{"componentChunkName":"component---src-templates-blog-js","path":"/blog/category/line-and-copy-editing","result":{"data":{"page":{"yoast":{"title":"%%title%% – Insights from a professional fiction editor %%sep%% %%sitename%%","metadesc":"Articles to help authors improve their writing and get published. Insights into the publishing and editing industry (and advice for professional editors).","ogImage":null,"twitterImage":null},"title":"Blog"},"featuredPost":{"edges":[{"node":{"title":"The Earning Potential of Developmental Fiction Editors (in 2027)","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">How much do developmental fiction editors typically earn? What should you charge? Why do rates vary so much, and how you can aim for those higher ones?</p>\n<p>If you’re thinking about becoming a developmental fiction editor, or adding this service to your editorial business, or creating a side gig that turns your passion for storytelling into extra income, this post will help you figure out if it’s financially feasible for you. </p>\n<p>It covers: what editors are charging, why some charge far more than others, how to work out what you need to earn, and what you could realistically make.</p>\n<p>Not sure what developmental editing actually is? Read this post first: <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/what-is-developmental-editing\">What is Developmental Editing?</a></p>\n<h2>What developmental fiction editors are charging in the real world</h2>\n<p>These figures are based on publicly listed rates published by professional bodies, manuscript assessment agencies, a large freelance marketplace and established independent editors in the UK and US. They show what editors <em>charge</em>, not what they <em>earn</em>. </p>\n<p>Dollar figures have been converted to pounds at roughly £0.75 to the dollar, the mid-market rate when I checked at the time of writing (11 November 2026), and everything is rounded. Per-1,000-word figures are my own calculations from the published rates, and the novel-length examples assume 80,000 words.</p>\n<h3>Developmental editing</h3>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Per 1,000 words:</strong> Most editors charge around £20–27 ($27–36), though the full range runs from about £18 to £80 ($23–107).</li>\n<li><strong>Premium end:</strong> Established independent editors charge £60–80 ($80–107) per 1,000 words.</li>\n<li><strong>Per novel:</strong> An 80,000-word manuscript typically costs £1,600–2,200 ($2,100–2,900). At the premium end, it costs £4,800–6,400 ($6,400–8,500).</li>\n<li><strong>Hourly:</strong> Published rates run from about £34 to £53 ($45–70). The suggested UK minimum is £42.66 ($57).</li>\n</ul>\n<h3>Manuscript critique, appraisal and assessment</h3>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Flat fees:</strong> For a novel-length manuscript, the typical fee is £500–870 ($670–1,160), usually with a report of around 2,000–3,500 words.</li>\n<li><strong>Per 1,000 words:</strong> That works out at roughly £6–11 ($8–15). The marketplace average is higher at £19.50 ($26), or about £1,560 ($2,080) for an 80,000-word novel.</li>\n<li><strong>Premium end:</strong> Established independent editors charge around £30 ($40) per 1,000 words, or £2,400 ($3,200) for 80,000 words.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Here&#8217;s a simplified view:</p>\n<p><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table.png\" alt=\"Table comparing typical and premium rates for developmental editing and manuscript assessment, in pounds with US dollars in brackets. Typical rate per 1,000 words: developmental editing £20–27 ($27–36), manuscript assessment £6–11 ($8–15). Typical fee for an 80,000-word novel: £1,600–2,200 ($2,100–2,900) for developmental editing, £500–870 ($670–1,160) for assessment. Premium rate per 1,000 words: £60–80 ($80–107) for developmental editing, £30 ($40) for assessment. Premium fee for an 80,000-word novel: £4,800–6,400 ($6,400–8,500) for developmental editing, £2,400 ($3,200) for assessment. Hourly rate: £34–53 ($45–70) for developmental editing, with no figure given for assessment.\" width=\"2168\" height=\"725\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-2011\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table.png 2168w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-300x100.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-1024x342.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-768x257.png 768w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-1536x514.png 1536w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Editorial-Editing-Rate-Comparison-Table-2048x685.png 2048w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 2168px) 100vw, 2168px\" /></p>\n<p><em>I couldn&#8217;t reliably work out an hourly rate for manuscript assessments, as editors don’t publish one and the deliverables (such as report length and depth) vary. However, they typically take much less time than a full developmental edit.</em></p>\n<h2>Key factors affecting earnings</h2>\n<p>The rates above vary widely, with some editors charging two to four times the typical amount for the same service. I believe several factors explain the gap, and while some depend on an editor’s circumstances, others can be shaped over time.</p>\n<h3>Individual situation</h3>\n<p>Some factors depend on an editor’s own circumstances and the path they choose.</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Experience:</strong> As with all jobs, the more you do, the more you learn. Experienced editors can apply more honed, real-world knowledge to a project, which is value worth paying for, especially if their past clients have been successful.</li>\n<li><strong>Background:</strong> If an editor has a relevant skill or experience (such as time spent as a commissioning editor in a publishing house, or being a published author), this can give them a competitive edge.</li>\n<li><strong>Client source:</strong> Editors must decide for themselves whether they will thrive by working for a larger agency or through a marketplace, or whether they are better positioned to go it alone. With the former, they lose part of their fee to commission, but with the latter they must spend more time marketing. Successful editors know which works best for them.</li>\n</ul>\n<h3>What all editors can control</h3>\n<p>Other factors are within every editor’s control, whatever their background.</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Reputation:</strong> Not quite the same as experience, reputation is affected by client successes and their experience of the service and editor (were they good to work with &#8230;?), and authority and competency signals (such as awards, media appearances, memberships to reputable editorial societies, and more).</li>\n<li><strong>Brand positioning:</strong> This has a massive effect on earning potential. Editors who present themselves in a way that appeals to their ideal clients and demonstrates their individualism and professionalism stand out for all the right reasons.</li>\n<li><strong>Efficiency and boundaries:</strong> The quicker an editor works on a project with a set fee, the more they earn per hour. Similarly, editors who are clear on the project boundaries and do not allow for ‘scope creep’ operate with greater capacity.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Want to learn more about branding and building an editor website that converts? Take a look at this course: <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/the-visible-editor\">The Visible Editor</a>. </p>\n<h3>Where does training fit in?</h3>\n<p>Anyone can call themselves an editor and start trying to find paying clients. There are no regulating bodies or legal requirements like there are for lawyers or doctors.</p>\n<p>Some editors have enough background knowledge and transferable skills and experiences to become successful without formal training, but when you don’t have these things, <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/book-editing-courses\">editorial training</a> provides an essential foundation.</p>\n<p>Training won’t guarantee higher rates, but it can certainly help. It builds your skills, helps you work more efficiently, and gives you credentials that feed into your reputation.</p>\n<h3>Doing the sums</h3>\n<p>Earning potential isn’t only about what editors charge. Earning potential is just that: potential. You can’t just copy what another editor is doing because, as we’ve just seen, there are lots of factors that go into whether that editor can be successful charging that rate. </p>\n<p><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn.png\" alt=\"Venn diagram with three overlapping circles labelled ‘What you need to earn’, ‘Your capacity’ and ‘What your clients will pay’. The point where all three overlap is labelled ‘Your rates’.\" width=\"1024\" height=\"768\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-2012\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn-300x225.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/What-you-need-to-earn-768x576.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px\" /></p>\n<p>You also need to think about whether what you can earn from developmental editing matches what you personally need financially. Setting your rate is part of the puzzle, and there are a few things that come into play here.</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>What you need to earn:</strong> This depends on your circumstances and where you live. Remember that the fee isn’t what you keep. Tax and social contributions (which vary by country), business costs, unpaid time (holidays, sickness, marketing and admin) and exchange rates all reduce it.</li>\n<li><strong>Your capacity:</strong> This is how many projects you can realistically complete in a year, which depends on how quickly you work, how much time you spend on running the business and finding clients, and how much time you have available. (Raise your hand if you, too, can only work during school hours!)</li>\n<li><strong>What your clients will pay:</strong> The rates in the table above show what the market currently supports, from typical to premium. As you can see, these vary widely. A potential client is more than ‘someone who is looking for an editor’. There are loads of factors at play, but the bottom line is that you need to position yourself in a way that appeals to clients who are capable of hiring you.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Where these three things overlap, you have workable rates. </p>\n<p>Where they don’t, there are options: increase your capacity, build the reputation that supports higher rates, or add other income. </p>\n<p>In fact, many editors who offer developmental editing don’t rely on it alone. It’s usually one service among several, such as copy-editing or proofreading, and for some it’s a side business alongside other work.</p>\n<h2>What a developmental fiction editor could actually earn</h2>\n<p>Let’s look at some concrete examples. I’ve used the fees from the table for an 80,000-word novel here, and all figures are before tax, business costs and unpaid time. Developmental editing and manuscript assessment are two different services, so I’ve separated these out. </p>\n<p>Remember: rate, speed and the number of projects you can take on make the biggest difference, which is why many editors combine developmental editing with other services, work towards premium rates, or do it as a side income.</p>\n<h3>Developmental editing</h3>\n<p>Six typical edits a year would bring in about £9,600–13,200 ($12,800–17,600), a realistic side income or as part of a wider mix of services. One a month would gross about £19,200–26,400 ($25,600–35,200), and this is closer to a full-time workload. At premium rates, six edits a year would bring in £28,800–38,400 ($38,400–51,200).</p>\n<h3>Manuscript assessment</h3>\n<p>Assessments are priced much lower, so they take more projects to add up – but you can earn more per hour with assessments, and they take much less time overall. Ten a year at typical fees would bring in about £5,000–8,700 ($6,700–11,600), as a side income or as part of a wider suite of services, while ten at premium rates would bring in about £24,000 ($32,000) – much rarer, but not impossible.</p>\n<p><strong>Developmental editing can be a rewarding income, whether it’s a side gig or the heart of a full-time business. The editors who do best build their skills, reputation and business sense over time. If you’d like help laying those foundations, my self-paced <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/book-editing-courses\">developmental editing courses</a> at Liminal Pages are a good place to start.</strong></p>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/developmental-editing-fiction-theory/\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad.png\" alt=\"Banner advertising the online course ‘Developmental Editing: Fiction Theory’ for freelance editors, with a smiling woman holding an open orange book and a ‘Learn more’ button.\" width=\"1320\" height=\"500\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-2013\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad-300x114.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad-1024x388.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2026/11/DEFT-Blog-Ad-768x291.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /></a></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>How much do developmental fiction editors typically earn? What should you charge? Why do rates vary so much, and how you can aim for those higher ones? If you’re thinking about becoming a developmental fiction editor, or adding this service to your editorial business, or creating a side gig that turns your passion for storytelling [&hellip;]</p>\n","slug":"earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors-2027","date":"11th November 2026","categories":[{"name":"Freelancing","slug":"freelancing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.7727272727272727,"src":"/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/2c512/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg","srcSet":"/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/7ede2/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 195w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/9f700/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 390w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/2c512/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 780w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/05233/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 1170w,\n/static/17f980abdad31d51f2e3e37239cee30a/b24a9/earning-potential-developmental-fiction-editors.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 780px) 100vw, 780px"}}}}}}]},"postCategories":{"edges":[{"node":{"wordpress_id":5,"name":"Developmental Editing","slug":"developmental-editing"}},{"node":{"wordpress_id":8,"name":"Freelancing","slug":"freelancing"}},{"node":{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}},{"node":{"wordpress_id":6,"name":"Publishing Landscape","slug":"publishing-landscape"}}]},"currentCategory":{"edges":[{"node":{"slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}}]},"form":{"wordpress_id":230,"acf":{"title":"Liminal Letters","subtitle":"The newsletter that shares lessons and reflections on the art and business of editing.","introduction":"<p>Course updates, special offers and honest opinions on the editing and publishing industry – plus insights into the life of a small business owner: how I juggle a toddler (not literally), limited hours and high ambitions while trying to cultivate meaningful work.</p>\n","cta_button_text":"Sign up","note":"I will never share or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time. Form not working? Go here: https://liminal-letters.subscribepage.io","mailchimp_url":"liminalpages.us6.list-manage.com","mailchimp_user_id":"5eae0b68be96658ab68947d28","mailchimp_list_id":"5cdff76c1a","mailerlite_user_id":"1255214","mailerlite_form_id":"142431918007256385","success_message":"Thanks for signing up to Liminal Letters. Check your inbox to confirm your subscription. Thanks!","generic_error_message":"Uh-oh. There was a problem signing you up to the mailing list. Please try again later.","already_subscribed_error_message":"You are already subscribed to Liminal Letters. No need to sign up again!","background_image":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":2.6666666666666665,"src":"/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/f422e/newsletter-form-background.jpg","srcSet":"/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/e75b5/newsletter-form-background.jpg 160w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/c01e2/newsletter-form-background.jpg 320w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/f422e/newsletter-form-background.jpg 640w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/a6352/newsletter-form-background.jpg 960w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/ec6c5/newsletter-form-background.jpg 1280w,\n/static/0ad74ba12e77392825463290d9f3e625/7019e/newsletter-form-background.jpg 1870w","sizes":"(max-width: 640px) 100vw, 640px"}}}}}}},"pageContext":{"id":15,"category":4,"filtered":true,"nodes":[{"node":{"title":"Line Editing Tip: Why Cutting Filter Words Isn’t Always Enough","slug":"line-editing-tip-why-cutting-filter-words-isnt-always-enough","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">In fiction, strong point of view (POV) is the reader’s lifeline to immersion. The deeper the POV, the more readers can live inside a character’s experience – see what they see, feel what they feel. One of the most common obstacles to this depth is the presence of <em>filter words</em>: verbs that insert a layer of narration between the reader and the character&#8217;s direct experience.</p>\n<p>Words like <em>noticed, saw, felt, thought, heard, realised, knew</em> – these are all filter words.</p>\n<p>They report that something happened, rather than letting the reader experience it firsthand. Professional line editors look out for this. The more we remove that filter, the more immediate and engaging the prose becomes.</p>\n<p>And so eliminating filter words isn’t just about tightening the prose. It’s about helping authors craft a more immersive, emotionally resonant reading experience.</p>\n<p>However, line editors also need to know where their job ends … and where POV issues cross into developmental territory.</p>\n<h2>What are filter words?</h2>\n<p>Let’s look at a simple example:</p>\n<blockquote><p>She heard footsteps behind her and realised she was being followed.</p></blockquote>\n<p>Compare that to:</p>\n<blockquote><p>Footsteps echoed behind her. She was being followed.</p></blockquote>\n<p>The first version tells us what the character is perceiving; the second lets us perceive it right along with her. In the second version, there&#8217;s no need to say <em>she heard </em>– the footsteps are already a sound. Likewise, <em>realised</em> is unnecessary when we show the character drawing that conclusion through action or reaction.</p>\n<p>Filter words often arise from a well-meaning instinct: to clearly convey a character’s experience. But they tend to create distance, reminding the reader that they’re watching a character notice something, rather than noticing it themselves.