma is completely up to the writer. It’s a stylistic choice – not a rule that needs to be followed. In general, authors should try to be consistent with their usage.</p>\n<p>However, clarity trumps consistency, so as the editor, may decide to ‘break’ the rule imposed if the sentence needs it. And both the omission or inclusion of a serial comma can create confusion! For example:</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><em>We partied with the burlesque dancers, Rick Grimes and Daryl Dixon.</em><br />\nEven though that sounds like a lot of flamboyant fun to me, the serial comma would remove the implication that Rick and Daryl are burlesque dancers.</li>\n<li><em>We partied with the burlesque dancer, Rick Grimes, and Daryl Dixon.</em><br />\nThe serial comma here could be mistaken for the second comma in a pair of commas offsetting the name of the burlesque dancer … which means Rick here could be the burlesque dancer.</li>\n</ul>\n<p><strong>Lesson:</strong> Check whether the author prefers to use the serial comma or not, then make usage consistent – but allow exceptions to the ‘rule’ for clarity.</p>\n<h2>2. A comma should be used to separate compound sentences</h2>\n<p>The rule is that you should use a comma to separate two sentences joined by a coordinating conjunction (<em>for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so</em> – remember these by the fact the first letter of each spells FANBOYS).</p>\n<p>Here are some examples:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>Sophie wanted cake, but she also wanted cookies.</li>\n<li>Sophie didn’t want to leave the party, nor did she want Rick to change out of his fabulous burlesque costume.</li>\n<li>Everyone at the party was having fun, and even Daryl didn’t want to leave.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>However, omitting these commas doesn’t often create much confusion. In shorter sentence (like the first example in the list above), it’s considered totally fine to omit the comma.</p>\n<p>How short should a sentence be before you omit the comma? There are no standard guidelines. Some people like to give themselves a rule, such as if the sentence is fewer than a certain number of words.</p>\n<p>I recommend using the comma in longer sentences (like in the last two in the list above), but if the author is attemping to create a faster-paced or more breathless sentence, the comma can be omitted.</p>\n<p><strong>Lesson:</strong> Include a comma between two sentences joined by a coordinating conjunction, but don’t sweat it too much if the sentence is short or if the author is playing with the rhythm of the sentence, as long as the meaning is still clear.</p>\n<h2>3. Use commas to offset non-restrictive phrases</h2>\n<p>A non-restrictive phrase is simply a part of a sentence that adds extra meaning but when removed, the sentence still makes sense. It’s easier to explain with examples:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>Lena, who was intolerant to gluten, didn’t eat any cookies.</li>\n<li>Throwing a party, though lots of fun, is very tiring.</li>\n<li>James, who doesn’t drink alcohol, brought some lemonade to the party, and, after introducing himself to the host, he poured himself a glass.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>That last sentence contains five commas, all of which are correctly placed; there are two pairs of commas offsetting non-restrictive phrases (‘who doesn’t drink alcohol’ and ‘after introducing himself to the host’) and one comma before a coordinating conjunction that links two sentences (‘James brought some lemonade, <em>and </em>he poured himself a glass’).</p>\n<p>But it feels like a bit of comma overkill, right? The <em>rhythm </em>of the sentence becomes quite staccato because of all the commas, so I would recommend removing some to create a better flow. However, commas should only be removed if by doing so doesn’t make the sentence difficult to understand.</p>\n<p>In my opinion, I think the following sentence is clear enough in meaning and reduction of commas creates a better flow:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>James, who doesn’t drink alcohol, brought some lemonade to the party, and after introducing himself to the host he poured himself a glass.</li>\n</ul>\n<p><strong>Lesson: </strong>More often than not you should offset non-restrictive phrases with commas, but if the sentence feels too choppy, delete commas that don’t make the sentence confusing to read. Remember, commas offsetting non-restrictive phrases in the middle of sentence <em>must come in pairs, </em>so you can’t delete one comma and keep the other – it’s both or none.</p>\n<h2>4. Use a comma after an introductory word, phrase or subordinate clause</h2>\n<p>A subordinate clause (also known as a dependent clause) is a part of a sentence that doesn’t make sense standing on its own. When a word, phrase or subordinate clause is used at the beginning of a sentence, you need a comma to offset it from the main (independent) clause.</p>\n<ul>\n<li>After the party, everyone went home to bed.</li>\n<li>As I climbed into bed, I started to feel very sleepy.</li>\n<li>Suddenly, I remembered I’d left the stove on.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Can you omit these commas? Again, it comes down to clarity and rhythm. It’s more acceptable to drop the comma after a single introductory word than it is for a whole introductory phrase or clause.</p>\n<p>There is an exception to this flexibility, though, and that’s when the introduction is a <em>participle phrase </em>describing the subject of the sentence. A participle phrase is a phrase that tells us something about the noun it’s modifying that starts with a participle (a word formed from a verb that can be used as an adjective).</p>\n<p>Yeah, it’s pretty difficult to explain – examples help!</p>\n<ul>\n<li><em>Searching the kitchen cupboards</em>, Sophie looked for hidden chocolate.</li>\n<li><em>Frightened by a car backfiring, </em>the cat ran under the couch.</li>\n<li><em>Wondering where the cat had gone, </em>Sophie gave up looking for chocolate.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Omitting these commas can create confusion and is considered grammatically incorrect, so this is a rule that shouldn’t usually be broken.</p>\n<p><strong>Lesson: </strong>It’s normally okay to omit a comma that separates an introductory phrase or subordinate clause if the meaning is still clear; it’s even more acceptable to drop the comma after a single introductory word. However, you shouldn’t omit the comma before an introductory participle phrase, otherwise the grammar police will come knocking.</p>\n<h2>5. Use commas to offset ‘yes’ and ‘no’, direct address, interjections and questions</h2>\n<p>You might think you can’t argue with this comma usage, but … I’m here to tell you that you can – at least for some of these structures. Usually, I’m all for this type of comma. And for the most part, it makes sense to follow this rule.</p>\n<ul>\n<li>Yes, I do enjoy chocolate cake.</li>\n<li>No, I won’t eat it all.</li>\n<li>Oh, I didn’t realise it was your birthday.</li>\n<li>George, would you like a slice of cake?</li>\n<li>He’ll save some for me, won’t he?</li>\n<li>Anyway, Sophie, I thought you were on a diet?</li>\n</ul>\n<p>However, an author might decide to omit the comma offsetting ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to create the effect of a lack of pause. Perhaps a character is snapping something at another. (‘No of course I didn’t eat all the cake!’) Or perhaps an accumulation of these commas creates clutter and negatively affects the rhythm. For example:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>Oh, yes, George, why I would like a slice of cake.</li>\n<li>Oh yes, George, why I would like a slice of cake.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>The second sentence reads better, don’t you think?</p>\n<p>I wouldn’t advise omitting commas when they’re used to offset a question or an interjection in the middle of a sentence – the sentences will probably lack clarity (and possibly sense) without them.</p>\n<p><strong>Lesson: </strong> These commas can be omitted when an accumulation of them looks clunky and if the clarity or sense of the sentence isn’t affected.</p>\n<p>And there you have it. Five comma rules you (or your client) can break for effect. The important thing is making sure you know why the rule is being broken, and how this is creating the intended effect.</p>\n<p>Remember: commas are our friends. They might be frustrating little monsters most of the time, but without them our writing would lack meaning and rhythm. Keep this at the forefront of your mind, and use it to guide your decisions on where to place or omit them.</p>\n<p><strong>Want to learn more about becoming a professional sentence-level editor? Take a look at my <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/\">online courses</a>.</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>Commas. They look so insignificant and innocent, but in reality they’re tricky little monsters that can have a big impact on a piece of writing. When I was a professional editor, sorting out commas was one of my main tasks. No matter how good the writing, there are always comma issues that need correcting. But [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"28th February 2017","wordpress_id":365,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M9%202l3%2017c1%2017%201%2018-5%2018l-4%202c-2%201-2%208%200%2010%201%201%201%201-1%203s-2%202%200%202c3%201%203%202%200%205-2%202-3%205-1%2010v9c2%201%202%206%200%207l-1%2027c0%2019%200%2027%201%2026%201-2%204-3%204-1h6c3-2%2010-2%209-1l32-4a945%20945%200%200155-9%204184%204184%200%200150-10c-3%200-6-3-4-4s1-2-4-3l-5%201%201%202%204%202c3%203%202%204-2%201l-4-2-5-3-5-3c-2%200-10-6-10-9-1-3-1-3%203-4%202%200%203%201%203%202l1%202h1l1-2v3c-1%202%200%206%201%206s2-1%201-3c0-2%200-2%202-2h3l3%201c4%200%208%204%206%205v1c7%201%2012%202%2014%205%203%202%209%204%2013%203s3-3-4-6a136%20136%200%2001-17-10l-5-2c-3-1-5-2-6-1l-2-1-2-2-6-2-5-3-3-2-4-3-3-1c-2-2-10-7-12-7-3%200-3%200-3-8l-1-8c-2-1-3%202-2%205%201%206-2%2014-5%2013l-1%201-1%202%201%202%201-2%201-2c1%201%200%206-1%2010l-3%2014-2%2012%201-17c1-18%201-21-2-18-2%201-2%201-4-1-3-4-5-5-10-6-4-1-4-1-2-2l9-2c6-1%207-2%208-5%201-2%201-2%202%200%202%204%204%202%205-3%205-18%207-45%204-53l-1-4H77C55%200%2054%200%2054%202v4l-1%202-1-2-1-4c1-2%200-2-3-2h-5l1%205c3%2014%203%2039%201%2034l-1-3-2-1c-3%200-5-5-5-14L36%207V0H9v2m105%209a421%20421%200%20002%2043c1%2014%201%2016%203%2016l1-12-2-27c0-27-1-31-3-31s-2%201-1%2011m33-2a2264%202264%200%20000%2037l-1%202-1%206v13l1-2h2l9%203%208%202c1%201%201%200%202-1%201-4%201-4-2-7s-4-7-5-40c0-20%200-22-2-22s-2%202-1%2024l-1%2024c-1%200-2-8-3-31V0h-7l1%209m205-1l-1%2020v13l3%201c5%202%200%202-6%200l-8-2c-2%200-3-1-3-3-1-3-5-4-6-2s-15-1-23-4c-4-1-7%200-10%203l-2%204-2%205-1%204c1%202%2012%206%2028%2010%2017%204%2028%208%2026%209l-16-4c-18-6-24-7-17-4l5%202%205%201c5%203%200%202-13-2-13-5-