</p>\n<h2>The key to eliminating filter words: deepening POV</h2>\n<p>Removing filter words successfully often means going deeper into the character’s point of view. This isn&#8217;t just a line-level tweak; it’s a technique that enhances the narrative voice, the emotional tone, and the character&#8217;s interiority.</p>\n<p>Deep POV means the reader is <em>in the character’s head</em>, not hovering over their shoulder. It’s the difference between:</p>\n<blockquote><p>He thought the room looked familiar.</p></blockquote>\n<p>and</p>\n<blockquote><p>The room was familiar. The warped floorboard near the fireplace, the faded red armchair – he’d been here before.</p></blockquote>\n<p>In the second example, we get direct access to the character’s perception, memory and emotional reaction without needing the signpost <em>he thought</em>. We are shown why the room was familiar instead of being told. This technique makes scenes more visceral and compelling.</p>\n<p>Of course, filter words don’t <em>always</em> need to be deleted. They can serve a purpose – especially when writing from a slightly more distant narrative stance. But when they’re overused, especially in a close POV, they dull the emotional impact and slow the pacing.</p>\n<h2>Line editing: how to fix filter words without rewriting</h2>\n<p>As line editors, our role is to polish and refine – not to rewrite. But when it comes to filter words, we’re often in the perfect position to flag opportunities to deepen POV and tighten prose.</p>\n<p>In the example we just looked at, a whole extra sentence is used to deepen the POV. But we can’t go around adding in lots of extra writing to a client’s novel – that would be overstepping the line.</p>\n<p>So how do we address filter words <em>without</em> rewriting the manuscript?</p>\n<h3>1. Flag and suggest rather than reconstruct</h3>\n<p>If a passage includes multiple filter words, highlight them and leave a comment like:</p>\n<blockquote><p>Consider rewriting to deepen POV here – phrases like ‘she saw’, ‘she thought’ and ‘she realised’ may be creating distance between the character and the reader. Can this moment be shown more directly through action or description?</p></blockquote>\n<p>This approach respects the author’s voice while guiding them toward a stronger execution.</p>\n<h3>2. Offer a brief solution – then let the author run with it</h3>\n<p>Here are a few examples:</p>\n<p><strong>Original:</strong> <em>He realised he’d made a mistake.</em></p>\n<p><strong>Comment: </strong>Try something like: <em>The silence pressed in. That was it – he’d messed up. Again</em>. This doesn’t just remove the filter word <em>realised</em>, it also adds a beat of interiority that anchors us in the character’s self-awareness and emotion.</p>\n<p><strong>Original:</strong> <em>She heard the door creak open and knew someone was there. </em></p>\n<p><strong>Comment: </strong>Try something like: <em>The door creaked open, slow and deliberate. Her breath caught. Someone was there</em>. This keeps us in her body and mind, building tension with rhythm and physical response – not just information.</p>\n<p><strong>Original: </strong><em>He saw the way she looked at him and thought she might be angry. </em></p>\n<p><strong>Comment: </strong>Try something like: <em>She didn’t smile. Her eyes flicked past him, sharp and fast. Was she angry? </em>This version shows the character interpreting what he sees, making the emotional subtext feel immediate and personal.</p>\n<p>Giving one good example often teaches more than editing every instance.</p>\n<h3>3. Respect the author&#8217;s voice and intention</h3>\n<p>Sometimes filter words reflect a deliberate choice for a more distant POV. Before cutting, consider whether the tone, style or narrative distance supports the use of filters. The goal isn’t to erase the author’s style (or every single filter word), but to eliminate <em>unintentional </em>distance that weakens the prose.</p>\n<h2>When POV problems go deeper than line edits can fix</h2>\n<p>As we’ve seen, filter words are often a symptom of a larger POV issue.</p>\n<p>In some manuscripts, they’re scattered here and there – a normal part of a draft. In others, they signal a deeper problem: the POV isn’t defined, consistent or controlled.</p>\n<p>This is where a line editor must tread carefully.</p>\n<p>A few considerations:</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Mild to moderate POV drift:</strong> The author might be using filter words to clarify switches in POV – but if the manuscript mostly sticks to one character’s POV (and clearly isn’t using omniscient narration), a line editor can flag these moments and suggest alternative phrasing.</li>\n<li><strong>Widespread inconsistency</strong>: If the manuscript bounces between heads or switches narrative distance frequently, line edits alone can’t solve the problem. Trying to fix POV inconsistencies line by line without a structural plan may result in a disjointed narrative (and an awful lot of work for you, the editor!). This kind of manuscript needs a developmental pass.</li>\n<li><strong>Unclear narrative intent:</strong> If it’s not obvious whether the story is meant to be in close third, omniscient, or something in between, the author may need to make a fundamental choice before line editing is effective.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>In these cases, the kindest and most professional response is honesty. A line editor can (and should) say something like:</p>\n<blockquote><p>There are significant POV issues throughout that affect narrative clarity and consistency. A deeper developmental edit is needed before a line edit will be fully effective.</p></blockquote>\n<h2>Key takeaways</h2>\n<p>Eliminating filter words is more than a mechanical process – it’s a way to deepen the emotional resonance of a scene and connect the reader directly to the character’s world.</p>\n<p>For authors, it means trusting the reader to follow the action and emotion without constant narrative signposts. For editors, it’s about guiding, not ghostwriting – suggesting stronger alternatives without imposing.</p>\n<p>And perhaps most importantly, it’s about recognising the limits of each editing stage.<br />\nLine editing can transform a manuscript’s prose – but only when the underlying structure, POV and character voice are already sound.</p>\n<p>Filter words are a great place to start – but they’re also a diagnostic tool. Pay attention to how and where they appear, and you’ll often discover not just a line that needs tightening, but a character’s voice waiting to be fully heard.</p>\n<p><strong><em>Want to learn more about line editing techniques? Sign up to the newsletter (at the bottom of the page) to be notified when my new line editing for fiction course is available for purchase.</em></strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>In fiction, strong point of view (POV) is the reader’s lifeline to immersion. The deeper the POV, the more readers can live inside a character’s experience – see what they see, feel what they feel. One of the most common obstacles to this depth is the presence of filter words: verbs that insert a layer [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"5th June 2025","wordpress_id":1834,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7575757575757576,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M19%201c22%201%2027%202%2016%204l-8%202c-2%203-6%204-16%205-11%201-11%201%208%201l14%201c-5%201-5%201-1%201h4l-6%202c-4%201-7%202-8%204l-6%203c-4%201-4%201%202%201l10%201c3%201%203%201-4%203l-5%203c0%202-2%203-4%204l-3%201h4a56%2056%200%20019%201c4%200%203%202-2%202l-6%204c-2%204-1%205%205%205%204%200%205%202%201%203-5%201-7%202-7%203%201%201%200%203-1%203-2%203-1%203%203%203l6%201-2%201v7l-2%201c-4%200-4%202-1%202%205%200%207%201%205%202l-1%205c0%203-1%204-3%204-3%200-4%201%200%201l6%201-2%202-1%201%202%205-5%201h-4l6%201c5%201%205%202%204%203-2%201-2%201%200%202l5%201%201%202%203%201h3l-3%201-8%201c-4%200-5%200-2%201%205%200%206%201%203%203l-2%201h3c4%200%207%201%207%203l3%201c7%200%200%202-10%203l-5%201%209%201c2%201%202%201-2%201h-5l4%201%207%201%204%201%203%201c2%200%202%200-1%201l-3%201h3c6%200-5%202-15%202-12%200-11%202%201%202%205%200%209%200%208%201-5%201-4%202%200%202s4%200%203%203-4%204-21%204H8l13%201a4610%204610%200%200117%204c2%200%202%200-1%203-3%202-7%203-24%204l-13%201h14c11%200%2017%200%2021%202l6%201-4%201-6%203c-2%202-4%202-16%203l-15%201%2017%201c18%201%2023%202%2023%203l-4%201-5%202-5%201c-2%200-2%200-1%201%203%201-10%202-20%202l-5%201%2018%201c19%201%2027%202%2018%204h-5l-4%202-25%203-2%202c0%201%2018%202%2026%201%203%200%2013%201%2012%202l-28%204H0v7h6l17%201h14l4%201h-5l-21%201-15%201v9h36l-6%201-18%201H0v7h181a2720%202720%200%2000206-4l6-2h-5c-6%200-13-1-19-3l-8-1c-6-1-4-3%206-3a46%2046%200%200016-4l-12-1c-8%200-17-1-21-3l-7-1%207-1%2010-1c1-1%2010-3%2021-4h7l-7-1-16-1h-9l3-2c5-3%206-4%203-5-2%200-2%200%201-1l9-1%207-1c0-1-7-2-14-1l-6-1%203-1%202-2%201-2%202%201v2c1%200%202-3%201-4l-5-1c-5%200-5-1%202-1l5-2h-2l-5-1h-2l2-1h4c2%200%201-1-1-3l-2-2h2c4%200%202-2-2-2-3%200-3%200-2-1%202-1%202-1%201-2-2-1-2-1%202-2%206-2%207-6%201-7h-8c-2-1-1-1%203-1%207%200%209-1%208-3l9-1c8%200%208-1%208-2%200-4-2-4-14-4-15%200-26-2-13-2%205%200%207%200%209-2l8-1c8%200%2011-1%2011-3%200-3-4-4-19-4l-15-1c-1-1%201-1%206-1l9-1%209-2c8%200%209-1%209-3%200-3-4-4-26-4-18%200-19-1-4-2%2031-3%2030-3%2028-6s-4-3-18-4h-29l8-1a32347%2032347%200%200137-5l-2-2c0-2-5-3-16-3l-21-1h-11l13-1a1125%201125%200%200134-3l-2-3c-3-3-9-4-27-4l-15-1%207-1%2010-1a262%20262%200%200124-2l-4-3c-5-3-8-4-39-4l-11-1a410%20410%200%200147-5l-4-2c-2-2-13-4-22-4l-21-1%2013-1a310%20310%200%200027-4l-5-2c-3-2-5-3-21-3-28-1-28-1-11-3a178600%20178600%200%200129-4l-5-2c-2-2-5-2-14-3a1934%201934%200%2001-32-1c-9%200%201-2%2015-2%2013%200%2041-3%2033-3l-9-3-10-2-35-3v-1c36-1%2049-2%2044-3l-7-3-5-2v1c1%201%201%201-1%201h-3c-2-1-6-2-14-2l-13-1-20-1c-30%200-13-2%2025-3%2031%200%2046-1%2034-2h-10l-7-2c-4-3-8-3-8-1s0%202-2%200h-3c-1%202-2%202-4%200l-3-2-150-1L19%201m228%2014l-8%202c-3%202-3%202%2014%202l20-1c2-3%201-4-3-4-3%200-3%200%200%201%202%201%202%201-3%201h-9c-2%200-2-1%202-1%204-1%204-1-1-1l-12%201m14%208c1%201-2%202-12%202l-13%201h40c3%200%202-2-1-2l4-1c6-1%205-1-6-1s-13%200-12%201m-81%2053c-2%201-2%205%200%205l1%201-3%201c-2%200-2%200-1%201l1%202v1l1%202c0%202%201%203%203%204s2%201-2%202-4%201-2%202l2%204%202%204c1%201%201%201-1%202l-1%202%201%204%201%203h11c12%200%2016-1%2016-2l1-3c2-2%201-5-3-4l-6-1%205-1c5-1%207-2%207-4l-6-2-1-1%201-2-1-1-3-2h4c6-1%206-2-1-2l-6-2-2-1c-2%200-2%200-1-1s1-1-1-1c-4%200-1-2%204-2h5l-6-1c-8-1-9-2-2-2%202%200%203%200%202-1l-2-1c0-2-3-3-4-2-1%202-2%201-4%200-2-2-7-3-9-1m1%2043l-2%201%202%203c3%204%206%205%2017%205%206%200%2010%200%209-1-4-1-4-2-1-2%202-1%202-1%201-2-2-1-1-1%202-1l5-2c0-2-28-3-33-1m1%2012c-3%200-2%202%202%203%203%200%204%201%204%202%200%202%205%203%2013%202%205%200%207-1%207-2l-1-1c-4%200%203-3%207-3s3%200-3-1h-29'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/b8178981cea1da263a8a484f9509277d/f7fa3/filter-words-pov-line-editing.jpg","srcSet":"/static/b8178981cea1da263a8a484f9509277d/c96d8/filter-words-pov-line-editing.jpg 116w,\n/static/b8178981cea1da263a8a484f9509277d/12243/filter-words-pov-line-editing.jpg 232w,\n/static/b8178981cea1da263a8a484f9509277d/f7fa3/filter-words-pov-line-editing.jpg 463w,\n/static/b8178981cea1da263a8a484f9509277d/ce8db/filter-words-pov-line-editing.jpg 695w,\n/static/b8178981cea1da263a8a484f9509277d/a677d/filter-words-pov-line-editing.jpg 779w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"What If You Spot Developmental Issues During a Copy-Edit?","slug":"what-if-developmental-issues-during-copy-edit","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">Here’s a common predicament: Your client hasn’t been through any kind of developmental editing before hiring you to copy-edit their book. You start editing, but partway through you realise there are … issues.</p>\n<p>Big issues. With the story itself. Or the way it’s written.</p>\n<p>Things that you can’t help address with the copy-edit you’ve been commissioned to do. Things that require some substantial rewriting …</p>\n<p>What should you do?</p>\n<p>There’s no single right answer, but you have options.</p>\n<h2>What you can do&#8230;</h2>\n<h3>OPTION 1: Only provide the service for which you’ve been hired.</h3>\n<p>You could decide that it&#8217;s the client’s responsibility to figure out what service they need. Perhaps the big-picture issues you’ve spotted aren’t a concern to the author, and they just want their sentences polished up. That’s up to them.</p>\n<p>Giving an author developmental feedback they haven’t asked for is the same as giving someone unsolicited advice (which can leave people feeling feeling irritated, shamed or judged), but with the added complication of money being involved.</p>\n<p>It might be best for everyone if you just stick to the task you’re being paid for, keeping in mind that you are still helping the author improve their book.</p>\n<h3>OPTION 2: Let the author know about easily fixable developmental issues.</h3>\n<p>If the first option doesn’t sit quite right with you and you can see some simple ways the author can improve their book, you might decide to provide a few pointers in a short editorial letter when you hand back the copy-editing manuscript.</p>\n<p>Make sure that whatever you suggest doesn’t require substantial rewriting, otherwise your copy-edits will go to waste.</p>\n<p><em>But</em> check beforehand that the author is open to this kind of feedback. A simple email saying something like, ‘I’ve spotted a few ways you could improve the story/your writing technique beyond the scope of this copy-edit. It would require you to invest a bit more work on the draft. Would you like me to send you these pointers alongside my edit?’</p>\n<p>Importantly, don’t spend so much time on these things that you damage your hourly rate.</p>\n<h3>OPTION 3: Ask if the author would be willing to hire you (or someone else) to help them address the developmental issues you&#8217;ve spotted.</h3>\n<p>The earlier in the edit you can do this, the better – as inevitably some of the writing you’ve edited will end up being rewritten or deleted.</p>\n<p>A <a href=\"/budget-book-editing-best-spent/\">client’s budget</a> and publishing timeline might not stretch to this, but you can give authors the option. Authors also might not be happy to hear their book needs more work, so see if the they’re open to critical feedback like this before you suggest it.</p>\n<p>This might seem like the most ethical option, but it can leave you in a difficult position where you end up with a cancelled project or a project that is put on pause, leaving you with a hole in your schedule (and out of pocket).   Because of this, my preferred solution is to try to pre-empt any developmental issues in a manuscript, rather than get to this point.</p>\n<h2>How to pre-empt developmental issues before you take on a copy-edit</h2>\n<p>It will be better for both you and your client if you&#8217;re able to make sure the manuscript is ready for a copy-edit before you take it on. Here&#8217;s how you might do that.</p>\n<h3>OPTION 1: Add some questions into your initial conversations.</h3>\n<p>Before you agree to take on a copy-editing project, ask the author if they’ve had any kind of big-picture feedback on their manuscript – whether that’s from a professional or <a href=\"/what-are-beta-readers/\">beta readers</a>.</p>\n<p>If they haven’t, ask if they are sure they are completely happy with the story and their writing techniques, explaining that copy-editing should only happen once this is the case.</p>\n<p>If the author is sure they want to go ahead with the copy-edit but you still end up spotting developmental issues as you work, choose one of the options laid out in the first half of this post, safe in the knowledge you’ve done some due diligence and the responsibility sits with the author, not you.</p>\n<h3>OPTION 2: Ask to see a synopsis and a sample of the manuscript.</h3>\n<p>Again, before you take on a manuscript to copy-edit, ask the above questions AND ask to see a <a href=\"/how-to-write-a-synopsis/\">synopsis</a> of the story and a sample. Take 10-15 minutes to analyse this – any more, and you end up wasting too much time and energy on authors who don’t convert to paying clients.</p>\n<p>Can you see a compelling <a href=\"/develop-your-novels-premise/\">premise</a> in the synopsis, with a beginning that seems like the right place for the story to start, rising complications in the middle, and a satisfying ending that makes sense? Skim the sample. Can you see any issues with point of view, scene structure or ‘show vs tell’?</p>\n<p>You don’t need to be an expert in all the things that a developmental editor looks for, but if you’re able to see whether these particular aspects are working, this will give you a good indication of whether the story or writing technique needs further work.</p>\n<p>If you think there are issues, let the author know that you recommend developmental editing before copy-editing and point them in the direction of a trusted colleague, asking them to come back to you for copy-editing when they’re ready.</p>\n<h3>OPTION 3: Require a paid assessment before a copy-edit.</h3>\n<p>Some editors don’t take on any kind of editing work until their clients have gone through a paid assessment of their manuscript. This involves a complete read-through (a quick skim) of the book and a short report that outlines the main issues and the recommended service(s).</p>\n<p>This assessment isn’t as in-depth as a manuscript critique (a type of developmental edit), and doesn’t cost as much. It’s generally not supposed to help the author completely redraft their book. Instead, it helps the author make the best decisions on their path through the editing process.</p>\n<h2>So there you have it. Those are your options.</h2>\n<p>Think about how you want to work, and what feels right for you and your business.</p>\n<p>Having a plan for how you’re going to deal with those instances where you’re conducting a copy-edit and realise there are developmental issues in the manuscript will help you save time and worry.</p>\n<p>Lastly, keep in mind that your role is to help authors improve their books, not make them perfect.</p>\n<p>Ultimately, the client is responsible for commissioning the right kind of service – though you can help them make this decision (if they want help) by doing some pre-project exploration.</p>\n<p><strong>Want to learn more? Take a look at this <a href=\"/courses/tea-and-commas/\">fiction copy-editing course</a> or this <a href=\"/courses/developmental-editing-fiction-theory/\">developmental editing course</a>.