20-6-24-6-3%200-3%200-2-2%201-3%200-4-2-4l-4-2c-5-3-8-4-8-3%201%202%200%202-1%202-3%200-5-2-3-3%202%200-2-3-4-3-4%200-7%202-6%203l1%201h2l1%201c2-1%203%201%202%204-1%202-2%202-5%202-3-1-4-1-2%202l6%201%207%201%208%202c13%202%2014%202%2014%201%200-2%205%200%207%202v1c-3%200-2%203%202%205%205%202%2020%204%2020%202l1-1v1l2%202c2%200%201%203-1%203l-3%203-1%204-14-1c-11%200-34-2-53-5-8-1%204%204%2015%206l7%202h-13c-21%200-20-1-20%204%200%202%200%203%202%203l8%203c6%203%206%203-6%201h-4v4c0%2011-4%2025-12%2037l-5%2010-1%202c-3%201-7%207-6%208l-1%201c-2%200-10%208-8%208l-1%201-7%205-3%203h6l-6%202h-4c-2%202-2%202%200%203v2l-1%202h1c1-1%201-1%201%201v1h1l3%203c2%200%203%201%202%202l1%202%204%202c3%203%200%202-10-5-9-6-10-6-13-5-3%202-3%203%201%203%203%200%2013%208%2010%208-1%200-2%200-1%201l-2%201h-3l-1%201-2-1-7-4%2015%2013%206%205a3782%203782%200%2000-40-29l5%203c6%203%206%202%201-1-5-4-6-8-1-12l2-2-3-1-3-2c1-2%208-2%2010-1%202%202%206-1%206-4-1-1%200-1%201-1%202%200%206-2%2010-6%201-1%201-1-2-1l-3-1%204-1c3%201%204%200%207-3%204-3%206-7%203-4h-4c-3-1-1-2%203-2%206%201%2017-18%2020-35l1-3h-14v26l-2%201-5%201v-4l3-1-3-1c-3%200-5%202-4%205s4%205%207%203l2-1-1%202c-2%200-2%200-1%201%203%202-2%205-8%205-5%200-5%200-4%202%202%203-1%206-6%206-3%200-3%200-2%201s1%202-1%203v3c2%200%201%202-2%202-3%201-5%200-5-1h3l2-1-6-1c-5%200-5%200-4%201%204%204%201%206-9%208-6%200-6%201-1%205l4%203h-4l-6-2c-6-4-6-4-6%202v6l7%205a165%20165%200%200118%2015h-1c-2-2-4-1-5%201l-1%203h1c1%200%202%200%201%201-2%200-1%202%201%202s2%202%201%205c-1%202%201%209%204%209%202%201%206%208%204%208l-1%201c0%202%2013%201%2013%200h1a2334%202334%200%2000149-1c-1%200-5-4-5-6l-3-7a1048%201048%200%2001-8-10c-2%200-2%200-1-1%202-1%202-1-1-1-7-2-1-5%2017-9%2012-2%2016-3%2016-1v1l1%201c0%203%204%2010%207%2012%202%201%203%205%201%205l-2%205-3%204-3%202-3%203-4%203%2029%201h30l-1-44V0h-48v8m-48%2030c-3%200-7%205-5%206l6%201%205%202%202%201%204%202%204%201a144%20144%200%200128%208%20458%20458%200%20019%201c-6-2-7-2-7-6l1-3%201-1h-1l-1-1-15-4-5-1-24-7-2%201M13%2053c-6%200-7%200-7%203-1%204%200%204%2011%203h10v-4c0-3%200-3-3-3l-11%201m1%2023l-4%201c-3%200-3%200-3%202l1%203%208%201c8%200%209%200%208-1l2-4c1-2%201-2-2-2H14m0%2073c0%204%201%206%203%208l1%203-10-2H1v24c0%2020%200%2024%202%2025v2l-1%201h2l2%201v1l3%202%2010%207%207%205h40l40-1-5-5a1120%201120%200%2001-51-45%20390%20390%200%2001-28-24l-5-4-4-3%201%205'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/c9d11197038614fe9ade4c4995268a08/f7fa3/5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break.jpg","srcSet":"/static/c9d11197038614fe9ade4c4995268a08/c96d8/5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break.jpg 116w,\n/static/c9d11197038614fe9ade4c4995268a08/12243/5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break.jpg 232w,\n/static/c9d11197038614fe9ade4c4995268a08/f7fa3/5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break.jpg 463w,\n/static/c9d11197038614fe9ade4c4995268a08/ce8db/5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break.jpg 695w,\n/static/c9d11197038614fe9ade4c4995268a08/87cea/5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break.jpg 926w,\n/static/c9d11197038614fe9ade4c4995268a08/b24a9/5-comma-rules-you-can-sometimes-break.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"How to Use Track Changes","slug":"how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">Most editors will edit a manuscript using Word’s nifty Track Changes feature. This allows authors to see exactly what edits have been made to their work and gives them the power to reject or accept the changes.</p>\n<p><strong>Updated May 2024</strong></p>\n<p>However, if you’ve not used Track Changes before, you might feel a little overwhelmed by it!</p>\n<p>Don’t worry. It&#8217;s not as complicated as it first seems.</p>\n<h2>What are tracked changes?</h2>\n<p>Okay, let’s start with the basics.</p>\n<p>Track Changes is a feature in Microsoft Word that allows you to keep track of the changes you make to a document – or, in other words, the edits you make to a manuscript.</p>\n<p>Each change can be either &#8216;accepted&#8217; or &#8216;rejected&#8217;. When a tracked change is <strong>accepted</strong>, the edit is assimilated into the document. If it is <strong>rejected</strong>, the text reverts back to how it was originally.</p>\n<p>The author gets to decide which changes they accept based on whether they agree with your edits.</p>\n<h2>How to turn the Track Changes feature on/off</h2>\n<p>It’s possible that you and your client may not be using the same version of Word. If this is the case, the aesthetics of the feature will be slightly different. However, once you’ve found Track Changes in the menu, it works in pretty much the same way in all versions.</p>\n<p>For most versions of Word, you simply need to go to the <strong>Review tab</strong> to find Track Changes.</p>\n<p>Click the button and the feature will be switched on!</p>\n<p>In this guide, I’ll be using Microsoft 365 Word for Mac.</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1343\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1343\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"wp-image-1343 size-full\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges1.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"286\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges1.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges1-300x65.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges1-768x166.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges1-1024x222.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1343\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Step 1: Go to the Review tab.</figcaption></figure>\n<p>&nbsp;</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1344\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1344\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"wp-image-1344 size-full\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges2.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"286\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges2.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges2-300x65.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges2-768x166.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges2-1024x222.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1344\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Step 2: Click on the &#8216;Tracking&#8217; button to see the options.</figcaption></figure>\n<p>&nbsp;</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1345\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1345\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1345\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges3.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"286\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges3.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges3-300x65.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges3-768x166.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges3-1024x222.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1345\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Step 3: Here, you can toggle Track Changes on/off.</figcaption></figure>\n<h2>What tracked changes look like</h2>\n<p>When you add text to the document, the new text will appear in a different colour and will be underlined. The colour of the insertions will depend on your settings, which are local to your computer. On my computer, I’ve kept the default red.</p>\n<p>When you delete text from the document, either the text will be moved to the side of the document  or it will appear crossed out in the body of the text. How it appears to you will depend on your default or customised settings, local to your computer. On my computer, the deleted text is pulled to the side.</p>\n<p>You’ll see a thin vertical line on the left of the text whenever a change has been made. This is a useful feature because sometimes it’s easy to miss small changes in the text, such as a deleted comma.</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1346\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1346\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1346\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges4.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"808\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges4.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges4-300x184.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges4-768x470.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges4-1024x627.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1346\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">A document edited with Track Changes will look something like this.</figcaption></figure>\n<p>Notice in the example above that when text is inserted, it appears in red. Notice, too, that when text is deleted, it’s pulled out to left-hand side of the document; a thin red line connects the balloon to where the text has been deleted from.</p>\n<p>With both inserts and deletions, a thin vertical line appears down the right-hand side of the document to signify that a change has been made on a particular line.</p>\n<p>In some places it appears that both an insertion and a deletion has taken place – for example, when changing &#8216;pours&#8217; to &#8216;pores&#8217; the original word is <em>deleted </em>and the new word is <em>inserted, </em>so you can see both a red insertion and that text has been deleted from the same place.</p>\n<p>You can also see my name above every change. If more than one person works on a document with Track Changes turned on, this means you can see who had done what to the document.</p>\n<p>Though I don&#8217;t show it here, text that has been moved from one place to another will show up in a different colour. On my computer, moved text appears in green.</p>\n<h2>How to accept or reject a tracked change</h2>\n<p>There are a few ways to do this, all of them nice and simple.</p>\n<p>As the editor, you might want to &#8216;accept&#8217; a change you meant to make &#8216;silently&#8217; (i.e. without Track Changes being switched on) or you might want to &#8216;reject&#8217; an edit you&#8217;ve changed your mind about.</p>\n<p>You&#8217;ll also need to know how to advise your author clients how to accept and reject changes.</p>\n<p>You can accept or reject an individual change by right clicking on the change (either the red inserted text or the deleted text at the side of the document) and selecting either Accept Change or Reject Change.</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1347\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1347\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1347\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges6.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"308\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges6.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges6-300x70.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges6-768x179.