</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>Here’s a common predicament: Your client hasn’t been through any kind of developmental editing before hiring you to copy-edit their book. You start editing, but partway through you realise there are … issues. Big issues. With the story itself. Or the way it’s written. Things that you can’t help address with the copy-edit you’ve been [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"4th September 2024","wordpress_id":1774,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":5,"name":"Developmental Editing","slug":"developmental-editing"},{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M56%2011v11H0v27h67l17%201V0H74v19c-1%2026-2%2026-3%200%200-18%200-19-2-19s-2%201-2%2016l-1%2016-1-17V0h-9v11m184-6v5h-5l-8-2c-7-2-13-3-24-2h-12a1124%201124%200%2000-12%201l1%202%201%201h-5c-1-1-1%200-1%201l-1%202-1-1-2-2c-2%200-3%201-3%202l-1%201v3c0%202%200%203-3%204l-4%201c-1-2-2%200-1%202%200%202%200%202-2%202h-2c1%201%200%202-2%203-2%200-4%202-4%203l-2%202c-2%201-1%205%201%206%203%202%201%204-5%205-2%200-4%201-4%203l-2%202c-2%201-3%202-2%204%200%202%200%203-1%202l-1-1%201%203c0%202%202%203%202%202l1%201v1l-1%203c-1%203-1%203-2%201h-2l1%202v4l-3%203-1%202c0%204-8%203-13-1l-2-1c0%203%209%207%2012%207%204-1%206%201%204%203-2%200-4%206-4%208%201%202%202%202%2016-2%2011-3%2011-3%2011-6l1-3-1-3c-3-6%200-23%204-22h1l-1%208%201%202c2%200%204-9%203-10-3-3%204-6%2012-5%206%200%2014%207%2014%2011%201%2011-1%2015-5%2016-3%200-4%201%200%201%208%201%2010-21%202-26l3-1%206-2h-7c-1-2-1-2%202-2l4-2c1-1%201-1%202%201v4l1%201c1-1%203-7%203-11%201-3%202-3%203%200l3%202%201%203c0%203%200%203-2%203-5%200-8%205-4%206l1-2c0-1%200-2%202-2s3%201%201%202-1%208%201%209h2c3-6%205-6%207-5s2%201-2%204l-6%206c-1%203-2%203-7%203-7-1-6%200%200%202%204%200%204%200%204%204l-2%204v2l-1%202v5l1%206%201-1%202-1-1%202c-1%201%200%201%202%201%203%200%203%200%201-2-2-3%200-2%203%200%207%206%2017%206%2024%202l4-1%201-1c-1-3%200-3%202%200%202%204%204%2013%204%2018a142%20142%200%2001-5%2021c0%202-6%2011-7%2012v8l3%2014c1%208%202%2010%203%208v1c0%202%203%201%204-1l4-2c2-1%203-1%202%207a196%20196%200%2001-10%2045c0%202%20112%201%20113%200%205-5%206-8%204-10l-4-6-5-9-15-24c-12-21-18-30-23-32l-4-2h-2c-2%200-3-2-1-3%201%200%202-1%201-4l1-3%201-2c-1-4%200-4%201-1l1%203v-3l-1-2v-3c2-3%203-2%203%201v4l1-7v-7l1%202%204-7-3%201-2%202-2-2c-2-3%200-5%203-3s3%201%203-3c-1-6-3-9-3-3%201%204%202%204-6%203-4-1-3-5%201-5%202-1%202-1-1-2l-3-3%201-2c0-2%202-1%204%201s3%200%200-2c-2-3-2-3-1-7l1-3%208-1%209-1V3c0-2-1-3-3-3h-2v76h-9c-12%200-13-2-7-7%205-5%205-6-1-8-8-3-9-5-8-11v-6l2-1%202-1h-6l-7-1-3-3c-4-2-5-4-2-4%202-1%202-1%200-1l-4-2-3-3-5-2c-5-3-6-8-1-7l2-1c0-1-3-2-4-1-2%201-4-2-5-6l-1-4-1%202c1%204-1%203-2%200l-1-1-2%202c-3%200-5-1-4-2l-1-1-2-1%201-1V4c-1-3%205-2%206%201%201%202%201%202%202%201l1-1c2%200%201-1-1-3l-7-2h-6v5m-25%2056c-19%209-14%2036%207%2036%206%200%2012-4%209-6h-4l-5-1-2-2%202-1c2-1%202-1%200-3s-3-1-4%202v3l-1-4c-1-4%200-6%203-6v1c-1%201-1%201%202%201%205%200%209%202%209%205l2%201%201%201v4c1%200%204-4%203-5l1-2c1-1%201-1-1-3l-1-2-2-1-3-3c-1-3-1-3%202-3%202%201%203%200%201-6l-1-2c-1%201-1%200-1-2%201-2-12-4-17-2m-51%2035a174%20174%200%20014%2052v4l-9%203-14%205h-6l-4-5-5-5-3%201-1%204-1%204c-1%200-2%201-1%204%200%204-3%208-10%2013l-4%208-8%2022c-3%205-6%2016-6%2019l47%201a953%20953%200%200044-3v-2l-3-9-4-10c1-2-1-5-3-10-6-12-7-16-8-29%200-10%200-11%201-10%202%200%203-1%201-3v-2c1-1%202-5%202-13v-13l6%202c14%203%2015%203%2016%206%200%202%201%202%205%202l5-1-14-7c-17-4-21-7-21-13l-1-8-1-8c0-4-1-5-2-6l3-1c8-1%208-1%200-2h-8l3%2010'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/f7b5c2823dd782ec30b0db84eaa7a386/f7fa3/spot-developmental-issues-copy-edit.jpg","srcSet":"/static/f7b5c2823dd782ec30b0db84eaa7a386/c96d8/spot-developmental-issues-copy-edit.jpg 116w,\n/static/f7b5c2823dd782ec30b0db84eaa7a386/12243/spot-developmental-issues-copy-edit.jpg 232w,\n/static/f7b5c2823dd782ec30b0db84eaa7a386/f7fa3/spot-developmental-issues-copy-edit.jpg 463w,\n/static/f7b5c2823dd782ec30b0db84eaa7a386/ce8db/spot-developmental-issues-copy-edit.jpg 695w,\n/static/f7b5c2823dd782ec30b0db84eaa7a386/87cea/spot-developmental-issues-copy-edit.jpg 926w,\n/static/f7b5c2823dd782ec30b0db84eaa7a386/b24a9/spot-developmental-issues-copy-edit.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"5 Weird Skills You Need to Copy-Edit Novels","slug":"5-weird-skills-copy-edit-novels","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">Being a freelance novel editor isn’t just about sprucing up sentences, fixing wonky grammar and annihilating typos. Nope! There’s a whole lot more to it!</p>\n<p>Before you set up your editing business and start looking for clients, you’ll need to know what else is expected of you.</p>\n<p>Here are a few things you might not have realised you’d be responsible for when taking on freelance editing work.</p>\n<h2>1. Checking prelims and end matter</h2>\n<p>Prelims (short for ‘preliminary material’ – also known as ‘front matter’ in publishing lingo) are the pages that come before the start of the main story. Think title pages, copyright pages, contents, etc.</p>\n<p>End matter (also known as ‘back matter’) are the pages that come after the main story. Think acknowledgements, glossaries, about the author, etc.</p>\n<p><strong>As a freelance novel copy-editor, it’s your responsibility to check that all the right pages are there, that they include all the right content, and that this content is also edited.</strong></p>\n<p>If you work with publishing houses, they will likely expect this from you.</p>\n<p>Self-publishing authors might not send you these things to check. If they don’t, you might want to ask that they do, since checking prelims and end matter is all part of editorial quality control.</p>\n<h2>2. Marking up for the typesetter</h2>\n<p>Marking up means using textual codes to show the person whose job it is to design the interior of the book exactly which parts of the text need to be styled, and styled the same way (e.g. chapter headings).</p>\n<p><strong>Marking up the manuscript to prepare it for typesetting is part of the copy-editor’s role.</strong></p>\n<p>These days, marking up electronic book files can be done in a couple of ways.</p>\n<p>The more traditional way (that mimics editing on paper) is to use coloured, bracketed textual codes.</p>\n<p>The more modern way is to use Word’s styles feature, to electronically tag the text.</p>\n<p>Most publishing houses will expect you to mark up for the typesetter.</p>\n<p>Most self-publishing authors won’t, usually because they’re unfamiliar with the needs and benefits of this process – but applying styles regardless (and explaining why) will certainly help them out when they come to designing their book files or passing them onto freelance typesetters.</p>\n<p>So it’s a good skill to have.</p>\n<h2>3. Creating a style sheet</h2>\n<p>A style sheet is a reference document you create in which you record any manuscript-specific editorial stylistic decisions you make (e.g. Does the author use the serial comma?) and anything in the story you need to keep an eye on for consistency.</p>\n<p>It’s super useful!</p>\n<p><strong>You’ll usually hand your style sheet over to the client so the author can quickly understand many of the editorial decisions you’ve made.</strong></p>\n<p>And further down the line, the proofreader will refer to your style sheet to help them do their final check, too.</p>\n<p>As you can imagine, it takes skill to create a good style sheet.</p>\n<h2>4. Applying house style</h2>\n<p>House style essentially refers to the editorial stylistic decisions that a particular publishing house follows.</p>\n<p>Self-publishing authors are much less likely to have created their own house style.</p>\n<p>Even so, you should always ask before you start editing whether they’ve made any stylistic decisions you should be aware of – otherwise you might accidentally undo something the author has done deliberately.</p>\n<p><strong>You need to understand how the house style applies to the manuscript and how to make this work in tandem with your style sheet.</strong></p>\n<p>This will mean you’ll conduct your edit efficiently and to the client’s desired specifications.</p>\n<h2>5. Keeping an eye on legalities</h2>\n<p>Libel, breach of copyright, plagiarism, passing off &#8230;</p>\n<p><strong>Did you know it’s the copy-editor’s responsibility to look out for certain legal issues in a manuscript and alert the clients to these?</strong></p>\n<p>As a professional copy-editor, you aren’t expected to have the same level of knowledge as a lawyer. (Phew.)</p>\n<p>But you should strive to understand the essentials of publishing legalities – and keep your knowledge up-to-date.</p>\n<h2>Learning how to do these things</h2>\n<p>If you want to be a professional copy-editor, you need more than just an excellent grasp of grammar and punctuation. You also need to know how to handle everything mentioned in this post.</p>\n<p>So where can you learn this stuff?</p>\n<p>Luckily for you, I have a comprehensive online course that teaches you exactly what you need to know and how to do it all.</p>\n<p>And unlike many other courses that teach copy-editing, this one focuses exclusively on fiction.</p>\n<p><a href=\"/courses/tea-and-commas/\">Check it out here.</a></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>Being a freelance novel editor isn’t just about sprucing up sentences, fixing wonky grammar and annihilating typos. Nope! There’s a whole lot more to it! Before you set up your editing business and start looking for clients, you’ll need to know what else is expected of you. Here are a few things you might not [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"22nd March 2023","wordpress_id":1634,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M183%2019c-4%204-7%205-10%202l-2-1v3l-2%201c-2-1-3%200-1%202l-2%201-3%201h-3c-3%200-3%200-2%201l5%202h5l-6%202-9%203-3%201-1%202v2l1%202c1%202%202%203%202%207%200%2014%206%2022%2018%2024%206%201%2015%200%2017-3%201-1%201-1-1-1-11%203-18%203-24-2-3-2-5-5-2-4%201%201%203%200%205-2l6-3c1%201%203%200%204-1h3l3%203c2%203%208%203%2011%201h1c0%202%200%202%205%201l4-1%202-1c2-1%2011%207%2011%2010l1%202c2%202%201%205-2%205-2%200-3-2-1-2l-1-1-2-3-2-5c-2-2-9-4-9-2l-3%202c-2%201-2%201-2%204%201%203-1%2010-3%2011s1%203%2010%207c8%203%2010%204%2010%206l3%201%202-2%203-1%201-1c0-1%2012%200%2016%202s5%203%205%201c-1-1%200-1%201-1%202%200%202%200%202-2-1-2-1-2%202-1%202%201%202%201%202-1-1%200-1-1%200%200l1-1-1-2v-2h-1l-2-2-3-3%201-3%201%201h3l1-2%201%201%201%201h4l1-2c2-1%202-2%201-3l-1-3-1-8c0-6%200-6%202-8%204-4%203-6-4-10l-7-5v-3l-2-2-2-2-3-2-4-2-1-1-2-1c-2-2-4-3-4-1l-2%201%201-2v-2l-3%202-1%202-2-2-2-2h-1v1h-1l-1%201-1%201-1-2c1-2%201-2-2-1l-4-1-2-1h-2l-1-1h-1c-1-2-7-2-7-1h-1l-2%202c-1%201-1%201-3-1-2-3-2-3-5%200m34%2090l-2%202-3%202c0%202-2%203-4%203-3%201-4%203-2%207%201%202%200%207-2%207-3%200-4-3-4-8%200-4-2-7-3-5l1%204v4c-2%205-8%205-10%200l-2-2c-2%200-12-4-14-7h-4c-1%201-2%200%200-2%201-1%201-1-2-1-3%201-4%200-3-2l-4-1-4%201-5%209-8%2018c-2%204-4%2010-6%2011l-1%204%201%203c0%202%201%202%2016%202l19%201c1%201-16%201-42%201-49%200-56%200-28%201l18%201h-19c-17%200-18%200-23%203-4%202-7%205-3%204a390%20390%200%20005%2042l1%2011%201%204h219l1-4%201-8c0-2%200-2%205-2l30%202c36%201%2061%203%2063%204%201%201%201%200%201-4s0-4-1-2l-1%203a659%20659%200%2001-31-3%201596%201596%200%2001-65-3l7-35c2-7%201-12-2-13-4-2-13-1-13%201l-1%201-1-2-5-1c-4%200-6%201-6%202l-1%201-1-1c0-2-1-2-3-2-3%200-4%200-4%202h-2c-1-2-4-2-11-2l-6-1c4%200%204-4%200-21-5-17-12-29-18-29-3-1-3%200-3%202l-3%201-1%201-7-1c-3-5-4-6-5-3M3%20211c-2%200-2%201-2%205v4h8a297%20297%200%200125-2c-1-1-4-2-5-1l-4-2h-7l-1-1h-3l-3-1-2-1c0-1-3-2-6-1'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/fa45d9a42db24e88b5bb1f195061408a/0b74b/5-weird-skills-copy-edit-novels.png","srcSet":"/static/fa45d9a42db24e88b5bb1f195061408a/d43b3/5-weird-skills-copy-edit-novels.png 116w,\n/static/fa45d9a42db24e88b5bb1f195061408a/28598/5-weird-skills-copy-edit-novels.png 232w,\n/static/fa45d9a42db24e88b5bb1f195061408a/0b74b/5-weird-skills-copy-edit-novels.png 463w,\n/static/fa45d9a42db24e88b5bb1f195061408a/321d3/5-weird-skills-copy-edit-novels.png 695w,\n/static/fa45d9a42db24e88b5bb1f195061408a/7dac8/5-weird-skills-copy-edit-novels.png 780w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"Writing Advice Myth: Eliminating &#8216;to be&#8217; Verbs","slug":"writing-advice-myth-eliminating-to-be-verbs","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">There’s a piece of writing advice floating around out there that recommends authors comb through their writing cutting out the word ‘was’ – or any form of the verb ‘to be’.</p>\n<p>In some cases, this is good advice. But in other cases, it causes writers to use the wrong tense.</p>\n<h2>When to delete &#8216;to be&#8217; verbs</h2>\n<h3>Reason 1: To turn the passive voice into the active voice</h3>\n<p>The passive voice is not something to be avoided at all costs. It has its place. I just used it at the start of this paragraph, for instance, because:</p>\n<p>a) I wanted the focus of the statement to be on the object of the sentence (the passive voice)<br />\nb) it flows naturally in this context.</p>\n<p>The passive voice is when the subject of the sentence (usually the person doing the action) is hidden – they’re not noted in the sentence.</p>\n<p>Who is doing the lack of avoiding in the first sentence of this section? Presumably you, the person reading this blog post. If I rewrote the sentence in the active voice, it would result in something like: ‘You should not avoid the passive voice at all costs.’</p>\n<p>Notice how this rewritten version does away with the verb ‘to be’?</p>\n<p><strong>Common writing advice is to avoid the passive voice. One way of doing that is to eliminate instances of the verb ‘to be’ (including its past-tense version ‘was’).</strong></p>\n<p>So yes, you can delete ‘to be’ verbs (including ‘was’) from a piece of writing if you want to change it from the passive to the active voice, but make this decision on a case-by-case basis.</p>\n<h3>Reason 2: To improve/tighten a sentence by shifting the focus to a more interesting verb</h3>\n<p>While writing, ‘was’ is often the easiest verb for authors to reach for.</p>\n<p>But while editing, you’ll often be able to see how another word in the sentence could take on all the work instead.</p>\n<p><strong>You&#8217;ll find that the &#8216;to be&#8217; verb could be replaced with something much more specific and descriptive.</strong></p>\n<p>Here are a few examples:</p>\n<p>Original: ‘Snow <u>was</u> blanketing the ground.’<br />\nEdit: ‘Snow blanketed the ground.’</p>\n<p>Original: ‘There <u>is</u> no method that would work in this case.’<br />\nEdit: ‘No method would work in this case.’</p>\n<p>Original: ‘The dragon <u>was</u> in the field.’<br />\nEdit: ‘The dragon lounged in the field.’</p>\n<p>A word of caution, though. If you&#8217;re editing a client&#8217;s manuscript and want to make a change like that last one, where you&#8217;re inserting a whole new verb, flag it up for the author to check – otherwise you&#8217;ll be overstepping your role as editor and entering the realm of co-authoring.</p>\n<h2>When NOT to delete ‘to be’ verbs</h2>\n<h3>When the past continuous tense is needed</h3>\n<p>Take another look at the first example above.</p>\n<p>Original: ‘Snow was blanketing the ground.’<br />\nEdit: ‘Snow blanketed the ground.’</p>\n<p>This edit actually changes the tense of the sentence.</p>\n<p><strong>And there’s a nuance between the past continuous and the past tense that shouldn’t be ignored.</strong></p>\n<p>The past continuous should be used when the action is still ongoing. Even though it’s in the past, it has not been completed.</p>\n<p>When reading ‘Snow was blanketing the ground’ I might assume it’s still snowing. The snow is continuing to blanket the ground.</p>\n<p>When reading ‘Snow blanketed the ground’ I might assume it has stopped snowing. The snow has finished its process of forming a blanket.</p>\n<p>Perhaps you think the verb ‘was’ still makes that first sentence read a little clunky. If so, an alternative way of removing ‘was’ while suggesting the past continuous is to use two verbs, one in the past and one in the present.</p>\n<p>Alternative edit: ‘Snow fell, blanketing the ground.’</p>\n<p>Here, it’s clear that the snow is still falling, but it does away with that ‘to be’ verb, providing the utmost specificity to a sentence.</p>\n<p>Here are some more examples.</p>\n<p>Original: &#8216;She was resting.&#8217;<br />\nAlternative: &#8216;She rested, snoring softly.&#8217;</p>\n<p>Original: &#8216;They were dancing to the music.&#8217;<br />\nAlternative: &#8216;They danced, moving to the music.&#8217;</p>\n<p>Of course, you should be careful not to overuse any kind of sentence structure, otherwise you risk the writing becoming repetitive in its rhythm.</p>\n<h2>To look at it a different way …</h2>\n<p>It’s a common piece of writing advice to get rid of all ‘to be’ verb forms (e.g. ‘was’) because it indicates a lack of creativity and specificity in the verb choice.</p>\n<p>However, this is only true when ‘was’ is used as the only verb, e.g. ‘He was at the bar.’ Here, the only thing happening (according to the verb ‘was’) is existence. Change the verb to something more interesting/specific and you might get: ‘He waited at the bar.’</p>\n<p>But now the tense needs attention, because this indicates that the waiting has ended; it’s all in the past. If he is still waiting at the bar, the past continuous tense more clearly indicates this – and the past continuous requires the use of ‘was’: ‘He was waiting at the bar.’</p>\n<p><strong>So, yes, think about where ‘was’ and the variations of the verb ‘to be’ crop up in a piece of writing, but don’t assume all instances need editing out!</strong></p>\n<p>Learn more about the nuances of professional editing by taking an <a href=\"/courses/\">online course</a>.