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges6-1024x239.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1347\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Right clicking a change brings up the options of accepting or rejecting the change.</figcaption></figure>\n<p>Alternatively, you can navigate through the tracked changes using the Previous and Next buttons under the Review tab and use the Accept or Reject buttons. When you use the Accept or Reject buttons, you’ll automatically be taken to the next change to review.</p>\n<p>You also have the option of accepting or rejecting <em>all </em>the changes in a document in one fell swoop. You can do this by clicking on the little arrow next to the Accept or Reject buttons and then selecting Accept/Reject All Changes in Document. Be careful, as this could be irreversible!</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1348\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1348\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1348\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges5.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"266\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges5.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges5-300x60.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges5-768x155.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges5-1024x206.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1348\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Be careful – accepting or rejecting all changes can be irreversible!</figcaption></figure>\n<h2>Understanding the Comments feature</h2>\n<p>An important part of the Review tab is the Comments feature, which is often used at the same time as Track Changes. If you want to comment on the text, simply highlight it with your cursor and click <strong>New Comment</strong>. (It might be slightly different for different versions of Word.)</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1349\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1349\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1349\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges7.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"288\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges7.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges7-300x65.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges7-768x168.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges7-1024x223.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1349\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Click &#8216;New Comment&#8217; to &#8230; add a new comment!</figcaption></figure>\n<p>A comment balloon will appear in the right-hand margin of the document – where any tracked changes appear, too – and you can write your comment here.</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1350\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1350\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1350\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges8.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"252\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges8.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges8-300x57.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges8-768x147.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges8-1024x195.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1350\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Text that&#8217;s been commented on will appear highlighted (here in pink) and the associated comment will be visible to the right of the document.</figcaption></figure>\n<p>Use the Comments feature to:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>offer short explanations of your edits</li>\n<li>request the author to check that their intended meaning has been retained</li>\n<li>leave a query for the author that requires their input or</li>\n<li>add a note of praise.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>You might want the author to reply to some of your comments. They can respond directly in the manuscript by inserting another comment.</p>\n<p>To do this, they need to click on the original comment, and then click on the <strong>New Comment</strong> button to create a new comment directly below the original. Their comment boxes may appear in a different colour and, depending on their settings, contain their name, too.</p>\n<h2>Understanding and using different document views</h2>\n<p>Word displays tracked changes by default once the feature is activated, but you can change how you view a document that contains tracked changes.</p>\n<p>Under the Review tab, you’ll see a drop down menu that says <strong>All Markup </strong>(the default on my computer). If you click it, you’ll see you have some more options: Simple Mark-up, No Markup, and Original – all quite self-explanatory.</p>\n<figure id=\"attachment_1351\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-1351\" style=\"width: 1320px\" class=\"wp-caption alignnone\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"size-full wp-image-1351\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges9.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"244\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges9.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges9-300x55.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges9-768x142.