</p>\n","excerpt":"<p>There’s a piece of writing advice floating around out there that recommends authors comb through their writing cutting out the word ‘was’ – or any form of the verb ‘to be’. In some cases, this is good advice. But in other cases, it causes writers to use the wrong tense. When to delete &#8216;to be&#8217; [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"4th August 2021","wordpress_id":1450,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M0%2015l1%2014%204%202%208%204c13%206%2020%2011%2017%2013h-3l-6-1-8-3-4-2-1-1-7-3a383%20383%200%20001%2064l3-1%201-3c0-6%202-8%207-7%204%200%205%204%204%208-2%204-2%204-3%202l-2-1-2%201c-2%201-2%201-1%203h3c1-2%202%200%201%203-1%202-2%203-3%202-4%200-4%200-1-1%201-1%201-1-3-3l-5-2-1%2022%201%2022%201%201c1%202%202%202%204%202%201%200%202%200%201%201l1%201h2v2c-2%202-2%202%200%204v4H8l-1%201%201%201h1l-1%202-1%201c-1%201-2%203-2%201l-1-1v2l1%202-1-1H1l-1%2028v28h11c10%200%2011-1%209-3-3-2-2-3%200-2h3l2%203v2h145a3819%203819%200%2000165%200h5v-7c0-6%200-6%202-7l6%201c3%201%209%209%209%2011s2%202%2011%202h12l1-3c1-5%202-7%204-6l3-2c2-3%209-7%2011-7l1%206-1%206-1-2c0-1%200-2-2-2-1%200-2%200-1%202%200%201-1%202-4%202-4%201-6%203-6%205l8%201h8v-29l-1-28c-2%200-2-1-1-3a217%20217%200%20001-44c1%201%201-20%201-60V0h-23c-20%200-22%200-22%202-1%202-5%206-8%206-2%201-2%201-2-2s0-4-2-4l-2-1-11-1c-10%200-10%200-10%202%201%201%200%202-1%202l-1%202c1%202%200%204-3%203l-2%201-4%204%201-4c1-1%202-4%201-6V0h-23v4l3%2016a6340%206340%200%200115%2080c2-2%2012-3%2015%200%202%202%203%202%203%201%200-3%204-6%207-6%206%200%206%206%201%2010-4%204-9%205-8%203l-1-2-2-1h-2c-2%201-1%202%203%203%202%202-3%203-9%203h-6l8%2048c0%205%200%205-25%208l-28%204c-7%202-8%201-8-3l-2-5-2-3-3%203-3%205-2%202c-1%201-1%201-1-1%201-3%200-4-1-2h-4l-3%201c0%202-3%203-3%202h-3l-1-1c0-2%200-2-3%200h-4l-2-1c-3%201-8%200-8-2h-1c-2%201-6%201-7-1-1-1-2-1-4%201-3%203-11%205-12%203h-2c-1%202-6%200-6-3l-1-1-2%202c0%201-2%201-3-1-1-1-4-1-5%201l1%201%202%202-3%201c-2%200-2%200-1%201%202%202%200%205-3%207-3%201-4%202-3%204h1l2-1v2l-4%201h-3l-12%202-10%201-15%202-14%202c-3%200-5-2-5-6A15133%2015133%200%200081%2012L80%200H0v15m51%2015c-5%201-8%204-8%208%201%206%204%207%2012%205%204-1%205-2%205-8%200-5-1-6-9-5m154%2021v1c3%200%204%202%203%203l-1%205-1%204c-2%202-13%203-13%202l7-11%201-2-9%2011c-3%204-3%204-10%204l-8%201%204-9%204-8c0-1-3%202-6%2010l-4%208h-10l1-3%202-7c1-5%201-5-1-4-2%200-2%201-6%2010-2%205-2%206-6%206-5%200-4%200-2-7v-7c-2%200-4%207-3%209%200%203-2%206-5%206-4%200-12%203-12%204%201%201%203%202%207%202h7l-1%209%201%208c2%200%205-5%209-12%204-9%205-10%205-2l1%209%201%202%202-2%206-9%203-8%208-1c8-1%209-1%207%203-2%208-2%2011%200%2012%204%201%207-1%2013-8l5-7-1%205c-1%208%203%209%2010%203%204-4%203-5-1-1-5%203-7%202-5-5l1-6%209-1c23-4%2022-4%2022%200%200%202-1%202-3%202s-2%200%200%201l2%201-7%208c-11%206-16%203-7-4%204-3%205-4%200-2-5%204-7%206-7%209s0%203%205%203c5-1%2014-6%2016-11%202-3%203-4%205-4%203%200%203%200%201-1-2%200-2-1-2-3v-3l8-1c12-2%2012-3%200-2-10%200-11%200-16-2l-6-3c-3%200-2-2%201-3l1-2c-2%200-6%203-6%205l5%204%206%202-25%203%201-5%201-6c0-2-4-4-7-3m168%202c-4%202-4%204-1%207l1%203c0%203%200%203%205%203s5%200%204-7c-2-9-4-10-9-6m-41%201l3%203c2%201%203%204%201%206l-1%202c1%201%200%204-3%207-3%204-4%205-4%203s-1-3-2-3c-3-1-5%200-6%201%200%202%203%2010%204%208%200-1%201-1%202%201h2c0-1%206-4%2011-5l9-1-1%205c-1%204-1%2012%201%2014%201%201%200%202-3%203-7%202-11%209-12%2016%200%205%201%205%209-2l9-4c2-1%202-1%200-1l-2-3h3l-1-1v-4c1-1%202%200%204%202%203%204%208%205%208%203l2-1c2%200%207-2%207-4l-2-2c-2-3-3-6-1-6v-4l-1-1c0%202-5%208-7%207v1c0%202%200%202-2%202-4%200-4-1-1-5%202-3%202-3%203-2%200%203%203%202%203%200l-2-1c-3%200-1-5%202-7%203-1%203-2%203-5%200-7-2-9-10-8l-7-1-2-1-1-1h5c4%202%205%202%205-2%200-2-12-9-13-7h-1l-3-2h-8M194%2071c-4%201-7%207-7%2012%200%204%202%204%208-3%208-8%209-10%205-10l-6%201m199%207c-5%201-9%203-9%205%200%201%206%202%207%201l4%201%205%203v-6c0-5%200-5-3-5l-4%201M52%20104c-3%201-4%202-5%204-1%203%200%204%203%203%202%200%202%200%201%201s-1%201%201%202l2%202v1c1%201%200%201-1%201-2%200-2%200-1%201%201%202%201%202-1%202-1%201%200%201%202%201%206%200%209-2%208-4l-3-2h2l4%201h1l4%201c5%204%206-3%201-9-6-6-12-8-18-5m303%207v4l1%2016v3c-2%204%202%2018%204%2016l3%201c2%203%204%201%202-2-2-2-2-3%200-5%202-1%202-2%201-2-2-1%202-5%204-4l1-2c0-2%202-4%202-2h3c2-3%206-2%204%201l-5%204c-3%201-4%203-4%204v1l-1%201v1l-1%205c2%200%2020-19%2020-20l-3-3c-5-3-9-2-9%202l-1%202-1-1-1-2-2-4c-1-3-2-5-2-3l-1%203c-2%201-2%201-2-3l-2-6-3-3-1-1v4l-1%204c-1%201-1%201-1-1l-1-4v-3c0-2%200-2-2-2-1%200-2%200-1%201m-28%207c-3%200-4%202-4%208v6l-1-5c-1-6-2-6-5-2-2%202-3%206-1%206l1-2%201-2-3%2010c-3%201-1%206%205%2010l7%205v-10l2-13v-12l-2%201M25%20143c-3%203-3%2010%201%2014%205%206%207%206%2010%201%203-4%202-16-1-16h-2v1c0%202-2%202-3%200-2-2-3-3-5%200m56%201l-6%203c-1%202-3%202-4%202h-2l-3%201h-3l3%203c2%202%203%203%202%204-2%201-2%209%200%2010%201%202%202%202%203%200v-2l-1-7%201%201h3l-1%203c-2%203-1%203%202%201s3-2%201-4c-1-2-1-2%201-2l1-1c-1-1-1-1%200%200l4-3%206-7%204-3h-4l-7%201m252%204c-7%205-10%2010-10%2017%200%204%200%205%202%205%202%201%205-1%205-3s1-3%203-4l2-2v-2l-1-2-2-1%202-1%203%201h2l-3-2c-4-2-5-4-2-5%201%200%209%204%209%206h1c1-4%200-6-4-8-4-1-4-1-7%201m45%205l-2%202v1c-3%200-3%202%200%203%203%202%204%204%202%204l-3%203c0%202-1%203-2%203l-2-1-1-1-2-1c-3-1-3%202%203%207%207%207%2012%2010%2012%209%204-5%203-22-1-26l-1-3h-3M77%20172c-1%204-4%208-6%208l-1%202-1%201-1%201-1%202c-1%202-2%202-2-1v-3l-3%202c-3%203-3%203-2%207%202%205%203%205%206%200l10-12%202-5c0-6%200-8-1-2m231%206c0%202%200%202-2%201-2-2-2-2-2%200l-4%202-3%202-8%201c-18%200-19%209-4%2023%207%207%207%207%209%205l3-2c1%201%203-1%202-3l-3-1c-1%200-2%200-2-2l-2-2-1-1c0-1%205%200%208%202%203%203%207%203%207%200%200-4%202-3%203%203s3%206%205%201-1-13-6-17l-6-3-4-1c-1-2-1-2%203-1%205%200%2014-4%2014-7l-1-1h-3c-3-2-3-2-3%201m-287%206l-3%204c0%203-3%205-5%205-1-1-3%200-6%201-3%202-4%204-2%204v2l1%201%204%201%202%202%202-2%202-4c0-2%203-5%205-5l1%204c0%203%201%204%202%202%201-3%203%200%202%203s1%204%203%201c0-3%206-3%206%200l3%201c7%200%208%200%207%202v1l3-1c3%200%208-6%208-8l-4-2-5-3-3-1h-1l1-2c0-2-5-3-6-1h-1c0-3-2%200-2%203%200%202-4%207-5%207v-3c0-4-1-10-3-12-3-4-3-4-6%200m349%202v5c3%202%201%203-1%202l-4-1-3-2-3-2c-2%200-4%203-2%204s2%204-1%204-4%200-4%205c0%206%202%2011%208%2017%202%202%208%200%208-3%200-2%200-2%202%200h4l4-1c3%200%204-2%202-6a5262%205262%200%2000-2-12c-1-2-1-2%202-1l3-1c-2-2%201-2%203%200%203%203%203%202%202-1-2-5-15-10-18-7M67%20204c-3%203-3%203-3%207v5l-1-1-1-2-1%202-1%201-1-1-1-3c-2-2-3%201-1%203l1%203c0%202%200%202%201%201h3c-1%201%200%202%202%202%203-1%206-4%206-8l1-3%201-4c0-5-1-5-5-2m175-1v3c2%202%201%203-1%202h-3l-2%202c-1%200-3%203-2%204%201%202%206%201%209-1%204-5%207-5%2011%200%203%203%203%203%204%202%202-3%203-2%203%201s3%202%205-1c2-4%203-4%204-1%200%205%201%203%202-1%200-4%200-5-3-7l-3-2-1%202c-2%202-2%202-3%200-3-3-6-3-6-1%200%203-4%203-6%200s-5-4-8-2'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/e5730c8381150be9c159f501169a43b4/f7fa3/delete-was.jpg","srcSet":"/static/e5730c8381150be9c159f501169a43b4/c96d8/delete-was.jpg 116w,\n/static/e5730c8381150be9c159f501169a43b4/12243/delete-was.jpg 232w,\n/static/e5730c8381150be9c159f501169a43b4/f7fa3/delete-was.jpg 463w,\n/static/e5730c8381150be9c159f501169a43b4/ce8db/delete-was.jpg 695w,\n/static/e5730c8381150be9c159f501169a43b4/87cea/delete-was.jpg 926w,\n/static/e5730c8381150be9c159f501169a43b4/b24a9/delete-was.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"How to Address Unconscious Biases in a Manuscript","slug":"address-unconscious-biases-manuscript","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">As an editor, it’s your duty to educate yourself on potential unconscious biases that might occur in a piece of writing so you can help the author address them.</p>\n<p><a href=\"https://learn.g2.com/unconscious-bias\">Courtney Moran</a>, a senior research analyst for HR technologies, defines unconscious bias in this way:</p>\n<blockquote><p>Unconscious biases, otherwise known as implicit biases, are inherent or learned stereotypes about people that everyone forms without realizing it. Unconscious biases are social stereotypes about an individual, group or institution. Everyone has unconscious biases about various groups, and they are often not aligned with one’s conscious values.</p></blockquote>\n<p>We all have unconscious biases. I have them. You have them. Readers have them.</p>\n<p>But just because they’re unconscious, it doesn’t mean we can’t do anything about them.</p>\n<h2>Uncovering unconscious biases</h2>\n<p>Before we can address unconscious biases, we first need to uncover them.</p>\n<p>Here are a few ways you can do this for yourself:</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li>Try to be more mindful of decisions and judgements you would normally make on autopilot.</li>\n<li>Read books about experiences different from yours and by people different from you to widen your worldview.</li>\n<li>Follow people online who are active voices in their areas of representation to develop your understanding.</li>\n<li>Listen when someone else calls you out on a bias you might be exhibiting – don’t react with offense and dismissal.</li>\n<li><a href=\"https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/selectatest.html\">Take the online tests</a> developed by Harvard University for Project Implicit.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>What’s interesting is that unconscious biases don’t usually align with our values.</p>\n<p>For instance, you might fully believe that Black authors can write novels as equally brilliant as white authors. And yet, perhaps you scan your bookshelf and discover you own hardly any novels by Black authors.</p>\n<p>Clearly there’s some unconscious bias at work there, but once aware of it, you can consciously address it.</p>\n<h2>What kinds of unconscious biases occur in fiction?</h2>\n<p>Here are just a few story-level examples:</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li>All astronauts, company bosses, military leaders, technicians, etc. are male, and female characters fulfil the roles of secretaries and lovers.</li>\n<li>The female love interest dies as motivation for the male protagonist.</li>\n<li>There is only one person of colour or one female in an otherwise all-male, all-white group of friends.</li>\n<li>The villain has a disfigurement (often a facial scar) – see: every James Bond villain.</li>\n<li>The villain is coded with queer stereotypes – see: most Disney villains.</li>\n<li>The villain is Russian/German/Chinese/British (the super-posh kind) or a mass of nameless, faceless Middle Eastern men.</li>\n<li>The villain is overweight, and this is often used to create a sense of disgust.</li>\n<li>The villain is a villain because they are suffering from mental illness.</li>\n<li>A white character rescues a group or society of non-white characters from unfortunate circumstances (the ‘white saviour’ narrative).</li>\n<li>The confident, violence-prone male character who mocks emotion is seen as favourable to the quiet, thoughtful, emotionally intelligent male character.</li>\n<li>The main role of a character with a disability is to help the character without a disability learn something about themselves.</li>\n<li>A character over fifty is baffled by smartphones, computers or the internet.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Hopefully you can see how each of these instances can be problematic and demonstrate unconscious negative stereotypes and biases.</p>\n<p>Here are a few word-level issues to look out for:</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li>Look for words like ‘only’, ‘need’, ‘always’ and ‘just’ that form generalisations and stereotypes that don’t serve as part of a larger critique of an issue, e.g. ‘She was just a woman’ and ‘Chinese students were always good at maths’.</li>\n<li>Consider the style preferences of the people being referenced. For instance, many people of colour prefer ‘Black’ to be capitalised when a piece of writing refers to people/culture.</li>\n<li>Think people-first, e.g. the phrase ‘disabled people’ and not ‘the disabled’ should generally be used as the collective term because ‘disabled’ is a description, not a group of people.</li>\n<li>Look for adjectives that are used to describe only one group of people. (These often carry negative connotations, too.) For example: the ‘ditzy’ woman, the ‘sassy’ Black woman, the ‘dirty’ old man, the ‘little’ old lady.</li>\n<li>Look for verbs that carry unintended negative weight. For instance, you ‘commit’ a crime and you ‘commit’ a sin, but the phrase ‘committed suicide’ should really be rethought because suicide is neither a crime nor a sin – ‘died by suicide’ is one alternative.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>If you want to learn more about how to address these kinds of language-based biases, take a look at the <a href=\"https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/bias-free-language\">APA Style Bias-Free Language</a> guide and the <a href=\"https://consciousstyleguide.com/\">Conscious Style Guide</a> – both free online recourses.</p>\n<h2>Your responsibility as an editor</h2>\n<p>First and foremost, don’t judge people for having unconscious biases – because it’s really not the same as being deliberate prejudice.</p>\n<p>If you&#8217;re conducting a <a href=\"/services/developmental-editing/\">developmental edit</a>, you&#8217;re in a better position to guide an author to reconsider any of the story-level unconscious biases that you might see in the manuscript.</p>\n<p>If you&#8217;re conducting a <a href=\"/services/line-and-copy-editing/\">line and copy-edit</a>, it can be more difficult to address story-based unconscious biases. Sure, it would be simple enough to make a few of the all-female secretaries male, but it would be a much bigger task to change a story based on the &#8216;white savour&#8217; narrative.</p>\n<p>I recommend you don&#8217;t just go ahead and change all the word-level instances of unconscious bias you spot in a manuscript, because that’s not your call.</p>\n<p>Your job is to flag up the instances you spot and explain why they could be problematic. This way, the author can make the final decision about their piece of writing with a fuller understanding of the implications of their words.</p>\n<p><strong>In the end, we all have unconscious biases. But both writers and editors have a responsibility to try to uncover them in themselves and the writing they’re putting out into the world.</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>As an editor, it’s your duty to educate yourself on potential unconscious biases that might occur in a piece of writing so you can help the author address them. Courtney Moran, a senior research analyst for HR technologies, defines unconscious bias in this way: Unconscious biases, otherwise known as implicit biases, are inherent or learned [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"24th June 2020","wordpress_id":1399,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":5,"name":"Developmental Editing","slug":"developmental-editing"},{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M71%2043a605%20605%200%2001-1%2061%203198%203198%200%20003%2069c-1-16%201-16%201%201l2%2013a7110%207110%200%2001-5-144m5-18a4751%204751%200%20004%20161c0%202%201%202%203%202%205%200%207%201%207%203l-4%201c-5%200-8%201-8%205%200%202-1%204-3%205l-3%203h8c7%200%208%200%2015-4%209-4%209-5%204-8l-3-2%203-3c4-5%205-5%205-2%200%202%200%203%203%203l6%203%2015%202c15%201%2021%200%2033-4l8-1c1%201%202%200%203-1l5-2c3%200%203%200%201%202-4%203-5%206-2%2010%202%204%203%207%201%207l-1%202c0%202%204%201%207-2s9-5%208-2l1%203%203%202%203-3%207-4c3%200%207-2%206-3-1-2%201-6%205-8%203-3%2010-5%2020-6a383%20383%200%200016-3h18c26%202%2036%205%2036%2012%200%206-9%2010-30%2014l-11%203c-2%202-2%202-4%201-4-3-9-2-12%202-3%203-3%203-3%208l1%205h87v-3l-2-7-2-10-2-8-2-5-1-5-1-8-2-8c-1-3-1-3-7-2l-6%201-5-12-1-3-3-6-4-18-2-3-2-14v-11l-1%2011v11l-3-7-5-12-3-5%205-3%206-4c4%200%2020-17%2020-20%200-2-2%200-5%203l-4%204-7%205c-8%206-10%208-15%208-6%201-10%204-17%2011l-5%205%201%2015-1%2045c-1%201-2%202-3%201v4l-2-2-1-4c-1-1-3-51-2-60s4-11%2013-16c6-3%206-3%202-7-4-3-10-5-18-5-2%200-4%200-3-1%201%200%201-1-1-3l-5-5a189%20189%200%2001-6-41l-1-6-6-20%203-1%204-1-4-1c-2%201-4%200-5-1-2-2-3-2-23-2l-21%201-1%203c-1%203-5%208-7%208l-3%202c-1%202-1%202-1-1l-1-3-1%204c-2%204-3%209-3%2036v18c1-2%202-2%202-1%201%201%201%200%201-1%200-4%202-2%203%203v5l-1%203-1%202h-2c-1-1-6%204-6%208l-3%205c-1%202-2%202-2%201l2-7c0-4%200-4-2-4s-6%201-8%204c-3%202-4%202-4%201-1-1-1-1-2%201l-2%203-2%203-2%203%208%204c7%203%209%205%2011%208l3%204%2028-12c3-1%202-2-1-6-2-2-2-3-1-4l1-2%203-7c4-5%204-9%200-12a63%2063%200%2001-12-30l-1-6-1-6c0-8%203-14%208-15%204-1%204-1%205%204l2%204c1%200%202%201%202%204%201%202%201%203-1%203v1c1%201%201%201-1%201-9%202-9%202-7%204%202%201%202%201%200%202s-3%203-1%203l4%202c2%202%203%202%205%200s4-1%204%201%200%202%201%200l1-3%201-1c3%201%203%2012%200%2012l-2%202%202%201h2l2%203c1%201%200%201-3%202l-5%203c-2%202-2%202%201%203%203%200%205%201%203%202-2%202-1%204%202%205%202%200%203%204%200%206-2%201-1%203%202%203%202%200%204%203%204%206%201%204%206%205%2013%203%206-2%206-2%208%200l4%202%202%202-1%201-1%202c0%202%200%203%202%202l1%204-1%2011c0%206%200%207-1%206h-1c1%202-1%204-2%204l-1-1-1-2-1%204c0%205-5%209-6%205-1-1-1%201-1%203%200%204-1%205-4%208l-5%204-1%203-2%203-1%202c1%201%200%201-3%201h-3l-4%201c-1%201-1%201-3-1-3-2-6-2-11%201l-3%201-1%201%204%201c5-1%205%200%201%201l-3%203c0%202-3%207-6%207-2%201-2%202-2%203%201%202%200%203-1%204-2%203%201%203%205%201%202-1%204-2%205-1%202%200%202%201-8%209l-1%202-1%201c-2%200-5-11-4-15%200-3%200-3-5-5l-15-7-9-4-4-8c-9-18-11-20-11-9l-1%204-3%202c-3%201-3%201-3%208l-1%207-1-8-1-8-1%204-1%204v-16a63%2063%200%2000-3-26l-2-7c-4-4-5-11-1-9l2-1%202-1-1-2c-2-1-2-1-1-2s3-25%204-66V0H76v25m301%2026c-13%201-13%201-11%204l3%20161v10h16l15-1-1-1c-3%201-6-16-7-46l-1-25c-2-14-4-82-3-84l10-5c2%200%202-1%202-7v-7h-6l-17%201M28%2070l-2%204c0%202-3%206-6%206-2%201-3%202-1%205h3c2-1%206%200%206%202v3c-2%202-1%203%202%203%205%200%207%204%203%205l-2%203-1%203c-2%200-1%202%201%202s3%201%203%205v5l2-5V93c-1-3%201-7%204-7%201%200%201-1-1-3v-7c0-4%200-5-2-6-3-3-6-2-9%200m16%2038c4%208%207%209%2017%209%206%200%208-1%202-2-7%200-7%200-7-2l1-2c2-2%201-3-1-3l-3%202h-2l-2-2h-5m12%2040c-5%202-4%206%202%2010l8%207%203%204v-9c0-10%200-13-2-13l-2%201h-3l-2-1-4%201m-7%2022h3c3-2%204%200%204%208%201%2010%202%2010%206%209%203%200%203%200%203-5l-4-9-2-5h-6c-5%200-5%200-4%202m36%2041c-4%202-4%203-5%209%200%206%201%206%203%206l5-3c2-2%207-2%208%200l1%201c1%200%202-13%201-14-2-1-10-1-13%201m120%201c-1%202-1%208%201%2011%201%203%201%203%207%203%205%200%205%200%205-2l-3-6-2-6h-8m-85%203l-3%203c-2%202-2%203-1%204l2%203%205%201c5%200%206%200%206-3%201-4%200-6-3-8h-6'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/b77912565d2e35fd1b093e4b9f2c97a3/f7fa3/unconscious-biased-fiction.jpg","srcSet":"/static/b77912565d2e35fd1b093e4b9f2c97a3/c96d8/unconscious-biased-fiction.jpg 116w,\n/static/b77912565d2e35fd1b093e4b9f2c97a3/12243/unconscious-biased-fiction.jpg 232w,\n/static/b77912565d2e35fd1b093e4b9f2c97a3/f7fa3/unconscious-biased-fiction.jpg 463w,\n/static/b77912565d2e35fd1b093e4b9f2c97a3/ce8db/unconscious-biased-fiction.jpg 695w,\n/static/b77912565d2e35fd1b093e4b9f2c97a3/87cea/unconscious-biased-fiction.jpg 926w,\n/static/b77912565d2e35fd1b093e4b9f2c97a3/b24a9/unconscious-biased-fiction.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"How to Avoid Starting Sentences with I","slug":"how-to-avoid-starting-sentences-with-i","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">You&#8217;re editing a first-person narrative and realise nearly every sentence starts with the pronoun ‘I’. It stands out, and feels repetitive and unimaginative.</p>\n<p>The first thing you&#8217;ll probably do is start to fiddle around with sentence structure. Here are a few ways you can quickly fix too many sentences starting with ‘I’:</p>\n<h2>The quick fix</h2>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Start with a prepositional phrase.</strong> A propositional phrase lets us know where the subject of the sentence is in time or space, or what the relationship is between two entities.They can be easily to add to the start of a sentence, e.g. ‘From across the street, I saw the hooded figure’, ‘After breakfast, I got dressed in my finest dinosaur costume and headed to work’.</li>\n<li><strong>Swap the clauses.</strong> Simple, complete sentences can be made of a single clause – and the minimum requirement for a clause is a subject and a verb. If the sentence contains more than one clause, you can often shuffle them around so the clause that starts with ‘I’ is not at the start of the sentence.So ‘I ordered the rocky road because marshmallows are the best’ could become ‘Because marshmallows are the best, I ordered the rocky road’ and ‘I whistled to myself as I strolled down the street’ could become ‘As I strolled down the street, I whistled to myself’.</li>\n</ul>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/coffee-and-clauses-the-art-of-line-and-copy-editing-fiction\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignnone wp-image-1907 size-full\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"500\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-300x114.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-1024x388.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-768x291.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /></a></p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Cut out unnecessary actions.</strong> We don’t always need a blow-by-blow account of what the character is doing. Listing out all the actions the character takes often leads to a shopping-list style of sentences beginning with ‘I’.Often, though, many of these actions can be cut out completely without risking the reader losing the thread of the action, e.g. instead of ‘I pulled up the hand break and turn off the ignition. I then opened the car door, climbed out and shut the door behind me. I locked the door and went to buy a parking ticket’ we wouldn’t lose anything if the narrative just said ‘I parked the car’.