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TrackChanges9-1024x189.png 1024w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /><figcaption id=\"caption-attachment-1351\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">You can choose your document view from the dropdown menu when clicking here.</figcaption></figure>\n<p><strong>Important: Changing a document’s view on your computer <em>does not</em> change how someone else sees the document on their computer.</strong></p>\n<p>If you select No Markup without having accepted or rejected the tracked changes and deleting any comments, the file will still retain all of the tracked changes and comments, even though you can’t see them. All the tracked changes and comments will reappear as soon as you reopen the file on your computer or when someone else opens it afresh on their computer.</p>\n<p>Changing your document view might be useful if you want to see <em>only </em>comments or <em>only </em>tracked changes, for example, but I recommend you provide your client with documents containing various views so they don’t have to fiddle around with this setting!</p>\n<h2>Recommended method: three file types</h2>\n<p>When you return an edited manuscript to an author, I recommend providing three separate files:</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Full Edit</strong> – The first file contains all the edits made visible through the Track Changes feature so the author can see <em>exactly </em>what’s been done.</li>\n<li><strong>Comments Only</strong> – The second file has all the edits assimilated into the text, but the comments are still visible so the author can easily find and address any issues.</li>\n<li><strong>Clean</strong> – The third file has all the edits assimilated into the text and all the comments deleted so the author can easily see a ‘clean’ version of the edited manuscript.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Not all editors work this way, and that&#8217;s fine.</p>\n<p>But I believe this is the most useful method. It enables the author to have access to both the edits and the edited manuscript without having to know too much about the technical know-how of using Track Changes.</p>\n<h2>How authors should review their edited manuscript</h2>\n<p>So now you&#8217;ve conducted your edit using the Track Changes and Comments features of Word. If you hand these files to your client with no instruction, they might be very confused about what to do (and even too embaressed to ask you), so it&#8217;s always worth drafting some instructions to send along to your client.</p>\n<p>Here&#8217;s what I recommend.</p>\n<p><strong>There are two ways an author might decide to review their edited manuscript:</strong></p>\n<ol class=\"separated-list\">\n<li>Look at every tracked change individually and decide whether to accept or reject it while addressing any comments and deleting the comment balloons as they go.</li>\n<li>In the manuscript file that has all the changes accepted with just the comments remaining (see method above), the author should address any issues raised in the comments, deleting the comment balloons as they go. After that, they should read through the manuscript carefully. If they spot anything odd or something doesn’t seem right, they should crosscheck it with the fully marked-up file and change their current version to how they want it to be.</li>\n</ol>\n<p><strong>Generally, I recommend the second method because it’s less overwhelming.</strong></p>\n<p>If there have been a lot of changes made to a manuscript (for example, if sentences have often been recast for better flow or a recurring grammar issue has been corrected), I <em>highly recommend </em>the author follows the second method.</p>\n<p>Sometimes, too, when there’s too much markup or too many comments to fit along the right-hand side of the page, a little ellipsis (…) will appear next to some balloons to show that there’s more information, just not enough room to show it.</p>\n<p>You can click on the ellipsis to see the rest of the balloon text, which will appear in a new separate reviewing panel. Really, an author only wants to be dealing with this if absolutely necessary because it’s such a pain (and will slow down their computer), so following method two above really can make it easier!</p>\n<p>If you decide to provide the client with just the one document to work with, I recommend suggesting the author make a copy before they start accepting or rejecting changes – just incase something goes wrong. So that they’re left with a clean final draft, they should make sure they’re viewing No Markup, all changes have been accepted or rejected, and all comment balloons have been deleted. Voila, they have their final draft.</p>\n<p><strong>I hope that’s helped!</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>Most editors will edit a manuscript using Word’s nifty Track Changes feature. This allows authors to see exactly what edits have been made to their work and gives them the power to reject or accept the changes. Updated May 2024 However, if you’ve not used Track Changes before, you might feel a little overwhelmed by [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"26th January 