</li>\n<li><strong>Avoid filter phrases (&#8216;I thought&#8217;, &#8216;I saw&#8217;, &#8216;I heard&#8217; &#8230;).</strong> When we’re in a first-person narrative, we often don’t need certain phrases that indicate which of the character’s senses are being engaged.These are known as ‘filter phrases’ because they act as an unnecessary filter between the viewpoint character and the reader. We know that what’s being narrated is what the character is thinking, seeing, hearing, tasting, etc. because we’re aware that we’re experiencing their point of view.So instead of ‘I saw the clouds gathering above field’ you can just have ‘The clouds gathered above the field’. Instead of ‘I heard a manic laugh in the darkness’ you could have ‘A manic laugh rang out in the darkness’.</li>\n</ul>\n<p><strong>TIP: Don’t fall into the trap of rewriting everything in the passive voice.</strong></p>\n<p>A sentence becomes grammatically ‘passive’ when emphasis is put on the person or thing that experiences the action instead of the person or thing driving the action, e.g. instead of ‘I gave the opening speech’ you’d write ‘The opening speech was given by me’.</p>\n<p>There’s nothing inherently wrong with the passive voice, even if some writing advice recommends avoiding it.</p>\n<p>However, if you end up making too many sentences passive to try to avoid starting too many with ‘I’, this will certainly weaken the writing (or make it sound strange).</p>\n<h2>The deeper fix</h2>\n<p>Those sentence revisions are a good way to quickly change things up if you occasionally run into the problem of too many sentences starting with ‘I’ – but what if the majority of the narrative ends up this way?</p>\n<p>Tweaking all the sentences might create a strange rhythm and cadence to the prose.</p>\n<p>Instead, trying getting deeper into the character’s point of view (or encourage the author to do this in their revisions if this goes beyond the scope of your editing service).</p>\n<p>This might be especially important if you find that removing filter phrases is making the writing a bit confusing. It shows that the narrative isn’t necessarily as closely aligned to a character as it could be.</p>\n<p>Try doing the following (or asking the author to do the following):</p>\n<ul class=\"separated-list\">\n<li><strong>Dig deeper into the character’s voice.</strong> A first-person narration should sound as though it’s coming from the character, not the author.So think carefully about the kinds of words the character would use, the kinds of sentence structures they favour. Reworking the sentences in this way will help you make the narrative flow more smoothly after taking out those filter words.</li>\n<li><strong>Dig deeper into the character’s viewpoint.</strong> Really put yourself in the character’s shoes.Instead of having a list of actions, consider what kinds of things make up the character&#8217;s subjective experience. Are they observational or do they focus inwards? Are they empathetic or are they fairly oblivious to the emotions of others?Once the focus is changed from the author looking at the character to the character looking at the world, you’ll find there are naturally fewer sentences starting with ‘I’.</li>\n<li><strong>Include more observations.</strong> Even if the character isn’t particularly observant, including at least some descriptions of what the character sees, hears and smells around them can help add variety to the writing.</li>\n<li><strong>Include more inner monologue.</strong> In a similar but opposite way, focusing the narrative inwards can help, too. How is the character interpreting the world? What thoughts are occupying their mind?Scattering more of this through the prose allows for more varied sentence structure.</li>\n</ul>\n<h2>Tips in action</h2>\n<p>Take a look at this bit of prose:</p>\n<blockquote><p>I shouldn’t have come to this party.</p>\n<p>I’m not even sure I belong at this party. I’m not bougie. I just think there are just some places where it’s not enough to be me – either version of me. I’m at one of those parties now.</p>\n<p>I squeeze through sweaty bodies and follow Kenya, her curls bouncing past her shoulders. I see a haze lingering over the room and it smells like weed. I feel music rattle the floor. I hear some rapper call out of everybody to Nae-Nae, followed by a bunch of “Heys” as people launch into their own versions. I watch Kenya hold up her cup and dance her way through the crowd. I have a headache from the loud-ass music and feel nauseous from the weed odor. I’ll be amazed if I cross the room without spilling my drink.</p></blockquote>\n<p>By removing many of the filter words and diving deeper into the character’s viewpoint, we end up with something like this:</p>\n<blockquote><p>I shouldn’t have come to this party.</p>\n<p>I’m not even sure I belong at this party. That’s not on some bougie shit, either. There are just some places where it’s not enough to be me. Either version of me. Big D’s spring break party is one of those parties.</p>\n<p>I squeeze through sweaty bodies and follow Kenya, her curls bouncing past her shoulders. A haze lingers over the room, smelling like weed, and music rattles the floor. Some rapper calls out of everybody to Nae-Nae, followed by a bunch of “Heys” as people launch into their own versions. Kenya holds up her cup and dances her way through the crowd. Between the headache from the loud-ass music and the nausea from the weed odor, I’ll be amazed if I cross the room without spilling my drink.</p>\n<p class=\"“attribution”\">— Angie Thomas, <em>The Hate U Give</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>Much better, right?</p>\n<p>So, to wrap up:</p>\n<p>If you find that too many sentences are starting with ‘I’ while you’re editing a novel, there are ways you can rework the sentences to avoid this – but if it seems like a deep-rooted issue, try to dive deeper into a character’s viewpoint (or encourage the author to in their revisions) and see how that changes things.</p>\n<p><strong>Want to learn more about becoming a professional copy-editor? Take a look at my <a href=\"/courses/\">online courses</a>.</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>You&#8217;re editing a first-person narrative and realise nearly every sentence starts with the pronoun ‘I’. It stands out, and feels repetitive and unimaginative. The first thing you&#8217;ll probably do is start to fiddle around with sentence structure. Here are a few ways you can quickly fix too many sentences starting with ‘I’: The quick fix [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"3rd February 2020","wordpress_id":1307,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M379%2029a4715%204715%200%2001-171%202h-2l-31-1h-30v5c0%203%200%204-1%203v-8H81v5l-1%205V30H17l-1%203c0%206-1%206-1%201l1-5H0v12h100l249-1h52V29h-22M269%2081v2l-1%202h-1c-1-1-2-1-5%203l-5%204h-26c-23%200-26-1-27-2a301%20301%200%2001-76%200%20347%20347%200%2001-74-8h-2c2%203%200%203-8%203L6%2089l-6%201v136h137a2031%202031%200%2000138-1l63%201h63v-65l-1-72v-7h-5c-5%200-9%202-11%205-3%204-13%204-16%201-2-3-7-4-7-2h-1c-1-1-2-1-6%201l-3%203%202%201h-5c-2-2-6-2-7-1-2%202-5%202-5%201l-9-1h-19c-13%203-13%203-13-1s-2-6-8-6l-4-1c0-3-2-2-2%201v2l-3-3c-3-2-3-2-3%200v3l-5-3c0-2-1-2-1-1m112%2045l-15%201%2020%201c4%200%206%201%206%202l-2%201%201%201c2%201%203%202%201%204v1l2-2c2-2%202%200%200%202%200%202-2%203-3%203l-1%201v1h-1l-1-1-1%202c1%202%200%204-4%208-8%207-13%2010-15%2010h-1l-2%201h-5c-2%200-2%200-1%202l-2%201h-3c0%201-10%203-18%203-23%200-46-12-57-30l-3-2h-1l1-1%201-2c0-4%203-5%2014-5%208%200%2010%200%209-1-3-2-39%200-40%202a85%2085%200%200099%2050c9-2%2026-11%2035-19l6-7v-14c0-14%200-14-2-14l-17%201m-184%202c1%201-1%205-2%205h-3l-3%202-5%203-15%209-13%208v7c1%208-2%207-6-3%200-2-2-4-3-4s-3-1-3-3c-1-4-4-3-4%201%200%203%201%205%208%2013%209%2010%2010%2011%204%2010-5-1-5%202%202%209l6%205c2%202%202%202%203%201s1-1-1-3l-3-4h1l3%202c2%200%202-1%200-9%200-3%201-5%2019-16%206-4%2010-8%2010-9l1-1v1l1%201c2-1%202-3%201-3l-2-1%201-1%201-1%201-2%201%202%201%202%201-3%201-2v-3l1-3v-4l-2-5-1-2-1%201m20%200v1l1%204%202%204%201%203%202%201c3%200%202%201-3%203-7%202-8%204-4%207l2%204a564%20564%200%200123-10c1%201-2%204-10%209l-10%207%202%203c0%203%201%202%2010-4%203-3%206-5%205-6l2-3h1l2%202%202%201%202%202c1%200%202-3%200-3l-5-9c-4-9-3-9-10-5l-6%202c-1-1%203-3%208-5l10-7c0-2-1-2-13-2l-14%201m18%2035l-8%206c-1%201-1%201%201%203s2%202%204%201c3-2%2014-13%2012-13h-2c0-2-2-1-7%203'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/77044026d5eef013b94db5d65a27f273/f7fa3/avoid-starting-sentences-with-i.jpg","srcSet":"/static/77044026d5eef013b94db5d65a27f273/c96d8/avoid-starting-sentences-with-i.jpg 116w,\n/static/77044026d5eef013b94db5d65a27f273/12243/avoid-starting-sentences-with-i.jpg 232w,\n/static/77044026d5eef013b94db5d65a27f273/f7fa3/avoid-starting-sentences-with-i.jpg 463w,\n/static/77044026d5eef013b94db5d65a27f273/ce8db/avoid-starting-sentences-with-i.jpg 695w,\n/static/77044026d5eef013b94db5d65a27f273/87cea/avoid-starting-sentences-with-i.jpg 926w,\n/static/77044026d5eef013b94db5d65a27f273/b24a9/avoid-starting-sentences-with-i.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"My Single Guiding Principle as a Professional Fiction Editor","slug":"my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">I’m a professional fiction editor. And for me, there’s a single guiding principle behind every editorial decision I make.</p>\n<p>It’s simply this: I must be able to justify every edit.</p>\n<p>We editors adopt the same mantra as doctors: ‘First, do no harm.’ That means we should be careful not to – God forbid – <em>introduce </em>errors into a text. (Okay, it&#8217;s not as serious as accidentally cutting off the wrong limb, but still. It&#8217;s pretty bad.) It also means we shouldn’t accidentally change the author’s meaning. This is something Amy Einsohn explores in <em>The Copyeditor’s Handbook.</em></p>\n<p>I work with these thoughts at the back of my mind. But I work with my guiding principle at the forefront of my mind. With every comma I insert or every word I change, I ask myself: How can I justify this edit?</p>\n<p><strong>If the answer to this question is that it just ‘seems right’, this isn’t good enough. That tells me I’m being subjective, possibly imposing my own style and creative values on the author’s work.</strong></p>\n<p>But if I can explain the edit using a nuanced understanding of grammatical and stylistic guidelines while also considering the author’s intentions and voice, I’m confident in the change I’ve just made to the author’s text.</p>\n<p>If I needed to, I could add a comment to accompany every single edit I make to a manuscript, explaining exactly why I’ve done what I’ve done. Of course, I don’t do this – otherwise the manuscript would be overwhelmingly bloated with comments, and it would take me around ten times as long to finish a project.</p>\n<p>Even so, I will add a comment here and there if I think I’m making an edit the author might question. As well as that, I provide a ‘style sheet’ along with the edited manuscript, and this contains a summary of my editorial decisions.</p>\n<p><strong>Being able to justify every edit is what makes a good editor.</strong></p>\n<p>That’s why it’s so important to be a well-informed editor. Someone who knows the rules of grammar so they can make judgements on how and when these rules can be broken. Someone who has undergone <a href=\"/much-training-fiction-editor-need/\">training</a> and continues to enhance their skills.</p>\n<p>I’ve been teaching editing skills for a handful of years now, and the students that worry me the most are the ones that make extensive changes to a section of writing in which there were no objective errors to begin with. When making suggestions around restructuring sentences or changing the wording, we have to be able to articulate exactly why our edits are an improvement on the author’s original text. If we can’t (or if we’ve changed a huge amount of error-free text), this indicates that we’ve overstepped the line.</p>\n<p>After all, the novel doesn’t belong to the editor. It belongs to the author. And though we edit with readers in mind, authors are the ones we answer to first.</p>\n","excerpt":"<p>I’m a professional fiction editor. And for me, there’s a single guiding principle behind every editorial decision I make. It’s simply this: I must be able to justify every edit. We editors adopt the same mantra as doctors: ‘First, do no harm.’ That means we should be careful not to – God forbid – introduce [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"15th January 2019","wordpress_id":760,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M26%201c0%202-6%209-9%2010-3%202-13%200-13-2L2%206C0%204%200%204%200%20115v111h258l1-3c1-3%204-2%207%201%201%202%203%202%2022%202h21v-4c0-3-1-4-5-4-7%200-16-2-18-4-3-2-2-4%201-4%204%200%204-1%202-3-4-2-3-12%201-16%204-5%207-13%209-24%201-8%203-11%206-16%207-9%206-77-1-85l-1-3-5-8-2-4-4-7-11-18c-7-11-8-12-16-21l-4-5H143L26%201m93%2032c-5%203-7%209-5%2013%202%203%203%202%207-2s5-9%204-11-2-2-6%200m36%2013c-4%201-5%202-4%204l-1%203c-3%200-1%203%204%207%203%201%205%203%204%204l2%201c3%200%206%202%208%205%200%202%202%205%204%206l2%204c-2%200-1%206%202%2011%202%202%203%205%202%206%200%201%206%202%209%200%206-3%201-21-9-39-6-9-16-14-23-12m35%205l-3%204h3l8-1c4-2%204-2%204%200l1%201v1l1%201c1-1%201-1%200%200l6%201c4%200%207%200%2010%202%206%203%206%203%202-3-5-7-8-8-21-10h-7l-4%204m20%209c-2%200-2%201-1%201v3l1%203c1%201%202%202%206%202l8%201v1c1%201%202-2%201-5-2-4-11-8-15-6m16%2027a40%2040%200%200116%2054v1c3%202%207-10%207-22%201-9%201-9%203-4l3%202h1c0%203%204%202%206-1%204-6%205-15%203-19-2-3-9-3-13-1l-5%201h-4l-5-4c-6-6-12-10-15-10l3%203m-102%200c-5%202-5%203-2%206l2%204-2%202c-2%202-2%202-1%204l2%203%203%203%202%203%201%202%203%204%204%203%202%202c1%201%201%201%201-1l1-2%201%202%201%201%204%206%203%207%201%203c0%203%204%2012%205%2012v3c0%202%200%202%203%202%204%200%207-2%207-6%200-2-3-10-12-29l-6-12c-4-10-10-19-15-22h-8m-39%2021c-14%207-22%209-30%209-4%200-5%200-5%202s-1%203-3%204-2%201-2%206l3%2011%203%208c0%204%203%206%207%205h4l7%202c6%200%207%201%2011%206l4%202c5%200%205-1%201-7-3-6-3-19%201-27%202-3%203-5%203-3-1%203%201%205%204%205h2v3l1-2c0-2%202-3%205-4%208%200%208%200%208-3l-1-7c0-3%200-3-3-3s-3%200-3-3c0-4-1-5-7-5-5-1-7-1-10%201m92%2014c0%203%200%203-1%201h-3v8c4%2015%2019%2027%2034%2027%206%200%2017-3%2016-4l1-1c1%201%203-2%202-3l-1-3c0-2-1-2-2-1l-3%202-2%201%201%201c2%200%201%203-1%203-3%201-4-2-2-3%201-1%201-1-1-1s-2%201-2%203v4l-1-4c-1-3-2-3-8-3l-2-1-4-3-10-9c0-1-3-6-5-7v-1c2%200%202-1%202-2l-1-4c0-2-1-1-1%201-1%204-4%205-4%202v-4c2%200%201-2%200-2-2%200-2%201-2%203m18%200l-4%201-4-1v5c2%209%207%2015%2018%2018h1l-1-3c0-4-4-6-7-4l-3-1-2-2-1-2-2-3c0-1%203-2%204-1h3v-6l1-1h-3m-88%2016c-5%203-5%205-2%209%202%202%203%203%205%203%204%200%205%200%203%201-2%202-2%208%201%2011l3%204c0%203%202%207%203%207v2c0%203%200%203%205%203%209-1%209-3%201-19l-7-15c-3-8-7-9-12-6m124%2014l-1%208c0%202%208%2012%2010%2012%201%200%202%204%201%205l-1%202c0%202%203%201%205-1%203-4%203-9-1-14s-11-11-11-9l-1-1-1-2'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/bd8350f09891b5104834c71232d07589/f7fa3/my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor.jpg","srcSet":"/static/bd8350f09891b5104834c71232d07589/c96d8/my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor.jpg 116w,\n/static/bd8350f09891b5104834c71232d07589/12243/my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor.jpg 232w,\n/static/bd8350f09891b5104834c71232d07589/f7fa3/my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor.jpg 463w,\n/static/bd8350f09891b5104834c71232d07589/ce8db/my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor.jpg 695w,\n/static/bd8350f09891b5104834c71232d07589/87cea/my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor.jpg 926w,\n/static/bd8350f09891b5104834c71232d07589/b24a9/my-single-guiding-principle-as-a-professional-fiction-editor.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"Editing Semi-Colons in Fiction: A Guide for Line and Copy-Editors","slug":"semicolons-fiction","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">What is it about the semi-colon (;) that is so alluring to writers?</p>\n<p>Is it because it feels like a sophisticated punctuation mark – more advanced than a full stop or a comma – and therefore the mark of a sophisticated writer?</p>\n<p>It’s surprisingly easy to fall victim to the semi-colon’s charm &#8230; until they insidiously infiltrate a piece of writing to the point readers can’t help but get distracted by them. There is such a thing as too many semi-colons!</p>\n<p>There’s something worse than having too many semi-colons in a piece of writing, though, and that’s when writers use them incorrectly. Oh, the sheer audacity! The horror! *swoons in outrageous indignation*</p>\n<p>Ah-hem.</p>\n<p>Okay, it&#8217;s really not that big of a deal. Even so.</p>\n<p><strong>Considered use of the semi-colon creates clarity, rhythm and emphasis to a piece of writing.</strong></p>\n<p>With that in mind, here’s how to use the semi-colon.</p>\n<h2>1. Use a semi-colon to divide two closely related sentences</h2>\n<p><em>Butcher’s Copyediting</em>, the <em>Penguin Guide to Punctuation </em>and <em>New Hart’s Rules </em>all say the same thing about the semi-colon: ‘It divides two or more main clauses that are closely related or parallel to each other, and that could stand as sentences in their own right.’ (<em>New Hart’s Rules</em>)</p>\n<p>This is the most fundamental rule around semi-colons.</p>\n<p>Whatever is either side of the semi-colon must make sense as its own sentence. And you only want to use a semi-colon to connect sentences that are closely related, to draw attention to the relationship between those sentences.</p>\n<blockquote><p>Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Leo Tolstoy, <em>Anna Karenina</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">LP Hartley, <em>The Go-Between</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>She plants a fierce kick against the door; it leaves a dirty boot print but barely vibrates the heavy hinges.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Isaac Marion, <em>The Burning World</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>If you follow this rule, you can’t go too wrong. Yet there’s a bit more to the semi-colon than this.</p>\n<p>You may have noticed when reading the examples above that when you came to the semi-colon in the sentence, you naturally paused a little longer than you would have for a comma yet a little less than you would have for a full stop. In this way, a semi-colon can alter the rhythm of a sentence.</p>\n<p>That’s something to keep in mind.</p>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/coffee-and-clauses-the-art-of-line-and-copy-editing-fiction\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-1907\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"500\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-300x114.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-1024x388.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-768x291.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /></a></p>\n<h2>2. Use a semi-colon to bring clarity to a convoluted sentence (as the ‘super-comma’)</h2>\n<p>The first usage is mostly about suggesting meaning and creating rhythm, but the semi-colon can also be used to bring much-needed clarity to a long or complicated sentence.