2016","wordpress_id":174,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M0%20113v113h141v-2c0-2%201-3%202-3l1-1%201-1v3c0%202%202%205%203%203v-2l-1-7-1-8%201-2%202%202c0%201%202%203%204%203%203%202%204%203%204%206%200%202%201%202%202%202%204%200%202%204-2%204-2%201-2%201%201%201l4%201%207%201h8l-1-3c0-4%201-4%202%200l1%203h18a3285%203285%200%2000-22-72l5%201c5%200%208%201%2010%204l7%2010%204%205%203%204c-1%201%200%201%202%201%206%200%204%202-4%203h-7l1%204c0%205%201%205%203%205s2%200%201%201c-3%201%200%2010%203%209%202%200%203%202%201%202-2%201-2%201%200%205l1%204h7a142%20142%200%20009-1l2%206c2%205%202%205%200%206l-2%202%2090%201h90V113l-1-87-1%2026-8%2026-10%2028v3h4l9-1c3%200%204%200%205-2s1%206%201%2021v24l-10%201a1032%201032%200%2000-85%2013h-11l-19%202c-16%200-19-1-30-11l-10-10-2-4-1-5c1-1-3-2-5%200l-3-1c-6-2-9%201-5%206%202%203%202%206%201%208%200%202-8-6-9-10-1-2-5-4-7-3l-6-1-5-1h-2l-1%201c-3%200%203-15%208-20l1-4c-1%200-3%201-5%204-3%204-4%203%200-2s3-7-3-2l-3%202%202-3%202-2%201-3%203-2-3%201-2-1c1-2-1-1-2%200l-2%201-1%201c-2%203-3%201-3-5%200-7%200-8%204-8l2-1v-1c2%200%202-1%202-6v-7l1%201%201-5c0-4%201-6%202-6l1-2c0-3-4-3-4%201-1%201-1-1-1-4%200-5%200-7%201-6l1%202v3l1-6v-7c-1-1-1%200-1%203v5l-1-4V41l-1-7-1-5-1-5-1%201-1%201-2%202c-1%201-1%200-1-1%200-3%200-3-1-2-2%202-3%201-3-1l-1-3c-2%200-2-1-2-5l-1-6c-1-1-2-3-2-8%200-2-1-2-3-2h-3a484%20484%200%2000-3%2030v5l-2-3-2-11c0-14-2-21-5-21s-3%200%200%2011c4%2018%204%2018%203%2022-2%204-2%204-4-2-1-5-2-7-8-12l-7-6-4-3c-2-2-3-3-4-2h-2l-1-2-2-1c-1-1-2-2-3-1-1%200-2%200-1-2l-1-2-1%202h-1c-2-2-6-2-61-2H0v113M323%2010a222%20222%200%2001-10%2049c-3%2011-4%2013-5%2012s-2%200-3%201c-2%202-3%201-4-3l-3-4c-2%200-3-2-3-4-1-3-3-5-4-4l-1-2c-1-2-4-1-4%201l-1%204-1-2c0-2-2-3-4-3l-1%205c-1%204-2%205-5%202-2-1-2-1-2%201v3l-1%206%201%204%201%204c1%200%202%203%202%207l4%209%201%205%204%2011c4%207%207%208%207%203l2-6v-4c-1-2%201-11%203-11l6-5%206-4%201%203c1%202%204%201%204-1l1%201c1%203%201%206-1%2010-2%203-3%205-3%2010%200%207%201%209%205%209s4%202%201%202c-3%201-3%204%200%204%205%200%2011-10%2014-26%201-4%209-9%2014-9s13%204%2016%208c3%203%204%2010%203%2017-1%204%200%205%202%208l2%202h1l3%201c1%201%202%201%201-1%200-2%200-3%202-3v-2l2-2c0-3-1-3-3-3h-3l3-2c6-4%206-7%200-13-4-5-5-6-7-5l-1-2-2-1c-1%201-1%200-2-1l-1-1-2-1h-3l-1-1-1-1-3-1c0-2-1-2-2-1h-1l-2-1c-1%201-2%200-2-1h-6c0%202-2%203-2%201h-4l-6%202-5%203%207-7%201-1c0-1%201-2%202-1l1-1-1-2c-5%202-1-1%207-7%2010-7%2019-6%2030%204%207%207%208%202%201-6l-6-5-1-2-2-1h-2l-6-2c-7%200-7-1%201-3s5-3-4-3c-7%201-8%201-8-1l5-4c7-3%207-7%200-6-10%202-9%202-10-1l-1-7c0-5%201-7%202-4%201%201%201-1%201-4%200-4%200-5%201-4%202%201%203-1%202-6%200-4-1-4-4%201-9%2018-10%2020-12%2019-1-1%200-5%203-9l2-4%204-10%204-9-6-1h-7l-1%2010m-200%209c0%205-2%208-6%209l-4%202-2%201c-2%200-5%204-5%206l-1%203v-4c0-3%200-4-1-3l-1%203c0%202%200%202-1%201-2-1-2%200-3%202-1%203-1%203-2%202s-1-1-2%201v5c2-1%203%200%203%203l1%203%201-2v-4c0-1%206-2%206%200l-1%201-1%201v1c-1-2-2-1-2%201v2l1-1h2l1-2h1c2%201%207%200%208-1h9l2%201c0%202-1%203-5%203l-7%203-3%201-1%201-2%204c0%202%200%202-1%201-2-1-2-1-2%201l-1%202c-2-1-2%200-2%201l-1%203c-3%200-2%202%201%205l2%201%201-2%201-1%201-2%201-1c0-4%2015-12%2018-10%201%201-1%203-3%203-3%200-5%203-2%204v3l1%202%201%201v3c0%202%200%202-2%201-3-2-2%200%201%203%204%203%206%204%203%201-2-3-1-4%202-2%202%202%203%202%203%201s1-2%202-1c1%200%202%203%200%203s3%204%206%206h4c-1-2%200-2%203-1%203%202%204%200%201-1-3-3%200-2%205%201l6%202%201%201-2%201c-2%200-2%200-1%202%201%201%201%201-2%201-2-1-3-1-2%201l1%201%201%202h-1c-2-1-2-1-2%202l-1%202v2l-1%202c-2%200-2%201-1%203%202%202%200%202-2%201h-2l1%203h2c2%200%204-1%206-4%201-3%203-5%204-5l1-1%201-1%201%201c-2%201%201%203%203%202l4-1%206-5c3-3%207-5%2010-6%204-1%205-2%204-3-2-3-9-6-13-7-7%200-18-8-19-11l2-6c2-5%201-11-3-15-2-3-2-4-2-10l-1-11c-1-4-7-11-10-10l-1-2-2-1h-5c0-2-3-1-3%201-1%201-1%201-1-1%200-3-2-2-2%201%200%206-1%207-2%202l-1-5v4m-57%2095c-3%202-3%205%201%205l3%201%202%202%205%203c1%201%201%201%203-1%204-4%202-6-11-12l-3%202m255%2019l1%2010-3%203-3%204c1%201%2014-1%2016-2v-13c1-2%200-3-4-7-7-7-7-7-7%205m-237-7c0%202%202%204%204%204l4%202%204%202c1-1%202%200%203%201%202%202%205%201%205-2%200-2-1-3-2-3l-5-3c-3-3-13-4-13-1m141%2026c-2%201-1%205%201%209l4%207c4%208%2011%2017%2013%2017%203%200%203-5-1-11l-5-9-5-8-5-4-2-1m-14%2061c-4%200-5%200-3%206%201%204%202%204%209%203%205%200%205-1%204-2-1-6-2-8-4-8l-6%201'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/e20a54803374dd316d28f02882a2468b/f7fa3/how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor.jpg","srcSet":"/static/e20a54803374dd316d28f02882a2468b/c96d8/how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor.jpg 116w,\n/static/e20a54803374dd316d28f02882a2468b/12243/how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor.jpg 232w,\n/static/e20a54803374dd316d28f02882a2468b/f7fa3/how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor.jpg 463w,\n/static/e20a54803374dd316d28f02882a2468b/ce8db/how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor.jpg 695w,\n/static/e20a54803374dd316d28f02882a2468b/87cea/how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor.jpg 926w,\n/static/e20a54803374dd316d28f02882a2468b/b24a9/how-to-use-track-changes-when-working-with-an-editor.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"Tell It Slant – An Alternative to ‘Show, Don’t Tell’","slug":"tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">American poet Emily Dickinson once wrote: ‘Tell the truth, but tell it slant.’ Following this advice can bring vividness and originality to your prose. Here&#8217;s how.</p>\n<p>You need descriptive writing in your novel so that the reader can accurately picture the scene, but descriptions can often fall flat.</p>\n<p>Choosing the right details helps create a clear and vivid image, but writers don’t have the time or the capacity to describe every little thing in minute detail. Plus, that would be super boring for the reader. Why? Because not only will it take up a lot of time in which the plot will be standing still, but often what you might describe will already be familiar to the reader &#8230; which is boring.