</p>\n<p>According to the <em>Penguin Guide to Punctuation, </em>this is the ‘one special circumstance in which a semicolon may be used to separate sequences which are not complete sentences.’</p>\n<p><em>New Hart’s Rules </em>says, ‘In a sentence already subdivided by commas, use a semicolon instead of a comma to indicate a stronger division.’</p>\n<p>Compare the following examples:</p>\n<blockquote><p>In East London, where the zombie infestation is at a critical level, the army, in spite of its most coordinated efforts, has been unable to extract the remaining citizens, and the people, starving, terrified and desperate, are themselves turning to cannibalism to survive.</p></blockquote>\n<p>Using a semi-colon in place of the comma that marks the biggest break in the sentence would allow readers to catch their breath and more easily separate the different points expressed in this sentence.</p>\n<blockquote><p>In East London, where the zombie infestation is at a critical level, the army, in spite of its most coordinated efforts, has been unable to extract the remaining citizens; and the people, starving, terrified and desperate, are themselves turning to cannibalism to survive.</p></blockquote>\n<p>The <em>Penguin Guide </em>goes on to say that this use of the semi-colon as a ‘super-comma’ is pretty clunky and should be avoided if possible. If you end up writing a sentence like the one above, recasting the sentence might be the more elegant solution.</p>\n<blockquote><p>In East London, where the zombie infestation is at a critical level, the army has been unable to extract the remaining citizens, in spite of its most coordinated efforts. Meanwhile, the people – starving, terrified and desperate – are themselves turning to cannibalism to survive.</p></blockquote>\n<p>If you find you’re using lots of semi-colons as ‘super-commas’ to try to break up your sentences, it’s probably a sign that you’re writing too many convoluted sentences.</p>\n<h2>3. Use a semi-colon to separate elements in a list where each element contains commas</h2>\n<p>This is another way semi-colons are used for clarity. ‘In a list where any of the elements themselves contain commas, use a semicolon to clarify the relationship of the components,’ says <em>New Hart&#8217;s Rules. </em></p>\n<blockquote><p>The most effective way to kill a vampire is by drenching them in holy water, water infused with garlic or petrol (and setting them alight); piercing their heart with a wooden stake made of oak, beech or yew; exposing them to sunlight, fire or holy images; or starving them of blood until they turn to dust.</p></blockquote>\n<h2>The Flexibility of Fiction (or How to Bend the Rules)</h2>\n<p>One of the best things about fiction is that we can sometimes disregard the rules in the name of style and effect. Fragment sentences? Why not. Sentences starting with a connecting word? Throw them in. They all have their place.</p>\n<p>And because fiction uses fragment sentences and sentences starting with connecting words (‘and’, ‘but’, ‘so’, ‘yet’, ‘or’, ‘nor’ and ‘for’), it makes sense that semicolons can be used to connect these kinds of sentences. It’s a kind of meta-logic. Broken rules within broken rules.</p>\n<blockquote><p>A pause; it ended horribly.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">F Scott Fitzgerald, <em>The Great Gatsby</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>Fog in the eyes and throats of ancient Greenwich pensioners, wheezing by the firesides of the wards; fog in the stem and bowl of the afternoon pipe of the wrathful skipper, down in his close cabin; fog cruelly pinching the toes and fingers of his shivering little ’prentice boy on deck.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Charles Dickens, <em>Bleak House</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>Where I would have been happily confined to my office, deep in the School of English with a view to the red brick wall of the window well, content to grub about in dusty corners, there is now this breadth of vision, this depth and freshness to each breath, this widening space; only her and the horizon.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Amy Sackville, <em>Orkney</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>The key, as with any time you break a grammar rule, is knowing that you’re doing it and doing it with purposeful deliberation. As always, keep in mind clarity, rhythm and emphasis when playing with punctuation.</p>\n<h2>Semicolons in Dialogue</h2>\n<p>Some people break into a sweat just thinking about whether it’s okay to use semicolons in dialogue. I used to lay awake at night worrying about this, until I realised it’s okay to be chilled out about these things. (I’m kidding – I’m never chilled out.)</p>\n<p>The argument against using semicolons in dialogue is that no one actually tries to deliberately convey a semicolon when they speak. That would be a bit weird. As well as that, a semicolon is more of a visual marker than an audible one. The cherry on top is that it can look a bit pretentious.</p>\n<p>AND YET.</p>\n<p>Even if you aren’t deliberately trying to convey a semicolon when you talk, the rhythm of speech still might be best represented by a semicolon over a comma or a full stop. (The length of the pause created by a semicolon is somewhere between these two punctuation marks, remember?)</p>\n<p>As well as that, you – as the author – might want to <em>highlight the connection </em>between two spoken sentences. And as for that cherry, well, maybe you <em>want </em>your character to seem a little pretentious (or educated or intellectual or …).</p>\n<p>Here’s a line of dialogue spoken by Dumbledore, for instance:</p>\n<blockquote><p>Lord Voldemort liked to collect trophies, and he preferred objects with a powerful magical history. His pride, his belief in his own superiority, his determination to carve for himself a startling place in magical history; these things suggest to me that Voldemort would have chosen his Horcruxes with some care, favouring objects worthy of the honour.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">JK Rowling, <em>Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<h2>When to Use a Semicolon and When to Use a Colon</h2>\n<p>Because of the flexible nature of fiction, some writers end up using a semicolon when a colon would be a more logical choice.</p>\n<p>‘A colon is used to indicate that what follows it is an explanation of elaboration of what precedes it,’ says the <em>Penguin Guide to Punctuation. </em>‘A colon is nearly always preceded by a complete sentence; what follows the colon may or may not be a complete sentence, and it may be a mere list or even a single word.’</p>\n<p><em>New Hart’s Rules </em>summarises that the colon ‘points forward: from a premise to a conclusion, from a cause to an effect, from an introduction to a main point, from a general statement to an example.’ And that sentence perfectly illustrates its own point.</p>\n<blockquote><p>My loathings are simple: stupidity, oppression, crime, cruelty, soft music.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Vladimir Nabokov, <em>Strong Opinions</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>These were rituals that were right and lasting: the lighting of pipes, the pale hands that moved knitting needles in the dimness, the eating of foil-wrapped, chill Eskimo Pies, the coming and going of all the people.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Ray Bradbury, <em>Dandelion Wine</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>If I loosed my eyes from my shoes, the gravel at my feet, or the chaos of ice at the shore, I saw what newborn babies must see: nothing but senseless variations of light on the retinas.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Annie Dillard, <em>Teaching a Stone to Talk</em></p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>There’s even more to the colon, but for now I just want to highlight the basic difference between semicolons and colons. In general, the semicolon links two closely related sentences whereas the colon indicates a deepening in meaning (in the ways <em>New Hart’s Rules </em>lists above).</p>\n<h2>If in Doubt, Use Sparingly … and Leave it to Your Editor</h2>\n<p>Semicolons can trip up a lot of writers, but I hope this post has shed some light on the rules around their usage – and when and how you can break those rules.</p>\n<p>I want to reiterate that semicolons (and colons) should be used sparingly in your fiction because if there are lots of them, they stand out to the reader and pull their attention away from the story. Obviously, that’s a bad thing.</p>\n<p>If you’re still not sure whether you’re using semicolons right, don’t worry too much. You could choose to not use them at all (lots of novels don’t contain a <em>single </em>semicolon). But, as always, <a href=\"/services/\">your editor will help you out.</a></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>What is it about the semi-colon (;) that is so alluring to writers? Is it because it feels like a sophisticated punctuation mark – more advanced than a full stop or a comma – and therefore the mark of a sophisticated writer? It’s surprisingly easy to fall victim to the semi-colon’s charm &#8230; until they [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"9th May 2018","wordpress_id":637,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M10%204c4%2031%204%2030%201%2034-2%201-3%204-4%206l-1%204h4l7%201-3%201c-8%202-6%203%204%203h10l-1%203v4H17L5%2059l-1-1-2%202c-2%200-3%205-1%206%201%201%202%206%200%207-1%202-1%204%201%204s2%208%200%209c-2%200-3%2042-1%2042l1-2%201-4c2-1%205-10%204-13V69l1-3h9c8%200%209%201%209%202%200%202-2%203-6%204-9%201-12%202-12%203h10c4%202%208%200%2011-5%205-8%208-9%206-2l-1%208c0%204%200%205-3%205l-2%203c1%201%200%203-2%204l-3%206-1%202a68%2068%200%2000-8%2016l-4%207-4%207-1%202-2%204c-2%202-2%202-1%203h13c10%201%2013%201%2035-3l29-5c7-1%207-1%206-7l1-5%201%203a3278%203278%200%20012-42c-2%201-5%2013-4%2017l-1%203c-2%200-2-13%201-16%202-4-5-10-12-11-6-1-4-2%206-4%208-2%2010-3%2011-8%202-15%207-30%208-30l2-1V5l-1-5H58v17a270%20270%200%2001-4%2038V23c-1-1-1-1-1%201s0%202-1%201c-1-2-3-20-2-23%200-2-1-2-3-2-3%200-3%200-2%206%201%204%202%2033%201%2034-1%202-6-3-7-7l-2-16-2-14V0H10v4m104%202l1%2017%202%2027c0%2016%201%2020%203%2019l-1-16-1-17c0-11-1-36-3-36l-1%206m33%206a3599%203599%200%20001%2045c0%208%200%208%203%209%204%202%2016%202%2017%200l-2-1c-4%200-5-8-7-49%200-13%200-16-2-16l-1%203c1%205%202%2045%201%2046-2%203-2-1-3-20-2-29-2-29-5-29h-2v12m205%200l1%2012v17l-1-3-1-3v3l2%204%205%202h-2l-7-1-5-1-2-1-2-1c-2%200-3%200-3-2l-1-3-3-1-2%201c0%203-2%203-18-2-9-3-11-3-15%203-2%203-3%205-2%207%200%202%200%202-1%201-2%200-2%200-2%202l2%203a175%20175%200%200030%208%2011259%2011259%200%200026%208c1%202-3%202-10%200l-3%201%203%201%201%201c-1%200-9-1-12-3l-2%201%204%202c3%201%204%203%202%203l-5-1c-4-2-9%201-10%204l-1%204h-8a317%20317%200%2001-56-4%20177%20177%200%200042%209l-18-1c-18-2-44-2-44-1%201%202%209%206%2019%2010s10%204-8%201l-20-5c-6-2-6-2-6%202s-1%205-7%202c-7-4-14-6-14-5-2%201-1%206%201%206l1%2013v12l3%201c13%202%2019%2015%2016%2033-1%205-1%205%201%204l2%201-2%201c-3%200-6%205-6%207l-3%204c-2%202-4%205-3%206l-2%202-5%202-2%203h2l2%203%203%203c2%202%202%202%201%203v3l2%202-9-5c-5-4-8-5-9-4s0%202%202%204l1%202c-2-1-5%202-4%204%200%201-1%201-4-1l-3-1%2014%2011v2a1402%201402%200%2000-40-29c2%200%202-1%202-4-1-5%202-6%2010-1%207%205%207%206%203%206-3%201-5%207-1%207l3%202%202%202v-1l-1-5v-4l3%202h3l1-3-8-7c-13-8-14-8-17-8h-2l-1-1%206-1c5-1%206-1%2010%202l8%203%204%203%202%201%203%202%204%201v-2l-1-2%202%201h2c1-2%201-2-2-2l-3-1%205-1c3-1%204-1%207-5l2-3h-3l-4-1%204-1c4%200%204-1%205-4v-2l-2-1%202-1%201-1-5-1c-6%200-11-2-14-6l-3-3v1c3%203-2%209-7%207-2%200-2%200-1%201s1%202-1%203v3c2%201%201%202-3%203-3%200-4%200-4-2l-4-2c-2%200-2%200-1%201%203%202%202%204%200%206-3%201-11%203-13%202-2%200-1%202%202%204l4%203c0%202-6%201-10-1-5-4-5-4-5%202%200%204%201%205%202%206l12%209%2015%2012c3%203%203%204-4%203h-3l2%203c2%202%203%203%202%204-1%202-1%202%201%202l2%202%206%206c6%205%206%206%203%206-2-1-3%200-3%201l1%201%202%201h5l72%201h73l-1-3c0-5-3-9-4-11l-2-3c0-3-6-8-10-8-3%200-1-4%204-7%207-3%2039-9%2035-6v3c-2%201%201%206%206%2011%203%202%204%204%204%205v2c1%201%201%202-2%208l-1%203-2%202-2%201-4%201-3%201%2027%201h27l-1-48V36h-4l-5-1h9V0h-48v12M31%203c-2%204-3%2054-1%2056l9%201h10l-1-4-1-5h-8l-7%201-1-9%201-13c0-3%200-3%201-1v-8c0-12-1-20-2-18m271%2035l-2%201-2%202c-2%203%200%204%206%205l5%201%2010%204%207%203%204%201%205%201%2010%203%2022%205c14%205%2022%206%2022%205l-3-1-9-2-23-7-3-1%203-3%202-2-2-2-3-2-1-2-1-2c-2%200-2%200-1%202h-1l-3-1c-2%200-2%200-1-1h-2c-6%201-9%200-11-1l-6-3-8-2c-3-1-12-2-14-1m-43%203h3l2%202v5l-4%201c-3%200-4%200-3%201l2%201h5l2%201%205%201%205%202%206%201h8c0-1-3-3-5-3s-2%200-1-2c1-3%201-3-1-3l-2-1-9-4-2%201v2c2%201%202%201%200%201s-3-1-3-2v-3c-1-2-3-3-6-3s-3%200-2%202M100%2063c1%204%201%205-1%208l-2%208-2%207a254%20254%200%2000-5%2039l40-6%2017-3h6l-6-3-10-6-7-4-7-5-5-4-4-2-2-2%202-1-1-1v-1l1-2-3-1c-4%200-8-3-7-4%201-2%204-1%206%201l2%201%207%203a494%20494%200%200058%2026v-2h-4c-1%201-11-4-9-5%202-2-17-12-21-10l-2-1-3-2-3-2-3-2c-3%200-8-3-8-5l-3-1-7-4c-1-2-8-5-9-5s-2-1-2-6l-2-8-1%205M12%2084l-1%207-2%209v6l1-1%201-1%203-4%201-4%201-3%201-2%201-1%202-2%201-1v-3h-9m2%2066l2%206c4%204%204%204-6%204H1v45l3%203c3%204%203%204%2015%2013l8%205h80l-6-5a799%20799%200%2000-66-58l-10-9c-9-8-11-8-11-4'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/51e562324182ae8e52fbd7e491c42571/f7fa3/semicolons-fiction.jpg","srcSet":"/static/51e562324182ae8e52fbd7e491c42571/c96d8/semicolons-fiction.jpg 116w,\n/static/51e562324182ae8e52fbd7e491c42571/12243/semicolons-fiction.jpg 232w,\n/static/51e562324182ae8e52fbd7e491c42571/f7fa3/semicolons-fiction.jpg 463w,\n/static/51e562324182ae8e52fbd7e491c42571/ce8db/semicolons-fiction.jpg 695w,\n/static/51e562324182ae8e52fbd7e491c42571/87cea/semicolons-fiction.jpg 926w,\n/static/51e562324182ae8e52fbd7e491c42571/b24a9/semicolons-fiction.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"How Much Description Should a Novel Have?","slug":"how-much-description","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">Description is the seasoning that flavours a story.</p>\n<p>It’s the smattering of details that prevents a novel from feeling bland. In the same way that just the right amount of carefully selected herbs and spices can bring a dish to life, the right amount of carefully selected descriptive detail can bring a novel to life.</p>\n<blockquote><p>Good description has the power to strike an almost musical chord of emotions, resulting, in the best of cases, in a kind of narrative trance in which the reader’s consciousness is buoyed up and swept along in the current of the story.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Tim Weed</p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>The words on the page is the only intermediary between what’s in the author&#8217;s mind and what’s in their reader’s mind. An author may have a clear image of the places, characters and details in their novel, but if their descriptions aren&#8217;t accurate, what the reader envisions could be quite different.</p>\n<p>Read: <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/improve-descriptive-writing\">How to Improve Descriptive Writing.</a></p>\n<p>If an author doesn’t write <em>enough</em> descriptive detail, the reader won’t be able to connect with the story at all – it will be too frustratingly hazy.</p>\n<p>But including<em> too much</em> description can cause the story to drag. The description slows down the writing – because the action must pause while things are being described.</p>\n<p>Because of this, the best course of action shouldn’t be to describe everything in as much detail as possible. Instead, the author should focus on a few interesting, meaningful details.</p>\n<p><strong>Good, effective description draws the reader into the story by allowing them to experience it through sensory detail. It also moves the story along and adds to characterisation. </strong></p>\n<p>Description is not meant to be filler, or a chance for the writer to demonstrate their extensive vocabulary. Good description has purpose.</p>\n<p>Authors should be encouraged not to think of description as an isolated part of their writing.</p>\n<p>That is, they shouldn&#8217;t be thinking, ‘Hmm, I need some description here,’ and then dump down a paragraph of description before moving on with the action.</p>\n<p>Let&#8217;s go back to the seasoning metaphor: description should be sprinkled throughout the prose.</p>\n<p>Just as you wouldn’t want to eat a spoonful of ground cumin, you wouldn’t want to read a page of static description. Sprinkle that cumin into your curry sauce, though, and it adds depth to the dish. Description sprinkled through the prose acts in the same way.</p>\n<h2>How to advise authors on how to balance descriptive writing</h2>\n<p>To prevent a story from stalling, authors can use descriptions that serve more than one purpose.</p>\n<p>They shouldn&#8217;t do the literary equivalent of saying to the reader, ‘Hang on a minute and come and look at this’ – at least not too often.</p>\n<p>Instead, encourage them to describe &#8230;</p>\n<ul>\n<li>the specifics of an object that becomes significant later in the story</li>\n<li>or a house in a way that reflects the character who lives there</li>\n<li>or an action in detail when they want to slow the pace</li>\n</ul>\n<p>&#8230; for instance.</p>\n<p><strong>Nothing should be described in detail unless it’s important – whether to the plot or the tone of the novel. </strong></p>\n<p>Take this description from <em>Dune </em>by Frank Herbert as an example. The description effectively portrays the gravity of this character:</p>\n<blockquote><p>Through the door came two Sardukar herding a girl-child who appeared to be about four years old. She wore a black aba, the hood thrown back to reveal the attachments of a stillsuit hanging free at her throat. Her eyes were Fremen blue, staring out of a soft, round face. She appeared completely unafraid and there was a look to her stare that made the Baron feel uneasy for no reason he could explain.</p></blockquote>\n<p>And here, Ray Bradbury in <em>The Halloween Tree </em>sets an ominous scene, creating suspense:</p>\n<blockquote><p>[T]he darkness took on a special feel because it was All Hallows&#8217; Eve. Everything seemed cut from soft black velvet or gold or orange velvet. Smoke panted up out of a thousand chimneys like the plumes of funeral parades. From kitchen windows drifted two pumpkin smells: gourds being cut, pies being baked.</p></blockquote>\n<p><em>Gormenghast </em>by Mervyn Peake is one of my favourite series of novels. It’s incredibly rich in vivid, original description that revels in making the reader slow down and deeply experience the fantasy world around them:</p>\n<blockquote><p>This tower, patched unevenly with black ivy, arose like a mutilated finger from among the fists of knuckled masonry and pointed blasphemously at heaven. At night the owls made of it an echoing throat; by day it stood voiceless and cast its long shadow.</p></blockquote>\n<p>(Don&#8217;t you just <em>love</em> that <a href=\"/write-powerful-metaphors/\">metaphor</a> of the tower being an echoing throat?)</p>\n<p>How much and what kind of description an author includes in their novel will depend on the kind of writer they are and the kind of story they’re writing. Even so, they need to consider <em>how</em> descriptive their writing should be, and <em>where</em> the most detail should be included, in order to help readers accurately envision their story.</p>\n<p>As an editor, you can help them do this.</p>\n","excerpt":"<p>Description is the seasoning that flavours a story. It’s the smattering of details that prevents a novel from feeling bland. In the same way that just the right amount of carefully selected herbs and spices can bring a dish to life, the right amount of carefully selected descriptive detail can bring a novel to life. [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"9th April 2018","wordpress_id":635,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M0%2015c0%2014%200%2014%202%2012%202-5%202-3%200%203-2%204-2%206-2%2016l1%2011%202-5c12-22%2015-23%204-1L0%2066v12l1%2012%205-10%2011-23c11-22%2010-22%2011-20l-1%204-2%202L6%2085c-5%2010-6%2012-6%2017s0%205%203%204c3%200%203%200%200%205-3%203-4%206-2%206v1c-2%200-1%2011%201%2012h2l-2%203-2%207v2l2-2%204-7%202-4%203%202%205%204%204%201-10%2018c-2%202-3%202-2-2%200-1%200-2-2-2-6-2-6-1-6%205%200%204%200%205%202%205l2%202c1%202-1%206-2%206-2%200-2%204-2%2029v29h401v-79c0-82%200-89-3-86v8a237%20237%200%2001-36-13c-3-1-3-1-2-3%202-3%203-3%203%200%201%203%207%203%2010%200%203-4-2-9-6-6l-3%201c-1-2%203-4%206-4l30%2011c1%201%201-11%201-27V0h-12l-11%201h-1l-23-1%201%202%209%2013c-1%201-4-1-5-4l-4-7-3-4H0v15m38%2029a547%20547%200%2000-19%2052l6-14%206-14a1336%201336%200%20017-24m149%206a193%20193%200%20004%2038l-1-25c-2-22-3-27-3-13m29-4c0%208%203%2027%205%2039l1%209-1-14c0-13-4-38-6-40l1%206M51%2050a1114%201114%200%2001-24%2068l2-4%208-18a767%20767%200%200014-46m121%2026c0%2040%200%2039-1%2037l-4-2c-2%201-3%2010-1%2010%201%200%202-1%201-2%200-3%203-3%204%200l1%203v-3c0-2%200-2%202-1l2%203c0%202%200%202%201%201s0-4-1-6a400%20400%200%2000-3-72l-1%2032m29-23l2%2020a206%20206%200%20012%2024l-1-37c-2-15-3-16-3-7m-95-3a596%20596%200%2000-13%2056l-3%2014-2%206h3l6%201c3%202%203%202%204-4%202-4%202-6%201-7-2-2-4%200-5%204%200%204-1%205-3%205s-2-1%202-20a467%20467%200%200010-55m40%202l-3%208c-1%203-2%204-1%206%201%203%200%2019-2%2037a278%20278%200%2000-3%2018l-1-3c0-3%200-4-2-4s-2%201-2%203c0%204-1%206-3%206-1%200-1%201%201%203l2%203%204%203%203%203v-10l4%201c2%200%203%200%203-2%200-3%206%200%207%204l1%204c1%202-4%204-5%202-1-3-3-2-3%200l-2%202-1%2010c1%209%202%2013%203%2011h3l2-2c0-2%201-2%204-1%203%202%206%200%206-4%200-5-3-21-4-20-1%202-3-1-3-5-1-3%200-4%202-2l1-1c1-2%200-3-1-3s-2-1-2-3c-1-4-4-4-5%201%200%202-1%203-2%203l-4%202-2%201v-6l4-30a319%20319%200%20001-35m-70%205a415%20415%200%2000-15%2048l-5%2016-2%202c-3%200-5%203-5%206h1c1-1%202-2%203-1%202%200%202%200%202-2-1-2-1-2%203-1l6%202c1%201%201%201%201-1%200-1-1-2-4-2s-3-1-3-2l8-25c12-35%2018-61%2010-40m-11-6a419%20419%200%2000-16%2045l-4%209-3%209-1%205-1%203v1l4-8a813%20813%200%200021-64m26%206a354%20354%200%2000-11%2042l-5%2023-1%203-2%201%203%201%202%202c0%203%202%203%202%200%201-2%200-3-1-4l-2-2a1941%201941%200%200015-66m28-4l-2%204c-2%203-2%205-3%2010l-1%2014a807%20807%200%2000-4%2045l7%201c2%202%203%201%203-2l-1-5c0-4-1-4-3-1%200%202-2%203-3%203h-3l1-6a312%20312%200%20017-40%20898%20898%200%20012-23m12%2011a615%20615%200%2000-6%2069c2-1%202-1%201-4-1-4%200-17%202-32a418%20418%200%20003-33m226-6l2%201%201%201%201%201%203%202c1%202%200%202-2%201-1-2-5-3-4-1v1c-2%201-1%204%200%204l2-1c1-2%204%200%204%202l-1%202-1-1-1-1-1%201c1%201%200%202-1%203l6%203c7%203%208%203%206%201v-2l1-3%204-2%203-1h1c1%200%201%201-1%204l-2%204%207-7%202-2c2-1%202-1-1-1l-5-1-4-2-18-7-1%201m-19%2013l2%202c1%200%202%204%201%205l-3-1-4-1%201%201%202%203c1%202%201%202-2%202l-5-2c-5-1-1%202%204%205a9146%209146%200%200121%209c-2-2-1-7%200-7%201%201%203%200%203-2%202-2%204-3%209%200%204%201%205%203%203%206-1%200-1%202%201%205%203%206%202%207-3%204-6-2-6-1%200%202l5%203c1%202%203%201%206-3%205-5%206-9%204-10a484%20484%200%2000-45-21m-50%207c0%204%200%205-2%207l-1%202%201%201%202%203c4%202%204%203%201%203-3%201-9-4-15-12-4-4-5-4-7-4-4%202-4%203%200%204%206%201%209%204%206%207l-2%205c0%202%200%203-2%203-1%200-2%200-1-1%200-3-1-3-3-1s-1%203%2012%2015l15%2015%208-2h6c0%202%202%201%202%200%200-3%201-2%206%203%207%205%207%205%2014-1l6-6-6-5a417%20417%200%2000-32-28l-2-2-1-1-4-10-1%205m107-3l-1%202-2%203c-2%205%204%2013%207%209V74c-2-1-3-1-4%201m-75%2014l-7%204c-3%200-3%200-1%201l6%205%2012%209%201-3c0-2%201-3%203-4l2-2%204-1h4l-3-2-17-11-4%204M190%2099c0%208%200%209-2%209l-3%202-2%204-2%202h4c4-1%205-1%205%201l1-1c0-2%201-3%203-3h4c1-1-2-4-4-4-1%200-2-3-2-11l-1-7c-1-1-1%202-1%208m157%208c-2%201-2%202%200%204l1%203h-5c-6-1-6-1-1%203%205%203%207%203%2014-4%203-4%203-4%202-6-2-1-2-1-4%201l-2%203v-3l-2-2c-2-1-1-1-3%201m-90%208l-7%204%202%205%205%206h3l3-1%201-1v-2l-1-1%202-2%203-3-2-3c-3-6-4-7-9-2m54-3c-2%202%203%207%207%207l2%201-2%201c-3-1-3-1-3%201s3%204%206%204%203%200%202-3c0-2%200-4%202-6%203-2%201-4-3-3-2%201-3%201-3-1-1-2-1-2-2-1h-6m-96%203v5l-1%204%201%202-4%202-2-1c1-2-1-2-2%200-1%201-1%202%201%206%203%207%204%208%208%206l8-3c6-2%206-1%203-5l-6-10c-5-9-4-9-6-6m17%202l1%202c2%201%202%202%202%203h-7c-3%200-3%200%200%205a190%20190%200%20018%2012l3-4c3-2%203-2%205%200h1l1-2%202-1h2c2%201%200-3-4-9l-4-5c-2-3-5-2-4%201%200%202-1%201-4-1l-2-1m-36%202v3c3%201-2%206-5%205l-1%201h-2c-2%200-2%200-1%202l2%207%202%206c1%203%201%203%205%201l4-1%202-1%203-1c2%200%202%201%204%207l1%204c1%200%202%201%201%203l-1%201c-1-2-2-1-1%201%200%203%200%203-2%202l-3-2c-1-3-5%200-6%205%200%205%201%206%2011%202l8-3-1-3c-1-2-2-5-4-6-2-3-4-7-2-7%201%200-6-17-10-22-4-6-4-5-4-4m-157%208c-2%201-2%202-2%204v3h-2l-2%201c-1%200-2%200-1%201l1%202-1%202h-1c-1%202-4%200-6-4l-1-3-2%203c-4%209-6%2014-4%2013h1l-1%201v1c1%203%203%201%203-2l1-4h1l2%201%204%202h-2c-2%200-3%200-2%201%200%201%200%202-2%203v2c4%201-4%207-9%207-2%200-3%200-2%203%200%202%200%202-2%202-1-1-2%200-3%201%200%203%201%204%204%204l7%202%204%201%203-7%2016-34c2-4%200-8-2-6m134%202c-1%201%200%202%201%202l1%203h-3c-1%201-2%200-4-1-4-3-4-3-3%205%202%2014%202%2015%204%2014l2%202%203%204c2%200%201-2-1-3v-4c2-2%204-1%205%205l2%205v-8l1%202c1-1%203%205%202%206l1%201%201%201c0%202-3%201-4-1-1-3-1-2-1%202-1%201%200%202%201%202l3%201-2%201-3%201c-1%201%201%201%204%201%205%200%205-1%203-2-2-2-2-2-1-3h1l2%201v-3l-2-8c-2-13-4-20-6-21%200-2-1-2-1-1l-1%201-1-1-1-2-2-2-1-2v2m-115%203l-1%202c1%201%200%203-1%203-2%202-3%202-5%200-2-3-3-3-2%200%200%202%200%202-2%202l-3%201-6%2014a186%20186%200%200014%203c4%201%2011-22%209-24l-3-1m55%200h-3l-2%201%202%201c4%200%205%203%202%204l-6%201-4-1v5a1078%201078%200%20010%2013c2-1%203%200%203%201h2v-1c-2-1-1-2%201-1l2%202h1c2-3%203-2%202%201v9h1l-1%201-1%203c1%202%200%203-5%201-2%200-2-5%200-8l1-2-3%203-4%204c-3%200-4%202-3%207v3h8c10-1%2010-1%209-12l1-10%202-13c0-6%200-11-1-10l-1%202-1-1v-2c-1-2-2-2-2-1m-20%202v4c-1%202-1%202-4%201-3-2-3-2-3%200s0%202-2%202c-2-1-3%201-3%205l-1%207-1%204h12c5%200%205%200%206-4l1-10%202-7-3-2h-4m187%202l-2%201h-1l-1%201c-4-1-8%209-5%2011%203%200%2016-9%2015-11-1-4-5-6-6-2m-144%200l-1%202c0%202-1%202-3%202l-4%201-2-1c0-3-1-2-3%200l-1%2017c0%2020%200%2019%208%2019h9l1-17-1-21c0-2-2-3-3-2m93%202l-8%203-7%204%208%2016%2015-5c2-1%202-1-3-10-4-9-4-10-5-8m-166%203l-1%207c-4%207-4%208-3%209l8%201h8l1-4%202-8c2-6%201-6-4-6l-6-1c-2-2-4-1-5%202m193%202v3l-3%203c-3%202-6%203-7%202-1-2-3%201-2%203s6%202%209%200l5-1c3%200%204-1%204-3%200-3-4-8-6-7m-98%2018l1%204%201%202v1h-5l-2-2c-3-1-3-1-3%201l1%201h1l-1%201c-1%201-1%201%201%201l-2%201c-3%200-4%201-4%203l1%202%2017-3c1-2-4-17-5-17l-1%205m-101%202v3l-2%206c-3%204-2%206%202%206l8%201c5%202%205%202%205-2l2-6v-3c-1-1-3%200-3%202h-2l-2-1-4%201c-3%200-3%200-3-3%201-4%200-7-1-4m31%205c0%202%200%202-5%202-6-1-8%200-8%204%200%203%200%203%207%203%2011%201%2011%201%2011-3%200-2%200-3-2-4l-2-2c-1-2-1-2-1%200m-43%201l-6%201c-6%200-8%201-8%203l13%203c3%200%204%200%205-3v-5c0-2-4-1-4%201'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/8a06cd8b79e245bb532cdce52f2ac5c1/f7fa3/how-much-description.jpg","srcSet":"/static/8a06cd8b79e245bb532cdce52f2ac5c1/c96d8/how-much-description.jpg 116w,\n/static/8a06cd8b79e245bb532cdce52f2ac5c1/12243/how-much-description.jpg 232w,\n/static/8a06cd8b79e245bb532cdce52f2ac5c1/f7fa3/how-much-description.jpg 463w,\n/static/8a06cd8b79e245bb532cdce52f2ac5c1/ce8db/how-much-description.jpg 695w,\n/static/8a06cd8b79e245bb532cdce52f2ac5c1/87cea/how-much-description.jpg 926w,\n/static/8a06cd8b79e245bb532cdce52f2ac5c1/b24a9/how-much-description.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"How to Edit Metaphors: A Guide for Line and Copy-Editors","slug":"write-powerful-metaphors","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">Metaphors are powerful weapons in an author&#8217;s writing arsenal. (See what I did there? That was a metaphor.)</p>\n<p>A thoughtfully written metaphor used in just the right place will help a writer create vivid, original prose – the kind that makes readers sigh in blissful appreciation.</p>\n<blockquote><p>Metaphors have a way of holding the most truth in the least space.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\">Orson Scott Card</p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>Truth is at the heart of a good metaphor. Metaphors shouldn’t make a piece of writing unnecessarily obtuse. Instead, metaphors should make complex or unfamiliar concepts <em>easier to understand</em> by connecting them to something more familiar. In this way, the writing should be more concise because writers don’t have to spend time explaining something.</p>\n<p>Examples of great metaphors in fiction:</p>\n<blockquote><p>Time has not stood still. It has washed over me, washed me away, as if I’m nothing more than a woman of sand, left by a careless child too near the water.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\"><em>The Handmaid’s Tale</em>, Margaret Atwood</p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>She was the third beer. Not the first one, which the throat receives with almost tearful gratitude; nor the second, that confirms and extends the pleasure of the first. But the third, the one you drink because it’s there, because it can’t hurt, and because what difference does it make?</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\"><em>Song of Solomon</em>, Toni Morrison</p>\n</blockquote>\n<blockquote><p>She herself is a haunted house. She does not possess herself; her ancestors sometimes come and peer out of the windows of her eyes and that is very frightening.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\"><em>The Bloody Chamber and Other Stories,</em> Angela Carter</p>\n</blockquote>\n<h2><a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/coffee-and-clauses-the-art-of-line-and-copy-editing-fiction\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-1907\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"500\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-300x114.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-1024x388.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2020/02/LEARN-PROFESSIONAL-EDITING1-768x291.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /></a></h2>\n<h2>Reasons for writers to use metaphors</h2>\n<h3>Metaphors create a shortcut to understanding</h3>\n<p>The qualities of the metaphor can be quickly and easily applied to the thing the metaphor is describing, without the need for those qualities to be explicitly stated. This makes a piece of writing delightfully succinct and concentrates meaning. The metaphor &#8216;love is a thorny rose&#8217; is not difficult to understand: it suggests that love it beautiful but has the hidden potential for pain.</p>\n<h3>Metaphors can surprise the brain, which in turn leads to delight</h3>\n<p>The key to keeping readers interested is by continuously smashing apart expectation. Usually, we think of originality and defying convention in terms of plot or character, but word choice is ripe with potential in this regard. By pairing two unexpected images (as long as they make sense together), a writer can interrupt the reader’s expected train of thought and make them sit up and pay attention, and there’s a natural delight in discovering something new.</p>\n<h3>Metaphors deepen the reading experience</h3>\n<p>Something that makes reading (rather than other forms of storytelling like movies) unique is that it has the potential to engage the imagination so intensely that readers <em>experience</em> a story rather than consume it passively. Invoking sensory detail is one of the best ways a writer can do this. Pairing metaphor with sensory detail amplifies this effect. It makes the reader <em>feel. </em></p>\n<h2>Similes vs Metaphors</h2>\n<p>It’s easy to confuse similes and metaphors. A simile tells us something is <em>similar </em>to<em> </em>something else. The words ‘like’ or ‘as’ are used. A metaphor, on the other hand, tells us something <em>is </em>something else. It implies a much stronger connection and can therefore be more powerful.</p>\n<ul>\n<li>‘Love is like a thorny rose’ is a simile.</li>\n<li>‘Love is a thorny rose’ is a metaphor.</li>\n<li>‘Her skin was as white as snow’ is a simile.</li>\n<li>‘Her skin was snow’ is a metaphor.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Can you sense the difference in tone? Similes are more grounded, whereas metaphors can be more lyrical. Metaphors can be amplified and extended more easily than similes, too. For instance: ‘Her skin was snow; she melted beneath my touch.’</p>\n<p><strong>Many new writers rely almost exclusively on simile to enhance their descriptions. But if similes become a writer&#8217;s main tool for creating interesting prose, the novelty wears off.</strong></p>\n<p>The overuse of the word ‘like’ becomes repetitive, and unintended repetition is poison to good writing because it draws attention to itself, which means readers becomes aware of the words on the page rather than what the words on the page are saying.</p>\n<p>It’s important to use any literary device sparingly.</p>\n<h2>Editorial considerations</h2>\n<h3>Is this metaphor needed?</h3>\n<p>If you&#8217;re editing a manuscript, look out for unnecessary metaphors or writing that&#8217;s stuffed with them. Sometimes authors overuse this technique because they feel it makes their writing more literary, and so you might find yourself suggested the writer remove some of their metaphors.</p>\n<h3>Is this a cliché?</h3>\n<p>Remember: the brain delights in the unexpected. Clichés are boring!</p>\n<p>Examples of cliché metaphors: armed to the teeth, bad to the bone, turn a blind eye, bite the bullet, the crack of dawn, burning passion, hammering heart, heart of gold, blood running cold …</p>\n<p>As an editor, highlight the overuse of clichéd metaphor and encourage the author to create more original and impactful prose.</p>\n<h3>Can this link to character and setting?</h3>\n<p>Authors should make sure the comparison they’re using in their metaphor is something familiar to their <a href=\"/know-this-about-point-of-view/\">viewpoint character.</a> This is a great way to build character and voice, too. For example, if a character is a chef, foody words could be infused into the metaphors: his face was a mangled plate of ham; she felt the singe of regret; blueberry bruises stained his skin.</p>\n<p>Also keep in mind the time period and setting of the novel. Metaphors like ‘the bowler-hat cave’ won&#8217;t work if the novel is set in Ancient Rome – I’m pretty sure they didn’t have bowler hats back then.</p>\n<h3>Is this a mixed metaphor?</h3>\n<p>A mixed metaphor is essentially when two unrelated images are used to describe the same thing, illogically combining different images or ideas. By doing so, the strength of both metaphors is diluted because the reader must work to sort out the comparative elements of both images. For example: &#8216;If we want to get ahead, we’ll have to <em>iron out</em> the remaining <em>bottlenecks</em>.&#8217; Help authors spot and untangle these!</p>\n<h2>Closing thoughts</h2>\n<p>Ultimately, editing metaphors is an exercise in judgment. The goal is to help ensure each one earns its place. Sometimes that means helping authors clarify and refine, or reach for originality and surprise. All this is to help deepen the reader’s experience rather than pulling them out of it.</p>\n<p>When a metaphor is precise, relevant to character and setting, and cleanly executed, it can carry an extraordinary amount of meaning in very few words. Your role as an editor is to help it do exactly that.</p>\n<p><strong>Want to learn more about becoming a professional sentence-level editor? Take a look at my <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/\">online courses</a>.</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>Metaphors are powerful weapons in an author&#8217;s writing arsenal. (See what I did there? That was a metaphor.) A thoughtfully written metaphor used in just the right place will help a writer create vivid, original prose – the kind that makes readers sigh in blissful appreciation. Metaphors have a way of holding the most truth [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"20th February 2018","wordpress_id":602,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M0%20113v113h97a1096%201096%200%2000100-2c-3%200-3-3-1-3%201-1%202%200%202%201l1%201%201%202c0%202%2028%202%2029-1v-7c-2-1-2-3-1-6v-1l-1-1%201-2c2%200-3-11-6-13-1-2-1-2%203-7%204-4%204-4%208-3%204%200%205%200%209-2l11-6c6-1%2012-4%2019-9a4196%204196%200%200135-23l23%209%2033%2014c12%206%2013%206%2020%206l8-1h4c2%201%202%201%203-1s2%202%202%2026l1-84V0h-35l-2%203-3%203-1-3V0h-54v8c0%207%200%208%203%209%201%201%202%201%201%202-1%200-1%202%201%202l1-2-1-3-1-4V8h9l9%201c0%202%2024%201%2024%200h1l2%202c2%200%202%200%202%203l-5%2011c-2%203%201%205%2017%206l29%204h2v56c0%2055%200%2056-2%2056l-2-1c-1-2-3-1-3%201h-5c0-2-2-1-2%201l-2%202-3-1-1-2-1%202c0%202-3%201-14-2-33-11-133-54-133-58%200-1%200-2%204-2%2028-1%2060-7%2060-10l2-3v-6l-1-7c1-3%201-4-2-6-2-2-3-4-5-11-1-7-1-8-4-8-2%200-3%200-3-2l-2-5-1-9-1-9-1-2-1-5c-1-4-2-4-6-4h-5l1%204c0%203%200%203-2%203l-8-2-6-3c0-2-6-2-126-2H0v113M117%203l-7%202-6%203c0%202%205%208%207%208s1%203-2%204l-3%201%203%201%201%202%209%204%201%201%206%201c5%201%206%202%204%208-1%202-1%202-2%201h-3l-6%201c-3%200-6%204-4%205l5%202c2%200%202%200%200%201l-3%203c-2%203-8%204-38%200a141%20141%200%2000-45%200L8%2047c-4%200-4-1%201%2023l5%2027c3%2021%204%2025%208%2031%209%2014%2011%2026%206%2040l-3%209-1%205%204%205%206%205%204%204c4%204%204%204%208%204%2012-2%2019-3%2028-7l6-1%201-1c1-1%2016-1%2020%201h4c2-2%200-3-5-4-6-1-5-3%202-3s8%201%209%205l1%203v-3c0-3%200-3%202-2l3%201h4l-3-2-4-2h-3l-4-1c-8-1-7-3%202-3%207%200%209%200%2012%202%204%201%206%201%207-1l-2-1h-2l2-2c2-3%202-7%200-7s-2%202-1%203v1l-1%201c-4-5-4-6-2-6h12c1%201%203%200%204-1l2-2h-2l-2-1-2-2c-2%200-2%200%200-2%201-2%201-2-1-2l-7%202-9%204-5%203v2c0%201-4%204-7%204l-6%204c-5%204-9%204-8%200%200-4%203-10%205-10%201%200%204-2%207-6l3-1%2014-12c0-4%2012-21%2016-22l3-4c3-6%209-11%2012-9l9%201h11c4-2%2018-31%2027-56l5-9%204-8c4-6%209-3%207%204l-1%204-2%207-3%2010c1%201-1%206-4%2012l-5%2012-3%204c-2%200-3%201-4%203-1%204%200%205%201%203l2-1v1c-3%200%200%201%203%202l5-1h10c4%201%205%206%205%2015v6l3-1c10-1%2014%207%209%2016l-2%204%203%205c4%205%204%207%201%2013-2%204-3%206-3%2012l1%206%203%201c4%201%205%201%2010-3a6514%206514%200%200161-39l-7-4c-6-3-7-3-6-5%200-3%200-3-7-3-12-2-18-3-18-5s-3-3-26-13c-12-4-12-5-13-11l-2-7-1-7-2-9c-3-3-4-7-2-10v-7c-1-3-1-4%202-6%202-4%203-15%201-30-1-11%201-11-48-16a7515%207515%200%2001-58-3'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/1e3333dd9490761785aeb9c20a026f7c/f7fa3/write-powerful-metaphors.jpg","srcSet":"/static/1e3333dd9490761785aeb9c20a026f7c/c96d8/write-powerful-metaphors.jpg 116w,\n/static/1e3333dd9490761785aeb9c20a026f7c/12243/write-powerful-metaphors.jpg 232w,\n/static/1e3333dd9490761785aeb9c20a026f7c/f7fa3/write-powerful-metaphors.jpg 463w,\n/static/1e3333dd9490761785aeb9c20a026f7c/ce8db/write-powerful-metaphors.jpg 695w,\n/static/1e3333dd9490761785aeb9c20a026f7c/87cea/write-powerful-metaphors.jpg 926w,\n/static/1e3333dd9490761785aeb9c20a026f7c/b24a9/write-powerful-metaphors.