</p>\n<p>Your reader won’t learn anything new or experiencing anything interesting if you spend seventeen pages describing every object in a room, the dimensions of every piece of furniture or the exact shade of every character’s eyes. Yes, you might create a very precise picture this way, but its vividness – its <em>aliveness</em> – will be smothered.</p>\n<p><strong>Vividness and originality is created through detail, but not by describing every detail. It’s created by describing a select few details – told slant.</strong></p>\n<h2>What does it meant to tell something ‘slant’?</h2>\n<p>To tell something ‘slant’ means to describe something in a new way, from a slightly off-centred perspective; the thing being described is made unfamiliar by the act of looking at it differently.</p>\n<p>Here’s an example. You might say: <em>The moon was shining.</em></p>\n<p>That’s pretty clear. It’s pretty succinct. But it’s not very interesting. It’s not very vivid. So instead let’s tell is slant by slightly altering our perspective and choosing some details described in a way that makes them feel unfamiliar and interesting.</p>\n<blockquote>\n<p>On the dam of the mill a fragment of broken bottle flashed like a small bright star, and there rolled by, like a ball, the black shadow of a dog.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Anton Chekhov</p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>In this sentence, we get the impression that the moon is shining, but it’s not directly stated. Instead, it’s shown indirectly (at a slant) through specific details made interesting through their interpretation (they’ve been made unfamiliar) – a piece of broken glass becomes a flashing star when the moonlight interacts with it; the shadow of a dog is given the quality of a rolling ball. Do we normally think about a dog’s shadow in this way? No – but the description works beautifully, and so a familiar image has been made new.</p>\n<h2>The problem with ‘show, don’t tell’</h2>\n<p>This piece of writing advice is often summarised as ‘show, don’t tell’, which encourages writers to avoid <em>explaining</em> what&#8217;s happening in a story and instead provide visuals that <em>demonstrate</em> what&#8217;s happening. The Chekhov quote above is more widely know in its recast version:</p>\n<blockquote>\n<p>Don’t tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Anton Chekhov</p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>However, it&#8217;s pretty easy to misinterpret the advice ‘show, don’t tell’. It can lead writers to think they must show everything <em>all </em>the time. But fiction is more than a string of images. It&#8217;s more than a visual unfolding of action that plays out in the mind’s eye. A novel isn’t like a film that we imagine. One of the main differences and advantages of the novel is that it portrays a story <em>through the lens of human experience</em>.</p>\n<p><strong>So should you ‘show’ or should you ‘tell’? Both are necessary, and balance is key. But because of the ambiguity of this piece of advice, I think it’s much more useful to think in terms of selecting the right details and telling them slant.</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>American poet Emily Dickinson once wrote: ‘Tell the truth, but tell it slant.’ Following this advice can bring vividness and originality to your prose. Here&#8217;s how. You need descriptive writing in your novel so that the reader can accurately picture the scene, but descriptions can often fall flat. Choosing the right details helps create a [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"29th April 2015","wordpress_id":160,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M203%201l-3%203c-2%202-2%202-3%200-1-1-1-1-1%201l-1%203c-2%201-5%209-5%2013l3%2012v4l1%203c2%200%200%209-2%2011-2%201-2%201-2-1s-1-1-2%202l-1%204v-2l-1-1-1%204-1%205c-2%203-2%2010%200%2014l1%206v3l2%2014a77%2077%200%20001%2019l1%204c2%203%202%2014%200%2019l1%207c3%207%205%2028%203%2030v11c2%202%203%209%205%2022v11l-2%203h4l61%201h60l-1-5%201-11c0-2%200-3-3-5-3-3-6-16-5-34%200-5%200-7-2-9-3-4-5-14-5-29%200-6-2-12-4-12-1%200-2-4-4-17v-8l-2-8c-2-5-4-14-5-26%200-7%200-10-2-12l-4-7c0-2-1-3-2-2-1%202-2%201-2-1l-1-4-1%201c1%202-1%202-3%201-1%200-2-1-2-3l-1-3v3c0%203%200%203-1%202-2-1-2-2-1-4l-1-3v-4c3%200%202-16%200-20l-3-5h-64'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/1642fd01563396b65cf02bea0602275c/f7fa3/tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell.jpg","srcSet":"/static/1642fd01563396b65cf02bea0602275c/c96d8/tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell.jpg 116w,\n/static/1642fd01563396b65cf02bea0602275c/12243/tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell.jpg 232w,\n/static/1642fd01563396b65cf02bea0602275c/f7fa3/tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell.jpg 463w,\n/static/1642fd01563396b65cf02bea0602275c/ce8db/tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell.jpg 695w,\n/static/1642fd01563396b65cf02bea0602275c/87cea/tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell.jpg 926w,\n/static/1642fd01563396b65cf02bea0602275c/b24a9/tell-slant-alternative-show-dont-tell.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}}],"page":2,"pages":2,"total":15,"limit":12,"prev":"/blog/category/line-and-copy-editing"}},"staticQueryHashes":["1904826805","930678125"]}