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"Does an Ellipsis Have Spaces Between the Dots?","slug":"ellipsis-spaces-dots","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">Does an ellipsis have a space between each dot (. . .) or should all the dots be together (&#8230;)?</p>\n<p>The short answer? Either is fine. But there&#8217;s a bit more to it than that.</p>\n<p>The ellipsis with a space between the dots is the format favoured by <em>The Chicago Manual of Style, </em>which says:</p>\n<blockquote><p>They [the dots] must always appear together on the same line (through the use of nonbreaking spaces,* available in most software applications), along with any following punctuation; if an ellipsis appears at the beginning of a line, any preceding punctuation (including a period) will appear at the end of the line above. If they prefer, authors may prepare their manuscripts using the single-glyph three-dot ellipsis character on their word processors (Unicode 2026), usually with a space on either side; editors following Chicago style will replace these with spaced periods.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\"><em>Chicago Manual of Style, </em>16th edition, 13.48.</p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>*You can create a non-breaking space in Word with <em>control + shift + spacebar. </em>(Different versions of Word may vary.) You’ll be able to tell you’ve created a non-breaking space if you toggle on the ‘Show all non-printing characters’ button, which is represented by a pilcrow (<strong>¶</strong>) – the markup will look different.</p>\n<p><a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/tea-and-commas\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-1917\" src=\"/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Tea-and-Commas-Blog-Ad.png\" alt=\"\" width=\"1320\" height=\"500\" srcset=\"/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Tea-and-Commas-Blog-Ad.png 1320w, /wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Tea-and-Commas-Blog-Ad-300x114.png 300w, /wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Tea-and-Commas-Blog-Ad-1024x388.png 1024w, /wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Tea-and-Commas-Blog-Ad-768x291.png 768w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 1320px) 100vw, 1320px\" /></a></p>\n<p>The single-character ellipsis has a stronger presence in <em>New Hart&#8217;s Rules, </em>which says:</p>\n<blockquote><p>An ellipsis (plural <em>ellipses</em>) is a series of points (…) signalling that words have been omitted from quoted matter, or that part of a text is missing or illegible […] They can be set as a single character […] and many word processors will autocorrect three dots into a single glyph.</p>\n<p class=\"attribution\"><em>New Hart&#8217;s Rules, </em>2nd edition, 4.7</p>\n</blockquote>\n<p>So both are correct! But it might depend on which style guide you or your client is following.</p>\n<p>Should there be a space <em>before</em> and <em>after</em> the ellipsis, though &#8230; like this? Or should there be no space&#8230;like this? Again, it&#8217;s a style decision. Either is fine, as long as you&#8217;re consistent.</p>\n<p>Personally, I think the spaced version is more readable, especially with the single-glyph ellipsis, so that&#8217;s the one I recommend.</p>\n<p>Keep in mind, too, that it&#8217;s important the dots always appear on the same line, so make sure you&#8217;re either using a single glyph or non-breaking spaces. Most importantly, consistency is key – always use the same style throughout your manuscript!</p>\n<p><strong>Want to learn more about becoming a professional sentence-level editor? Take a look at my <a href=\"https://www.liminalpages.com/courses/\">online courses</a>.</strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>Does an ellipsis have a space between each dot (. . .) or should all the dots be together (&#8230;)? The short answer? Either is fine. But there&#8217;s a bit more to it than that. The ellipsis with a space between the dots is the format favoured by The Chicago Manual of Style, which says: They [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"7th June 2017","wordpress_id":559,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M10%202l1%207%202%2015c1%2010%201%2011-1%2013l-4%203-1%202v4c-1%202-1%202%204%202s8%201%206%202l-5%201-3%201%207%201%2010-1h3V35c0-18%201-31%202-33%201-1%201-1%201%202v5l1%2021c-1-4-2%201-2%2012l1%2010%207-1h8l1%204%201%205H30l-1-4c-1-3-1-3-1%202%200%201-2%202-12%202H6l-1-4c0-5%200-5-2-4v2c2%201%201%205-1%206-2%200-3%205-1%206%201%201%202%206%200%207-1%202-1%204%201%204s2%208%200%209c-2%200-2%203-2%2021%200%2012%200%2021%201%2020l6-16c0-2%201-4%204-7l3-5%201-2v-5c0-2%200-4%201-3%200%202%201%201%203-1%204-4%203-5-2-5l-5%201v4l-3%2015-1%202c-1%202-1-1-1-21-1-19-1-18%2010-18%208%200%209%201%209%202%200%202-8%205-11%204-2-1-1%202%202%203%204%202%209%200%2012-5l7-7-1%204-1%209c0%204%200%204-2%205-2%200-3%201-3%203l-2%205c-2%201-3%203-3%205l-1%202-3%207-1%201-3%207-1%201-3%205-3%206-1%202-1%202-1%201c0%202-3%205-5%205l-1%201%201%201h16c10%201%2012%201%2034-3l28-5c6%200%208-2%208-4l-1-11v-3l2%209c1%202%201%202%201-3a952%20952%200%20001-38c-2%200-5%2013-4%2016l-1%203c-1%201-1%200-1-3v-6c-1-2%200-5%201-7l2-3-4-3c-3-3-5-4-9-5-5-1-4-2%205-4%208-2%2010-3%2011-7a3299%203299%200%200011-53l-1-5H59v7a702%20702%200%2000-5%2049V24l-1%202-1%201c-1-1-3-24-2-26l-3-1c-3%200-3%200-3%203%203%2011%204%2037%202%2037-6%200-9-8-10-23L35%203V0H22C11%200%2010%200%2010%202m104%203a485%20485%200%20003%2053c0%208%201%2012%203%2011l-1-15-1-18c0-16-2-35-3-36l-1%205m33%207a3599%203599%200%20002%2053l16%203c4-1%204-3%201-3-2%200-3-2-4-5a797%20797%200%2001-5-60l-1%203c1%205%202%2044%201%2046-1%205-2-1-3-19-2-30-2-30-5-30h-2v12M353%202l-1%2013c0%208%200%209%201%204l1-5v5l1%205%201%204-1%204-1%204c-1%204-1%204-2%203-1-2-1-2-1%200l2%203%205%202h-2l-7-1-4-1-3-1-2-1c-2%200-3%200-3-2l-1-3-3-1-2%201-1%202c-1%201-2%200-17-4-9-3-12-2-14%201l-3%205v4c0%202%200%202-1%201-2%200-2%200-2%202s2%203%2011%206l13%203%205%201%205%201%206%202%204%202%2010%203%202%201%205%201h-11c-4-2-6-1-3%201h-2l-6-1-3-1c-2%200%202%203%205%203l3%201%202%201c2%200%202%200%201%201l-4%201c-2%200-2%200%200-1h-3l-5-1c-3-2-8%201-9%204l-1%204h-10a338%20338%200%2001-55-4c-2%201%2019%206%2037%207l15%202h-9l-18-1c-20-2-46-2-44-1%201%202%209%206%2019%2010l7%203a185%20185%200%2001-39-8c-2-1-2-1-2%203%200%205%200%205-11%200l-10-3c-2%200-1%205%201%206l1%204%202%202c4%200%209%203%2011%207%206%2010%200%2020-11%2023h-10l-1-3c-2-1-2-1-2%201%200%203%204%207%205%205l4-1h4l-3%201c-2%201-3%202-2%203l-1%202-2%203c0%201-1%202-3%202l-4-1%202-1h3c1-1%200-1-3-1-4%200-4%201-4%203%200%203-4%206-8%205-1%200-2%200-1%201%201%200%201%202-1%204v2c2%201%201%202-3%203-3%200-4%200-4-2l-4-2c-2%200-2%200-1%201%203%202%202%204%200%206-3%201-11%203-13%202-2%200-1%202%203%204%204%203%204%204%201%204-2%201-4%200-7-2l-5-3v11a403%20403%200%200029%2022l4%203-6-1h-5l2%202%202%205c-1%202-1%202%201%202l4%204%203%204c1-1%206%205%206%206%200%204%201%204%2074%204h72v-3c0-4-2-9-4-11l-2-3c0-3-4-7-8-7-4-1-4-1-3-3%202-4%206-6%2020-9s22-4%2020-2v3c-2%200%201%206%205%2010l5%205v9c1%200%201%201-1%202l-2%202c0%203%200%204-2%204h-2l-2%201a866%20866%200%2001-4%201l26%201h27v-33l-1-113V0h-47v2m-53%2037l-2%203-1%201c0%201%205%203%208%203l4%201%2010%204%202%201%203%201%202%201%203%201%205%201%207%202%2035%209c6%202%2013%203%2013%202l-6-2c-8-2-19-4-26-7l-6-2%203-3%202-2-2-2-3-2-1-2c1-2-4-4-10-2-5%201-7%201-10-1-2-2-16-6-23-7-5%200-6%200-7%202m-42%201c-1%201-1%201%201%201h3c1-1%201-1%201%201l1%202v4l-4%201c-3%200-4%200-3%201l2%201h5l2%201%205%202%203%201%206%201c8%202%2010%202%209-1l-2-2c-5%200-6-2-3-4%201-1%201-1-1-1l-2-1-9-4-2%201v2c2%201%202%201%200%201s-3-1-3-2v-3c-1-3-6-4-9-2M101%2066l-2%205-2%209-2%206-5%2032c-1%208-1%208%2015%205l17-3h4l-1-5c0-4%200-6%202-9%202-4%202-4%200-4l-7-7-2-1c-2%200-13-6-10-6l3%201h2v-1l-1-3c0-4%201-4%209%201l7%204%204%202c4%203%2010%206%2014%206l3%202%203%202%2010%206c8%204%2013%205%2015%203%201-2%201-2-1-3l-3%201-3-1-5-2-2-3c0-3-12-9-19-9l-4-2-2-1-4-2-6-3-4-3-3-2-4-2-2-1-5-4-5-2c-2%201-2%200-2-4l-1-4-1%202m152%2034c-6%203-7%206-8%2012-1%2016%2019%2022%2028%209%201-2%202-2%204-2l2-1-2-1c-1%200-2-2-2-5-2-11-14-18-22-12M14%20150c0%203%201%205%203%207l4%203H1v45l3%203c3%204%203%204%2015%2013l8%205h79l-5-5a1408%201408%200%2000-87-71m149%2011l-5%201-3%202h3c3%200%205%201%2031%2018%2014%2010%2019%2013%2020%2012v-1c-2%200-4-2-2-3%201-1%200-1-1-3-2-1-3-2-3-4l-5-3c-3%200-5-1-5-3l-2-2-3-2-3-2-2-1-5-3-8-3-7-3m-2%209c-2%201-2%201-2%204%200%204%200%204-2%204h-2l2%202c19%2015%2039%2028%2040%2027v-2l-2-1-6-5c-6-4-8-7-3-4%203%202%204%202%204%201-1-1%201-4%203-4h1c2-1-9-9-12-9l-5-2-2-1%201%203-1%204h-2l-2-1c-4%200-2-6%201-7%205%200%204-1-7-8-2-1-3-2-4-1'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/5f06f811b2b323a514b54989798c7464/f7fa3/ellipsis-spaces-dots.jpg","srcSet":"/static/5f06f811b2b323a514b54989798c7464/c96d8/ellipsis-spaces-dots.jpg 116w,\n/static/5f06f811b2b323a514b54989798c7464/12243/ellipsis-spaces-dots.jpg 232w,\n/static/5f06f811b2b323a514b54989798c7464/f7fa3/ellipsis-spaces-dots.jpg 463w,\n/static/5f06f811b2b323a514b54989798c7464/ce8db/ellipsis-spaces-dots.jpg 695w,\n/static/5f06f811b2b323a514b54989798c7464/87cea/ellipsis-spaces-dots.jpg 926w,\n/static/5f06f811b2b323a514b54989798c7464/b24a9/ellipsis-spaces-dots.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}},{"node":{"title":"Why Most Grammar Guides Suck (and Where to Get Answers Instead)","slug":"grammar-guides-suck","content":"<p class=\"highlighted\">A little while ago I had the pleasure of seeing Professor Geoff Pullum, head of linguistics and English language at the University of Edinburgh, give a talk about grammar.</p>\n<p>Now I don’t know about you, but I’m wary of people talking about grammar. I feel myself tensing in anticipation of inaccessible technical terms and stuffy haughtiness. And I’m an <em>editor, </em>so you’d probably expect I love debating the finer points of subject-verb agreement.</p>\n<p>And I <em>am </em>interested in these things. Because I’m interested in helping people with their books, and writing that follows the rules of grammar and punctuation is more easily understood. And what’s the point in writing something if you don’t want it to be accessible?</p>\n<p><strong>Grammar is a tool we wield – used correctly, it whittles sentences into more beautiful shapes.</strong></p>\n<p>As an editor, I want to make sure I’m an expert in using such a tool.</p>\n<p>Which means learning about grammar because, believe it or not, I wasn’t born with an innate knowledge of the intricacies of the English language!</p>\n<h2>Where do we learn about grammar?</h2>\n<p>Lots of us learn the rules of grammar and punctuation in school. Unfortunately, a lot of what’s taught is wrong – or at least doesn’t look at the bigger picture. One of the most important lessons everyone should learn about grammar? How flexible it is. School often doesn&#8217;t teach that.</p>\n<p>If your job involves words in any meaningful capacity, you may have also read a grammar guide or two. <em>These can do way more harm than good! </em>Many are incredibly outdated, having been written more than a hundred years ago. As the originals go out of copyright, they get repackaged and republished by others as new guides – simply spewing the same old outdated nonsense.</p>\n<p>Because of the nuances of language and the way language evolves, this prescriptive stance isn’t useful. In fact, clinging with desperate authority to such ‘rules’ can not only make you look stuffy and pedantic, but it’s also a sign you probably don’t understand grammar that well in the first place. (Ooh, I went there.)</p>\n<h2>So how <em>do </em>we learn about grammar in a meaningful way?</h2>\n<p>In part, the same way you learned how to talk. We subconsciously and intuitively absorb many of the rules of grammar just by being immersed in language.</p>\n<p>Though there are some decent grammar handbooks out there, consulting them for all your grammar needs is not sufficient. We need factual investigation, not the opinions of famous men, says Pullum. Linguists are skilled at gathering the facts about language – and we can learn the same skills.</p>\n<p>Be observational, and investigate. With the internet at our fingertips and access to resources like Google Books, we can search for certain constructs and see how common (or uncommon) they are, simultaneously assessing the clout of the source – Orwell’s writing might be considered artful in a way a teenager’s blog about gaming memes might not.</p>\n<h2>Things to keep in mind &#8230;</h2>\n<p>If you’re an editor (or a writer or a teacher), there can be a lot of pressure to know the ‘right’ answers when it comes matters of grammar. We’re often considered authorities on such matters. Yeah – no pressure.</p>\n<p>So it’s completely understandable that you’ve looked for guidance from authorities who profess to have more knowledge than you – namely the stuffy old grammar guides I&#8217;ve been talking about.</p>\n<p>But I want to encourage you to remember the level of <em>optionality </em>and <em>variation </em>there is when it comes to grammar.</p>\n<p>Always remember:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>Comprehension is more important than grammatical correctness.</li>\n<li>Aesthetics shouldn’t be ignored – writing is an art, not a science.</li>\n<li>Often grammatical ‘errors’ are simply an informal style – so don’t overcorrect.</li>\n<li>House style is important to follow – though feel free to make your case against it if applying it weakens comprehension, aesthetics or style!</li>\n<li>Different readerships will appreciate and expect different levels of ‘correctness’.</li>\n<li>Some grammar and punctuation rules really aren’t up for debate – such as parenthetical commas needing to be in pairs.</li>\n</ul>\n<h2>Grammar books to avoid</h2>\n<p>Pullum declares the following books should be burned:</p>\n<ul>\n<li><em>Dictionary of Modern English Usage </em>by HW Fowler (‘Too old!’)</li>\n<li><em><a href=\"http://www.chronicle.com/article/50-Years-of-Stupid-Grammar/25497\">The Elements of Style by Strunk and White</a></em> (‘Lies!’)</li>\n<li><em>Gwynne’s Grammar </em>by NM Gwynne (‘Copies <em>Elements</em>!’)</li>\n<li><em>Simply English: An A-Z of Avoidable Errors </em>by Simon Heffer (‘Ignorant!’)</li>\n</ul>\n<h2>Grammar books worth your time</h2>\n<p>Pullum suggests all books with an evidence-based approach to grammar are worth reading. He highly rates <em>Butcher&#8217;s Copy-editing</em> – and since this is one of most valued resources in the editorial community, we editors can feel a bit smug about that.</p>\n<ul>\n<li><em>Butcher&#8217;s Copy-editing: The Cambridge Handbook for Editors, Copy-editors and Proofreaders</em> by Judith Butcher</li>\n<li><em>The Sense of Style: The Thinking Person’s Guide to Writing in the 21st Century</em> by Steven Pinker</li>\n<li><em>A Student&#8217;s Introduction to English Grammar</em> by Huddleston and Pullum (Hey, of course he&#8217;s gonna recommend his own book!)</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Instead of learning the rules to break the rules, it’s important to consider whether the rule is any good in the first place. Remember, not all grammar guides are created equal.</p>\n<p><strong>Does grammar and punctuation make your head spin? And yet &#8230; you&#8217;re interested in become a novel editor? Don&#8217;t worry, I&#8217;ve got you covered. Take a look at my <a href=\"/courses/\">online courses.</a></strong></p>\n","excerpt":"<p>A little while ago I had the pleasure of seeing Professor Geoff Pullum, head of linguistics and English language at the University of Edinburgh, give a talk about grammar. Now I don’t know about you, but I’m wary of people talking about grammar. I feel myself tensing in anticipation of inaccessible technical terms and stuffy [&hellip;]</p>\n","date":"23rd May 2017","wordpress_id":553,"categories":[{"wordpress_id":4,"name":"Line and Copy-Editing","slug":"line-and-copy-editing"}],"featured_media":{"localFile":{"childImageSharp":{"sizes":{"aspectRatio":1.7846153846153847,"tracedSVG":"data:image/svg+xml,%3csvg%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20width='400'%20height='226'%20viewBox='0%200%20400%20226'%20preserveAspectRatio='none'%3e%3cpath%20d='M0%20113v113h136l136-1c0-2%204-6%206-6l2-1h2l15%202c6%201%2010%204%204%204l-3%201%2051%201h52V0h-67v13l-1%2014-5%209c-1%205-3%209-5%2011a255%20255%200%2000-27%2032l1-3c2%200%206-10%206-12V52c-2-1-3-4-1-4l-1-2c-1-3-2-2-7%206-5%207-6%207-3%201%201-4%202-6%201-9l1-7a11507%2011507%200%2001-7%208%20796%20796%200%2000-17%2032v-3l-4%205c-5%206-14%2024-17%2034l-4%208c-1%202-1%202-1-1a309%20309%200%20019-47c-1-2-4%206-5%2011l-4%208%202-9%204-21%206-38c1-4%200-7-2-6l-1%203-1%202v4c0%202%200%202-2%201-1-1-1-1-1%201v6l-1%202-1%202-1%201-5%2018-2%207c-2%203%200-9%206-40l1-9-1%201-1%201v-2l-1-2-2%205c0%204%200%205-1%204h-1l-1%206-2%208V24c2-12%202-14-2-14a679%20679%200%2000-9%2078%201515%201515%200%2000-4%2052c0%203-3%203-4%200-1-2-1-2-3%202-2%205-2%208%201%2016%203%207%206%2017%206%2021a772%20772%200%2000-65-96%20539%20539%200%2001-28-40c0%202-1%203-3%201s-6-2-6-1l-1%202v3l1%202c-3-3-3%200%201%204%205%205%205%2012%201%2013l-2%203v9c-1%200-1%201%201%201v1l-2%202c0%202-1%203-4%200-5-5-10-8-10-7%201%202%201%202-1%202-2-1-3%200-3%201s-5%202-5%200h-8l1%202c2%203%200%204-5%202s-5-1-2%202l3%203h-5l2%202c4%204%200%206-8%205h-2c7%204%208%207%203%207l-2%201c1%201%200%201%200%200-1%200-2%200-1%202%200%202-4%205-6%203l-1%201-2%202%201%201c4%203%204%204%201%205-1%200-2%201-1%202l-2%201c-1%200-2%200-1%202l-1%201-1%202c1%201%200%202-1%203l-1%202c2%201%201%203-1%203v1c0%202%200%203-2%203-2%201-2%201%201%203l3%203h-3c-2%200-2%200%200%202%201%202%201%202-1%202-3-1-3%201%201%202%202%201%203%202%201%203l-2%201v3c0%202%200%202-2%202s-2%200%201%201c4%201%205%207%201%207l-3%202-3%202c-2%200-2%200-1%201%201%202%201%202-1%203l-1%202c3%200%202%201%200%203-3%203-5%207-3%207s3%202%201%202v1c2%200%201%202-1%202l-3%205-3%208h-4c0-1-1-1-2%201h-2c0-3-3-5-5-5l-2-1c0-2-6-4-9-3l-2-1%202-1%203-1-1-1c-5%200-4-12%201-17l3-2h5v-10a734%20734%200%20004-19c1%200%203-5%203-9%200-5%204-12%206-12%204%200%205-3%204-17a7017%207017%200%2001-6-94V0H0v113m312%2050c-3%202-4%203-3%204h2l2%202c0%201%201%203%203%203l2%204%202%201c2%200%202%200%201-2l-2-3-2-3c-1-1-1-1%202-1%203-1%204-3%202-5-3-4-4-4-9%200'%20fill='%23d3d3d3'%20fill-rule='evenodd'/%3e%3c/svg%3e","src":"/static/1715d5af9b4014dfa2eb5aa1fed434e4/f7fa3/grammar-guides-suck.jpg","srcSet":"/static/1715d5af9b4014dfa2eb5aa1fed434e4/c96d8/grammar-guides-suck.jpg 116w,\n/static/1715d5af9b4014dfa2eb5aa1fed434e4/12243/grammar-guides-suck.jpg 232w,\n/static/1715d5af9b4014dfa2eb5aa1fed434e4/f7fa3/grammar-guides-suck.jpg 463w,\n/static/1715d5af9b4014dfa2eb5aa1fed434e4/ce8db/grammar-guides-suck.jpg 695w,\n/static/1715d5af9b4014dfa2eb5aa1fed434e4/87cea/grammar-guides-suck.jpg 926w,\n/static/1715d5af9b4014dfa2eb5aa1fed434e4/b24a9/grammar-guides-suck.jpg 1560w","sizes":"(max-width: 463px) 100vw, 463px"}}}}}}],"page":1,"pages":2,"total":15,"limit":12,"next":"/blog/category/line-and-copy-editing/page/2"}},"staticQueryHashes":["1904826805","930678125"]}